Searching for the best Mexican restaurants in Geneva, NY can feel like a culinary treasure hunt. As someone who’s dedicated an unreasonable amount of weekends to sampling salsa and debating the perfect burrito, I can say with confidence that this small upstate city packs a surprising punch. Geneva’s food scene is tightly knit, but the variety of Mexican options here brings more flavor than you might expect from its size.
I’ve zigzagged across Seneca Lake in pursuit of everything from spicy street tacos to crisp, golden churros. Along the way, I’ve found spots where the salsa tastes like sunshine and kitchens that use recipes passed down through generations. If you’re after fresh ingredients, bold flavors, and authentic experiences (without having to guess which places are worth it), this list will save you some trial and error. Let’s dig into the real gems for Mexican food in Geneva.
Where to find the best mexican restaurants in Geneva, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best mexican restaurants in Geneva, NY:
- Char Burrito Bar
- Taqueria Los Amigos
- Monterrey Mexican Restaurant II
- Taco Bell / Kfc
- La Reyna De Mexico
- La Fiesta Brava Mexican Restaurant
- Casa Mezcal
- Laguna Grande Restaurante Mexicano & Bar
- El Bajio
- D’s South of the Border
1. Char Burrito Bar
Char Burrito Bar sits right in the heart of downtown Geneva, but its relaxed vibe always makes my lunch break feel like a mini-vacation. The place sets itself apart with a simple idea: fresh ingredients, real flavor, and full customization. You get to build your meal just the way you want, with options for every taste and dietary need.
On my last visit, the staff greeted me like an old friend. I went for a rice bowl, loaded it with marinated grilled chicken, black beans, roasted corn, and topped it all off with their tangy house-made salsa. Vegetarian and vegan choices are just as tempting, with plenty of roasted veggies and zesty sauces on offer.
For a quick but satisfying bite, try the classic burrito or a taco trio. Each dish gives you a snapshot of Char Burrito Bar’s straightforward, fresh approach—bold flavors, generous portions, and a welcome that feels personal every time.
2. Taqueria Los Amigos
Taqueria Los Amigos feels like stepping into someone’s lively family kitchen. This spot is all about tradition, with recipes straight from Guanajuato that deliver rich, homemade flavor. Each visit reminds me why locals are quick to send friends here for an authentic meal—everything is made lovingly and you taste it in every bite.
The atmosphere is cozy and unfussy, but the food is anything but ordinary. I always find myself craving their street-style tacos piled high with tender grilled chicken or veggies. The fresh salsas and careful layering make every taco seriously memorable.
If you’re extra hungry, the enchiladas verdes are a must. The tangy green sauce and soft tortillas show off the kitchen’s balance of flavor and comfort. Go hungry, leave happy, and take a little of the abuela’s warmth with you.
3. Monterrey Mexican Restaurant II
Monterrey Mexican Restaurant II always feels like the place where generous hospitality meets standout flavors. The staff treats you like family, whether you’re dining in or swinging by for takeout. I started coming here for casual dinners, but soon found myself returning to explore more of their daily specials.
What sets Monterrey apart is its dedication to freshness—every salsa, every sauce, and every filling is made daily. The arroz con pollo and veggie fajitas are favorites, brimming with color and warmth. Their portions are hearty, so bring an appetite.
For a meal that lingers in your memory, try the enchiladas filled with tender chicken or mushrooms. Paired with their homemade guacamole, it’s a full-flavored experience that keeps regulars coming back.
4. Taco Bell / Kfc
Taco Bell / KFC in Geneva is all about quick options and familiar flavors. If you need a fast bite or a late-night meal, this spot delivers every time. The combo location gives you plenty of options, but the tortilla-based favorites are the main draw for anyone craving something from the Mexican tradition.
What I like about this spot is the consistency—no matter when I stop in, the classic bean burrito or the crunchy tacos hit the spot. The menu is always evolving, too. Items like the black bean Crunchwrap Supreme offer a hearty, vegetarian-friendly choice with lots of melty cheese and crisp layers.
Perfect for nights when you want something reliable and fast, Taco Bell keeps things simple and satisfying with a lineup that’s easy to customize to your taste.
5. La Reyna De Mexico
+1 315-936-1944
La Reyna De Mexico is a hidden gem just off the main street, tucked into a cozy spot that always feels welcoming. This place wins points for authenticity—every dish feels thoughtfully prepared, never rushed. The kitchen doesn’t cut corners, which you notice right away in the fresh salsas and careful seasoning.
On my last visit, the warmth of the staff stood out, but so did the food. I tried the vegetable quesadillas, filled with seasoned peppers and cheese, and the portion was generous and satisfying. The flavors matched what you’d expect from a home-style kitchen, layered and comforting.
