Craving something bold for dinner in Sugarcreek, OH? Mexican food around here isn’t just about tacos and salsa—though, let’s be honest, both deserve their spotlight. The village’s restaurant scene offers a surprising mix, from local favorites that know your name to national spots where you recognize every item on the menu. I once found myself weighing salsa choices at a Sugarcreek eatery debating between mild or spicy. The staff noticed my hesitation and slid over both, setting the tone for a meal that balanced flavor and friendly local character.
If you’re looking for great Mexican food without hidden surprises, you’re in the right place. I’ve tasted my way through these kitchens—some cozy and tucked away, others buzzing with chatter even on weeknights. These spots cover the classics and a few creative twists while keeping things on the right side of tradition. Whether you want a plate of enchiladas or a quick burrito fix, you’ll find something that fits. Let’s dive into Sugarcreek’s best Mexican restaurants so you can skip the guesswork and get straight to the good stuff.
1. The Nineteenth Hole Restaurant
Set beside the rolling greens of the Black Gold Golf Club, The Nineteenth Hole Restaurant brings a fresh perspective to Sugarcreek’s dining scene. The panoramic views here pair perfectly with conversation and a relaxed meal. My last visit included a sunset dinner, where you could actually taste the care the kitchen puts into each dish.
While the menu offers a variety of classics, I found their Mexican-inspired specials worth lingering over. Try the seasoned chicken fajitas or grilled steak tacos—both deliver bold flavor without going overboard on spices. Each plate feels as inviting as the atmosphere, making it a great stop for anyone who loves Mexican favorites with a homestyle twist.
2. El San Jose
El San Jose is a friendly spot where locals gather for generous plates and quick service, just a short drive from Sugarcreek. The atmosphere carries that laid-back comfort you want from a neighborhood place—always bustling, always welcoming. On my last trip, the staff greeted everyone like family, which sets the tone for an easy meal out.
What keeps people coming back? The salsa comes out fresh and zesty, and the menu offers more than your usual fare. The chicken enchiladas here are especially popular for their tender filling and bright, savory sauce. I’d also recommend the vegetarian quesadilla, packed with sautéed peppers and cheese, for its solid flavor profile.
El San Jose is made for easy-going lunches or dinners, and you always leave comfortably full. That’s consistency you can taste.
3. Tlaquepaque Mexican Restaurant
With vibrant décor and fast-paced energy, Tlaquepaque Mexican Restaurant blends lively atmosphere and authentic taste under one roof. The place hums with conversation, and the aroma from the kitchen invites you in before you even see the menu. I stopped by on a whim, hoping for something different, and ended up staying longer than I planned.
The real magic is in their tableside guacamole—fresh, customizable, and creamy every time. If you want a full meal, try their pollo asado. The chicken is marinated well and arrives gently charred, paired with seasoned rice and beans.
Tlaquepaque makes traditional Mexican comfort food approachable and memorable. Their friendly staff keeps everything running smoothly, whether you’re there for a quick bite or a long, relaxed dinner.
4. El Pueblito
El Pueblito delivers the charm of a local bistro with a Mexican twist. This spot in Dover balances friendly service and bright flavors in a cozy space. The colorful walls are as cheerful as the plates they serve, and regulars always seem to have a favorite table.
Last time I dropped by, the standout was their arroz con pollo. The chicken was tender and the rice perfectly seasoned—a comforting, no-frills classic. If you’re hungry for something to share, their fresh pico de gallo with warm chips is a table-pleaser.
El Pueblito feels effortless in its approach, giving you honest, satisfying food. Their easygoing style makes it a safe bet any day of the week.
5. Campesino’s Grill
Campesino’s Grill in Strasburg is a casual place where you won’t find pretense—just good food and quick refills. The menu brings a range of Mexican classics at fair prices, making it popular with families and anyone looking for a laid-back bite. One rainy night, I ducked in for dinner and left in a far better mood than I arrived.
The real highlights are their shrimp fajitas, sizzling and fragrant at the table, and the beef burrito, stuffed with just enough spice to keep things interesting. Portions are generous, so even big appetites leave satisfied.
Campesino’s Grill keeps things simple—no fancy extras, just well-seasoned, hearty Mexican favorites you’ll want again.
