Looking for the best Mexican restaurants in Highland, IN? You’re in the right place. Whether you’ve got a soft spot for street tacos, or you’re a burrito loyalist, there’s something about fresh tortillas, slow-cooked meats, and tangy salsas that grabs everyone’s attention. After more local meals than I care to count, I can confirm Highland’s Mexican food is much more than just a quick food fix—it’s a genuine experience.
A while back, I tasted my way across Highland. At one spot, the carne asada was so tender that I couldn’t help but strike up a conversation with the cook about his secret marinade. Another time, a pile of warm chips and chunky guacamole turned a forgettable Tuesday into something worth talking about. If you want to skip the tourist traps and stick with honest plates and bold flavors, you’re in good hands. Every place on this list is here because it delivers. Dig in for a lineup that covers bold, casual, and everything in between.
1. Tacos & Burritos El Ranchito
(219) 972-7966Call
Tacos & Burritos El Ranchito is nestled right in Highland Plaza, making it a staple for anyone craving fresh Mexican flavors. The vibe here is casual, and the staff never hesitate to share a smile.
After my first visit, the memory of their al pastor tacos stuck with me. The meat hits that balance of juicy and slightly crispy, and the salsa has the right kick—not just heat, but actual flavor.
Their burritos are another highlight. A good burrito isn’t just big; it’s got to taste great from the first bite to the last, and theirs delivers every time. For a lighter bite, try their steak tacos. Tacos & Burritos El Ranchito knows how to do the classics right.
2. Asada Grill & Cantina
Asada Grill & Cantina gives Highland a burst of energy. This spot thrives on lively conversation and the warm scent of sizzling grilled meats. The space feels cozy but modern, so it works for both family dinners and casual meetups.
My favorite memory here? I once lingered over a plate of carne asada tacos, each bite packed with smoky, tender steak and topped with fresh cilantro. The homemade salsas here brighten every dish—they don’t mask the flavor, they highlight it.
If you want something hearty, their enchiladas verdes are a must. The tomatillo sauce has just a bit of tang, tying everything together. Asada Grill & Cantina nails the simple dishes with top-tier ingredients and a real focus on taste.
3. Maria’s Buena Cocina
Maria’s Buena Cocina brings homemade comfort to Highland, all from its no-frills spot on Kennedy Ave. The vibe is relaxed, and you’ll notice regulars exchanging friendly greetings at cozy tables. It feels like stepping into someone’s living room, but with better food.
On my last stop, a plate of chicken tamales stood out. Steamed just right, the masa was fluffy and full of flavor—impossible to rush through. Their tortilla soup is another strong suit, rich and soothing, perfect for chilly days.
This place is cash-only, which somehow makes it feel more like a hidden gem. If you’re in the mood for traditional recipes that don’t cut corners, Maria’s Buena Cocina serves the classics with true care and quality.
4. El Hefe De Tacos
El Hefe De Tacos brings a burst of personality to every meal on Indianapolis Blvd. It’s colorful, casual, and built for people who want serious flavor without fuss. The menu is clear and straight to the point, with each dish given just the right amount of attention.
I still remember my first taste of their grilled steak “El Hefe” taco. The tortillas come warm and soft, holding together savory, perfectly seasoned steak and a sprinkle of chopped onions and cilantro—simple done right.
If you’re looking to share, the quesadillas here are always fresh, cheesy, and big enough to feed a hungry group. El Hefe De Tacos is that spot where everything tastes homemade, but you don’t have to clean up after.
5. Boss Man Tacos
Boss Man Tacos makes its mark with bold flavors and a laid-back atmosphere. The menu has all the staples, but every dish here seems to have that extra punch of seasoning. It’s a go-to for both a quick lunch and a casual dinner.
One meal that stands out for me is their carne asada taco. Every bite packs juicy steak and a lively mix of onions and cilantro. The tortillas have a nice chew, and nothing feels like it sat around waiting—it’s all made to order.
If you want variety, take a shot at their veggie tacos; plenty of color and flavor, without missing anything. Boss Man Tacos is easy to love if you appreciate food that delivers real satisfaction.
6. Mas Tacos
(219) 301-5077Call
Mas Tacos is the kind of neighborhood spot where you can’t help but create a go-to order. It’s small, no-nonsense, and lets the food do all the talking. The energy is laid-back, and the staff make regulars out of first-timers with friendly service.
