16 Fresh Tomato Sandwich Recipes for Summer Enjoyment

Are you looking for delicious ways to enjoy summer tomatoes in your sandwiches? I’m sharing 16 easy and tasty tomato sandwich recipes that will bring out the best flavors of fresh tomatoes.

There’s something magical about summer tomatoes that makes any sandwich special. I still remember the first time I enjoyed a fresh, simple tomato sandwich in my grandmother’s kitchen. The juicy tomatoes, paired with just the right amount of mayonnaise and seasoning, created a flavor I can still taste today.

Over the years, I’ve perfected the art of creating easy, delicious tomato sandwiches that highlight the best summer flavors. From fluffy white bread to hearty whole-grain options, I know how to make every bite perfect. Whether you prefer classic or a little twist, I’ll guide you through making the ultimate tomato sandwich.

These recipes are about more than just ingredients—they’re about capturing the essence of summer in every bite. With simple steps and fresh ingredients, you can create a mouthwatering sandwich that’s perfect for any sunny day. Let’s explore how to turn fresh tomatoes into a delicious and satisfying meal you’ll want to make again and again.

1. Classic Tomato Sandwich

A classic tomato sandwich is a simple celebration of peak summer tomatoes, made with fresh white bread, mayonnaise, and just a touch of salt and pepper to enhance their natural flavor. It’s best enjoyed unstuffed and unadorned, allowing the juicy, sun-ripened tomatoes to shine through in every delicious bite.

Read the Recipe: Classic Tomato Sandwich

2. Classic Tomato Sandwiches

Imagine biting into a juicy, ripe tomato nestled between slices of soft white bread topped with creamy mayonnaise, a sprinkle of salt, and a dash of pepper—simple, yet utterly delicious. These classic tomato sandwiches are the perfect celebration of summer’s freshest flavors, making your taste buds dance with every bite!

Read the Recipe: Classic Tomato Sandwiches

3. My Best Tomato Sandwich

Imagine biting into a perfectly ripe tomato sandwich with crispy whole grain toast spread with creamy mayonnaise—the juicy slices of fresh tomato bursting with flavor. Just layer the tomato slices on the toast, sprinkle with salt and black pepper, and enjoy this simple, delicious summer classic right away!

Read the Recipe: My Best Tomato Sandwich

4. Tomato Sandwich

Dive into a summertime favorite with a juicy heirloom tomato sliced thick, salted to draw out all their natural flavor, and placed generously on mayonnaise-spread bread. Layer it all together, press with another slice, and enjoy a fresh, satisfying sandwich that’s perfect with a cold glass of Summer Sweet Tea.

Read the Recipe: Tomato Sandwich

5. Tomato Sandwiches

This Tomato Sandwich is a burst of summer in every bite, featuring crusty bread rubbed with garlic and ripe tomato pulp for rich flavor. Just layer fresh tomato slices, crisp onions, mayonnaise, and bacon if you like, then top with the second piece of bread—perfect for devouring over the sink with plenty of napkins!

Read the Recipe: Tomato Sandwiches

6. Better Than The Classic Tomato Sandwich

This Better Than The Classic Tomato Sandwich is a fresh, vibrant treat that skips the mayo and uses tangy labneh for an irresistible creamy twist. Just layer juicy heirloom or seasonal tomatoes on your favorite bread, spread with the flavorful labneh mixed with olive oil, and finish with a sprinkle of salt and pepper for a simple, summer-perfect bite!

Read the Recipe: Better Than The Classic Tomato Sandwich

7. Tomato Sandwich [grandbaby-cakes.com]

A Tomato Sandwich is a summer classic that shines with fresh, juicy heirloom tomatoes and simple ingredients like mayo, toasted bread, and a tasty lemony-garlic aioli. Just layer the seasoned tomatoes, crispy bacon (if you like), and lettuce between toasted slices, then cut and enjoy this delicious, fresh treat!