6. La Palma Mexican Grill & Cantina
La Palma Mexican Grill & Cantina sits right in downtown Millersburg, drawing locals and travelers with its welcoming vibe and quick service. Walking in, you’re greeted by the aroma of grilled vegetables and a bright, bustling dining room. I once sampled lunch here during a busy weekday, and the energy was contagious—so was the laughter over lunch.
Their chicken chimichangas strike a balance between crisp and tender, and the veggie tacos come loaded with just the right crunch. Each plate arrives fresh, a nod to their promise of daily-cooked food.
If you like casual Mexican spots where your order tastes homemade, La Palma delivers with style and consistency.
7. El Pueblito Mexican Cuisine
(740) 922-1888Call
El Pueblito Mexican Cuisine in Uhrichsville is a cozy spot where the food arrives fast and full of color. The dining room is welcoming, never too crowded, which makes it easy to settle in for a relaxed meal. On my last visit, the staff was quick with refills and genuine with their menu suggestions, which always adds a nice touch.
If you’re in the mood for something classic, the chile relleno will win you over. It’s stuffed, battered, and covered with a vibrant sauce that brings everything together. The chicken tamales are another highlight—steamed just right and full of flavor.
El Pueblito Mexican Cuisine brings comforting, simple Mexican dishes to the table, giving you exactly what you came for: a satisfying meal and easy conversation.
8. Taqueria Hernandez
(740) 229-7092Call
Taqueria Hernandez is one of those hidden gems where you taste the difference in every bite. This small spot in Uhrichsville draws in those looking for honest, unfussy Mexican food. My visit here started with the unmistakable sizzle from the kitchen, which only built up the anticipation.
The tacos are a must, especially their carne asada and grilled chicken tacos. The tortillas come soft, warm, and just chewy enough to soak up those savory fillings. If you want something substantial, order the chicken burrito—packed and piping hot, it’s comfort in a wrap.
Taqueria Hernandez stays true to classic flavors and portions that never leave you hunting for more. This no-frills spot gets it right.
9. The Pointe Cafe
The Pointe Cafe manages to blend upscale comfort with approachable dishes, tucked inside New Philadelphia. The space feels modern but never stuffy. My visit here included the pleasant surprise of punchy Mexican flavors on a menu known for variety.
Don’t skip the chicken fajita salad—it’s colorful, loaded with grilled chicken, crisp peppers, and a light citrus dressing that keeps it fresh. The veggie quesadilla offers a cheesy, satisfying crunch with grilled vegetables.
It’s a rare place where you could just as easily order steak as you could tacos, and both would be done right. The Pointe Cafe’s menu keeps everyone at your table happy, with a little bit of spice thrown in for good measure.
10. Taco Bell
Taco Bell in Dover is the place for a fast fix of familiar Mexican favorites, especially on nights when you just want quick, customizable eats. The drive-through moves at a decent pace, and ordering online is an easy skip-the-line bonus. I’ve swung by after a long day when only a no-fuss meal would do—and it delivered.
The go-to items are clear winners: a Bean Burrito for its classic flavor and budget-friendly price, or a Crunchwrap Supreme if you want a little bit of everything in every bite. Taco Bell also offers solid vegetarian options, making it an easy choice for groups.
For late-night cravings or a pit stop between errands, Taco Bell is reliable, quick, and always open for those who need it.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best Mexican restaurants near Sugarcreek, OH?
You’ll find quality options like The Nineteenth Hole Restaurant, El San Jose, Tlaquepaque Mexican Restaurant, and El Pueblito. Each has its own style, from cozy hideaways to lively, bustling spaces.
Do any of these restaurants offer vegetarian dishes?
Absolutely. Many places such as Taco Bell, Tlaquepaque, and El San Jose feature vegetarian-friendly options like veggie tacos, quesadillas, and burritos.
Can I find halal or haram-free dishes at these restaurants?
Most Mexican restaurants in the Sugarcreek area keep a focus on classic, non-haram dishes such as bean or veggie-based plates. Always ask your server for details if you have specific dietary needs.
Which restaurants are best for families?
Campesino’s Grill, La Palma, and El Pueblito Mexican Cuisine are all popular with families due to their casual settings and kid-friendly menus.
Are reservations needed?
In most cases, you won’t need reservations for these spots. However, calling ahead during busy dinner times can save you from waiting.
Is there quick takeout or delivery available?
Yes—Taco Bell, Chipotle, and several others offer fast takeout or online ordering. Local spots often welcome call-ahead takeout orders as well.