On my last visit, the fish tacos were a knockout—crispy on the outside, flaky inside, and paired with a squeeze of lime. Their homemade salsas are bright and a little addictive, perfect over just about anything they serve.
If you’re hungrier, try the chicken burrito. You’ll walk away full, but it’s the combination of seasoned rice, beans, and grilled chicken that sticks with you. Mas Tacos proves a great meal doesn’t need any pretense.
7. Riviera Maya Taco & Tequila Bar
Riviera Maya Taco & Tequila Bar pairs vibrant décor with a lively atmosphere, making it a favorite for both gatherings and quiet lunches. The space buzzes with energy, and everything from the service to the presentation feels intentional.
I remember trying their shrimp tacos—sautéed just right, wrapped in warm tortillas with a hit of citrus. There’s a real freshness in every bite, and the house-made salsas bring extra personality to each dish.
If you’re thinking about something filling, the grilled chicken burrito is a standout. It’s packed, but every ingredient feels perfectly balanced. Riviera Maya captures the fun side of Mexican cuisine without cutting corners on the essentials.
8. Fat Burrito
(219) 513-8027Call
Fat Burrito looks unassuming from the outside, but inside it’s all about big flavors and generous portions. Porte De Leau Plaza isn’t short on options, but this spot pulls in regulars who know their way around a good meal.
One bite into their chicken burrito and you’ll get why the name fits—stuffed with rice, beans, and juicy grilled chicken, it’s comfort food wrapped up tight. Each order comes out hot, with plenty of options for salsa on the side.
Their steak tacos are also a winner: classic, simple, and always fresh. Fat Burrito delivers quick service without cutting back on what matters most—flavor and satisfaction you can count on.
9. Memo’s Taco Mex
(219) 934-7300Call
Memo’s Taco Mex is one of those places that wins you over with its homey atmosphere and simple, heartfelt cooking. Tucked along 45th St, the menu is packed with classics, but everything tastes like it’s made with care.
I still think about their chicken tacos—each one loaded with tender chicken and fresh toppings, wrapped in warm corn tortillas. The salsa here is no afterthought, either; it’s bright, flavorful, and clearly homemade.
If you’re in the mood for something different, don’t skip the quesadillas. They’re cheesy, generous, and great for sharing. When you walk into Memo’s Taco Mex, you know you’ll get a solid meal every time.
10. QDOBA Mexican Eats
QDOBA Mexican Eats keeps things simple: fast service, lots of options, and flavors everyone can agree on. The vibe is modern but low-key, perfect for a quick lunch or a family meal where everyone wants their own twist on dinner.
I’m always drawn to their grilled chicken burrito bowl. It’s customizable, so you pick all your favorites—rice, beans, grilled veggies, and that smoky chicken. Their hand-crafted guacamole and signature 3-Cheese Queso? Also worth a spot on your order every time.
If you want something lighter, try the fajita veggie tacos. QDOBA delivers freshness in every bite, and it’s easy to build a meal to match your mood. For a chain, the Highland location manages to feel surprisingly personal.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the highest rated Mexican restaurants in Highland, IN?
Many locals give high marks to places like Tacos & Burritos El Ranchito, Mas Tacos, and Maria’s Buena Cocina for their authentic dishes and friendly service.
Are there Mexican restaurants in Highland with vegetarian options?
Absolutely. Nearly every spot offers vegetarian tacos, burritos, and quesadillas. Ask about veggie fillings and fresh salsas to keep your meal meat-free.
Do any Mexican restaurants in Highland offer takeout or delivery?
Yes, most restaurants—including QDOBA, El Hefe De Tacos, and Boss Man Tacos—offer takeout. Larger chains and some local spots provide delivery, especially through apps.
Where can I find authentic Mexican flavors in Highland, IN?
Try Maria’s Buena Cocina for tamales and homemade soups, or Memo’s Taco Mex for their tacos and salsa fresca. These spots lean into home-style recipes you won’t find everywhere.
Are there family-friendly Mexican restaurants in Highland?
Plenty. QDOBA and Mas Tacos both offer menus and settings that work well for groups and kids, with broad choices to suit different tastes.