If you’re searching for the best Mexican cuisine in Yonkers, you’re in for a treat. This vibrant city is home to a plethora of spots that serve up everything from spicy tacos to hearty enchiladas. Having tasted my way through many of these eateries, I can confidently say that Yonkers does not disappoint when it comes to flavor and authenticity. Each restaurant tells its own story through dishes inspired by traditional recipes and fresh ingredients. The aromas that waft through their doors beckon you in, promising an experience that extends beyond just a meal.
There’s something uniquely satisfying about sharing a table filled with colorful salsas, perfectly grilled meats, and zesty lime wedges. Whether you’re a taco aficionado or a newcomer to Mexican fare, Yonkers’ offerings cater to all tastes. Each bite transports you to a festive atmosphere that captures the essence of Mexico. So, let’s dive into a curated list of must-visit Mexican restaurants in Yonkers, where delightful surprises await at every turn.
1. Guapo Cocina Mexicana
Nestled in downtown Yonkers near the waterfront, Guapo Cocina Mexicana is a feast for the senses. The moment you step inside, the vibrant decor—bursting with bold colors and artistic flair—sets the stage for a dining experience that’s Mexican tradition with modern elegance. The ambiance strikes a perfect balance between cozy and sophisticated, making it ideal for everything from casual lunches to celebratory dinners.
What truly sets Guapo apart is its fusion of Cuban and Mexican flavors, a rarity in Yonkers. Their menu is a creative playground, but the standout is the Carne Asada Tacos—tender, marinated steak piled onto handmade tortillas with just the right char. Pair it with their Mango-Habanero Margarita, a sweet-spicy twist that embodies their inventive spirit.
For a taste of their craftsmanship, don’t miss the Mole Poblano, a rich, complex dish that showcases their dedication to authenticity. Whether you’re here for brunch or dinner, Guapo delivers flavor, flair, and unforgettable service.
2. The Taco Project
At The Taco Project on North Broadway, tacos aren’t just food—they’re a celebration. The vibe here is effortlessly cool, with a laid-back energy that makes you want to linger over margaritas and shared plates. What stands out immediately is their commitment to fresh, high-quality ingredients, transforming simple street food into something extraordinary.
Their Al Pastor Tacos are a must—juicy, citrus-marinated pork with pineapple, a perfect balance of sweet and savory. For something bolder, try the Crispy Fish Tacos, where flaky cod meets tangy slaw and chipotle crema. The flavors are bright, the textures crisp, and every bite feels like a mini vacation.
Don’t skip the Queso Fundido, a molten cheese masterpiece with chorizo and roasted poblanos. It’s indulgent, shareable, and utterly addictive. The Taco Project proves that great Mexican food doesn’t need frills—just passion, creativity, and a killer tortilla.
3. Plaza Garibaldi
Plaza Garibaldi is a family-owned gem that has been serving authentic Mexican flavors in Yonkers since 1998. Located on Nepperhan Avenue, this cozy restaurant is a go-to for those seeking hearty, comforting dishes that feel like home. The vibrant decor, complete with traditional music and colorful accents, creates a lively yet welcoming atmosphere perfect for any meal.
Start with the Chiles Rellenos, a classic dish featuring roasted poblano peppers stuffed with melted cheese, battered, and fried to perfection. It’s a masterclass in balance—crispy exterior, creamy interior, and a tangy tomato sauce. For something hearty, try the Carne Guisada, tender beef simmered in a spicy tomato-based broth, served with fresh cilantro and warm tortillas for dipping.
Plaza Garibaldi shines with its commitment to tradition and generous portions, making it a standout spot for casual, satisfying meals. Whether you’re grabbing takeout or dining in, this family-run restaurant delivers warmth and flavor in every bite.
4. Mexican Resturant Don Jose
Mexican Restaurant Don Jose is a hidden gem on Central Park Avenue, offering a warm and inviting atmosphere that feels like a slice of Mexico in Yonkers. The moment you walk in, the vibrant colors and lively music set the tone for a flavorful journey. This family-friendly spot is known for its generous portions and authentic flavors, making it a local favorite for casual dining.
For a taste of their expertise, try the Pollo al Carbon, a classic dish featuring grilled chicken marinated in a blend of spices, served with fresh cilantro and warm tortillas. The Chiles Rellenos is another standout, with roasted poblano peppers stuffed with cheese, battered, and fried to a golden crisp. Pair your meal with a refreshing glass of Agua Fresca, like watermelon or hibiscus, for a truly authentic experience.
Mexican Restaurant Don Jose excels at delivering bold, traditional flavors with a personal touch. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout, this spot is a reliable choice for satisfying your Mexican food cravings in Yonkers.
5. Tako Mexican Street Food
Tako Mexican Street Food is a vibrant taqueria on Central Park Avenue that captures the essence of authentic Mexican street cuisine. The moment you step in, you’re greeted by the enticing aroma of grilled meats and fresh tortillas, instantly transporting you to the lively streets of Mexico. This spot excels at delivering a casual dining experience that celebrates bold flavors and traditional recipes.
For an unforgettable treat, order the Tacos al Pastor, featuring marinated pork topped with pineapple, fresh onions, and cilantro. The harmony of sweet and savory is simply perfection. Another must-try is their Elote—grilled corn slathered in creamy sauce and dusted with cheese, delivering that authentic street snack experience.
What sets Tako apart is its commitment to quality and the casual but lively atmosphere. Whether you’re here for a quick lunch or a late-night snack, this spot promises a delicious taste of Mexico right in Yonkers.