Read the Recipe: Tomato Sandwich [grandbaby-cakes.com]

8. Southern Tomato Sandwich

A Southern Tomato Sandwich is a quick and delicious treat that combines juicy garden tomatoes, mayonnaise, and soft white bread. Just layer thick slices of fresh beefsteak tomatoes on bread, spread with mayo, sprinkle with salt and pepper, and enjoy this simple, summery staple right over the sink for maximum messiness and flavor!

Read the Recipe: Southern Tomato Sandwich

9. Classic Tomato Sandwich [www.simplyscratch.com]

Grab ripe tomatoes from your garden and layer them on slices of soft white bread spread with rich mayonnaise. Season generously with salt and black pepper, then top with the other slice of bread—toast or not—to create a delicious, classic tomato sandwich perfect for a quick summer treat!

Read the Recipe: Classic Tomato Sandwich [www.simplyscratch.com]

10. The Best Tomato Sandwich to Make All Summer Long

Get ready to enjoy a delightful summer treat with this classic tomato sandwich! It’s all about juicy, sweet tomatoes paired with a herby cream cheese spread on toasted whole-wheat bread, making every bite fresh and flavorful. When making it, simply mix cream cheese, Greek yogurt, and fresh herbs, then spread it generously on your bread, add slices of tomato, and enjoy a simple, satisfying meal that’s perfect for sunny days.

Read the Recipe: The Best Tomato Sandwich to Make All Summer Long

11. Simple Tomato Sandwich

A Simple Tomato Sandwich is the ultimate summer comfort food, featuring juicy sliced tomatoes topped with creamy mayonnaise on toasted crusty bread. Just layer the ingredients with a little salt and pepper, and you’ve got a fresh, flavorful treat that’s perfect for sunny days and nostalgic moments!

Read the Recipe: Simple Tomato Sandwich

12. Tomato Sandwich [www.thekitchn.com]

This simple summer delight features juicy ripe tomatoes layered between soft white bread with a spread of mayonnaise, creating pure tomato perfection. In just five minutes, you’ll enjoy a fresh, flavorful sandwich that captures the essence of summer sunshine in every bite.

Read the Recipe: Tomato Sandwich [www.thekitchn.com]

13. Tomato Sandwich [www.chelseasmessyapron.com]

Imagine sinking your teeth into a soft white bread slice topped with juicy heirloom tomatoes and a rich, flavorful basil mayo—made with fresh basil, lemon juice, and good-quality mayo. Toss in some optional toast or add a few extra ingredients like mozzarella or bacon for an even tastier twist!

Read the Recipe: Tomato Sandwich [www.chelseasmessyapron.com]

14. How To Make the Best Tomato Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Create a delicious open-faced tomato grilled cheese by grating a mix of sharp cheddar and Gruyère for faster melting and richer flavor. Spread mayonnaise on toasted bread to prevent sogginess, then layer pat-dried tomato slices and the cheesy mixture before broiling for a golden, crispy finish that’s bursting with flavor.

Read the Recipe: How To Make the Best Tomato Grilled Cheese Sandwich

15. My Favorite Tomato Sandwich Takes 3 Minutes To Make

This tomato sandwich is a quick, delicious treat that comes together in just 3 minutes using five simple ingredients. Toast some sourdough, then layer on cheese, fresh basil, creamy avocado, and big juicy tomato slices—finished with a sprinkle of flaky salt for the perfect summer bite.

Read the Recipe: My Favorite Tomato Sandwich Takes 3 Minutes To Make

16. The Tomato Sandwich I’ve Been Making Since College

This Tomato Sandwich—called the Marv ‘n’ Joe—is a simple, flavorful open-faced treat made by spreading garlic butter on toasted sourdough, then layering juicy tomato slices topped with melty provolone and Parmesan cheese. Drizzle the tomato with olive oil and balsamic vinegar to enhance the crunch and tang, then broil until the cheese is bubbly and golden for a perfect, nostalgic snack.

Read the Recipe: The Tomato Sandwich I’ve Been Making Since College