If you want to taste something simple but packed with tradition, their rice and beans with a squeeze of fresh lime delivers. La Reyna De Mexico shines for anyone craving honest, straight-from-the-heart cooking.
6. La Fiesta Brava Mexican Restaurant
La Fiesta Brava Mexican Restaurant, a quick trip from Geneva, is known for its relaxed atmosphere and colorful platters. The energy inside is always friendly, and regulars seem to treat it like a second home. It’s an easy spot to bring friends or family and linger over a long lunch or dinner.
I’ve stopped in more than once for their vegetable fajitas, which arrive sizzling and loaded with grilled veggies. The menu offers lots of choices, but their homemade salsas shine especially bright, adding fresh flavor to every bite.
If you love sharing, their table-sized platters of nachos or rice and beans make La Fiesta Brava a great group destination. Count on generous helpings and genuine hospitality every time you visit.
7. Casa Mezcal
Casa Mezcal brings a touch of modern flair to classic Mexican dishes in Penn Yan, just a short drive from Geneva. The menu feels both traditional and inventive, with bright flavors and careful presentation. The space is airy and welcoming, perfect for a casual meal or a special night out.
Each visit leaves me impressed by their fresh approach. The veggie enchiladas come layered with grilled vegetables and a zesty green sauce that’s both comforting and vibrant. The attention to detail here makes every plate photo-worthy and satisfying.
Don’t skip the fresh guacamole and tortilla chips—they’re crunchy and creamy, ideal for sharing. Casa Mezcal’s creative, honest cooking stands out in the area, appealing to both traditionalists and adventurous eaters alike.
8. Laguna Grande Restaurante Mexicano & Bar
Laguna Grande Restaurante Mexicano & Bar in Canandaigua draws you in with its lakeside views and energetic setting. There’s a festive mood here, but it’s the detail in every plate that pulls people back. The staff treats guests like regulars, and the bustling dining room always has the happy, contented sound of satisfied diners.
Last time I visited, I went for the vegetarian chimichangas, crisp on the outside, filled with beans and fresh veggies. The house-made sauces—especially their tangy salsa verde—add layers of flavor to every dish. Each bite manages to taste both light and indulgent.
For a group meal, try the fajita platters sizzling with peppers and squash. It’s a lively spot where every meal feels like a special event, with a view that’s just as memorable as the food.
9. El Bajio
El Bajio in Seneca Falls brings a sense of comfort that’s easy to appreciate, especially when you’re craving the real thing. This spot excels in honest, unfussy Mexican dishes, made with care and a steady hand in the kitchen. It’s one of those places where you can unwind and enjoy a hearty meal without any pretense.
I always find myself drawn to their veggie burritos, which are filled with well-seasoned beans, rice, and fresh vegetables. Every bite tastes home-cooked and satisfying, reminding me of cozy, casual meals with friends.
For a little kick, order the enchiladas with green sauce. Their bold flavors and comforting textures — without unnecessary extras — are what make El Bajio a reliable go-to.
10. D’s South of the Border
(315) 573-7234Call
D’s South of the Border in Newark is unpretentious, affordable, and packed with gratifying flavors. This place is all about comfort food with a Mexican twist, served in a space that’s as relaxed as your favorite hometown diner. Friendly faces behind the counter make every visit easy and welcoming.
I can’t help but gravitate toward their vegetarian tostadas, made with crisp shells stacked high with beans, lettuce, and plenty of veggies. Generous portions guarantee you leave satisfied, and the salsa is always fresh and bright.
If you have a knack for finding hidden gems, try the rice and roasted pepper burrito. It’s a flavor-packed option that exemplifies the simplicity and heart D’s brings to every meal.
More Things to Try in Geneva, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best Mexican restaurants in Geneva, NY?
Some local favorites include Char Burrito Bar, Taqueria Los Amigos, Monterrey Mexican Restaurant II, and La Reyna De Mexico. Each offers a unique approach to classic dishes, from build-your-own burritos to traditional street tacos.
Are there vegetarian or vegan options available?
Yes, most Mexican restaurants in Geneva feature vegetarian and vegan-friendly choices. Popular picks are veggie burritos, fajitas, and rice bowls. Many places also offer plant-based proteins and plenty of fresh salsas.
Is takeout or delivery available?
Nearly all the Mexican spots in Geneva offer takeout options, and some partner with delivery services. It’s easy to grab a quick meal on the go or order in for a cozy night at home.
What are some must-try dishes at Geneva’s Mexican restaurants?
Don’t miss the street-style tacos, enchiladas with house-made sauces, and veggie chimichangas. Each restaurant puts its own spin on classics, so trying a specialty at each spot is the way to go.
Are these restaurants family-friendly?
Absolutely. Most places have a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere for everyone. You’ll find plenty of choices for kids and adults alike.