6. Metate#2
Metate#2, located on North Broadway, is a cozy yet vibrant spot that brings the heart of Mexico to Yonkers. The moment you enter, the warm, colorful decor and inviting atmosphere make it clear that this place is all about tradition and flavor. It’s the kind of restaurant where every dish feels like it’s been made with care by someone’s abuela.
Their Carnitas Tacos are a highlight—slow-cooked pork with crispy edges, served on fresh, soft tortillas with a generous sprinkle of cilantro and onions. For something different, try the Chicken Enchiladas Verdes, smothered in tangy green salsa and melted cheese. The flavors are bright, satisfying, and deeply comforting.
What makes Metate#2 stand out is its authenticity and affordability. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout, this spot delivers a taste of Mexico that’s both genuine and memorable.
7. Rancho Grande Yonkers New York
Rancho Grande Yonkers New York is a vibrant spot on Central Park Avenue that captures the essence of authentic Mexican cuisine. The restaurant’s warm, inviting atmosphere and lively decor make it a great destination for casual dining. Known for its generous portions and flavorful dishes, Rancho Grande is a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
One of the standout dishes is the Fajitas, sizzling with tender steak or chicken, fresh peppers, and onions, served with warm flour tortillas. For a vegetarian option, the Vegetable Quesadilla is a must-try, packed with sautéed zucchini, squash, and cheese. Pair your meal with a glass of fresh horchata for a truly authentic experience.
Rancho Grande excels at delivering bold, traditional flavors with a modern twist. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout, this spot offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere and delicious meals that keep you coming back for more.
8. El Marinero
+1 914-423-1840
El Marinero, nestled on South Broadway, is a hidden treasure for Mexican cuisine lovers in Yonkers. This unassuming spot is perfect for those seeking authentic flavors in a cozy, no-frills setting. The moment you step inside, the aroma of freshly grilled meats and spices signals a meal that’s crafted with care.
Their Carne Asada is a star dish—perfectly marinated and grilled steak served with beans, rice, and warm tortillas. For seafood enthusiasts, the Camarones al Ajillo (garlic shrimp) is a must-try, featuring plump shrimp sautéed in a rich, garlicky sauce. Each dish is a testament to their commitment to tradition and quality.
What makes El Marinero stand out is its simplicity and authenticity. Whether you’re here for a quick lunch or a hearty dinner, this spot delivers flavorful, satisfying meals that feel like home-cooked comfort.
9. Tio Nacho – Yonkers
+1 914-476-4000
See Menu
At the bustling corner of Central Park and Yonkers Avenues, Tio Nacho – Yonkers serves up vibrant Mexican flavors with a welcoming neighborhood vibe. The restaurant’s cheerful yellow exterior and colorful interior create an instant festive mood, making every visit feel like a mini-celebration. What stands out immediately is their all-day Mexican breakfast – a rarity in Yonkers that keeps locals coming back.
Their Huevos Rancheros perfectly showcases Tio Nacho’s style – crispy tortillas topped with sunny-side-up eggs, smothered in rich ranchero sauce, with just the right kick of spice. For lunch or dinner, the Pork Carnitas shine – slow-braised to tender perfection with crispy edges, served with house-made corn tortillas. The Horchata here is particularly noteworthy, perfectly balanced between sweet and cinnamon-spiced.
Tio Nacho stands out for its consistent quality and authentic touches – from the hand-pressed tortillas to the family recipes behind each dish. Whether you’re craving breakfast chilaquiles or late-night tacos, this spot delivers genuine Mexican comfort with every bite.
10. El Poblano Cafe
+1 914-963-0062
Tucked away on Main Street, El Poblano Cafe offers a culinary journey through Mexican and Central American flavors. The cozy, no-frills atmosphere feels like stepping into a family kitchen, where the focus is squarely on hearty, authentic dishes. What makes this spot special is its blend of regional influences, creating a menu that stands out in Yonkers’ Mexican food scene.
Their Pupusas are a must-order – thick, handmade corn cakes stuffed with cheese and beans, served with tangy curtido slaw. For Mexican classics, the Mole Poblano showcases their skill with complex sauces, featuring tender chicken in a rich, chocolate-tinged sauce. The Chicken Tamales, steamed in banana leaves, are another standout – moist and flavorful with just the right masa-to-filling ratio.
El Poblano Cafe shines with its homestyle cooking and generous portions. Whether you’re craving familiar Mexican dishes or want to explore Central American flavors, this unassuming spot delivers authentic, satisfying meals that keep regulars coming back.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What are the best authentic Mexican restaurants in Yonkers?
A: For authentic flavors, try Guapo Cocina Mexicana (Mexican-Cuban fusion), Plaza Garibaldi (family-owned since 1998), or El Marinero (no-frills traditional dishes). Each offers distinct regional specialties.
Q: Where can I find good vegetarian options at Mexican restaurants in Yonkers?
A: Rancho Grande and Guapo Cocina Mexicana both offer excellent vegetarian dishes like cheese enchiladas, veggie fajitas, and chiles rellenos (stuffed peppers).
Q: Which Mexican restaurants in Yonkers offer late-night dining?
A: Plaza Garibaldi serves until midnight for takeout, while Rancho Grande offers late-night table service – perfect for post-work or weekend cravings.
Q: Where can I get the best tacos in Yonkers?
A: For standout tacos, visit Tako Mexican Street Food (try their al pastor) or The Taco Project (known for crispy fish tacos). Both use fresh, high-quality ingredients.
Q: Are there Mexican restaurants in Yonkers with outdoor seating?
A: Guapo Cocina Mexicana near the waterfront and The Taco Project both offer outdoor dining when weather permits.
Q: Which Mexican restaurant is best for large groups/family dining?
A: Plaza Garibaldi and Rancho Grande both accommodate groups well with spacious seating and family-style portions perfect for sharing.
