Easy Black and White Cookie Recipes for Homemade Bakery-Style Treats

Are you looking for delicious black and white cookie recipes? I’m offering 18 easy and tasty recipes to help you make perfect black and white cookies at home.

Black and White Cookies are a classic treat that never fails to bring a smile. I remember the first time I tried baking them; the joy of creating those perfect half vanilla and half chocolate flavors was truly rewarding. These cookies are more than just a dessert—they’re a delicious symbol of comfort and nostalgia.

With simple ingredients and easy steps, you can recreate these bakery-style goodies at home. I’ve tested many recipes, and I know how satisfying it is to make a soft, cake-like cookie with a glossy frosting. Once you master this recipe, you’ll want to make these versatile treats again and again.

Black and White Cookies are not only stunning but also incredibly easy to customize with hints of lemon, vanilla, or almond. They’re the perfect sweet escape—great for sharing, indulging, or just enjoying a moment of pure deliciousness. Reading further will guide you to cookie perfection you can be proud of.

1. Black and White Cookies

Imagine biting into a soft, cake-like cookie that’s both fun and delicious. These Black and White Cookies are topped with half vanilla and half chocolate icing, making each bite a perfect balance of flavors and textures—easy to make and totally addictive!

Read the Recipe: Black and White Cookies

2. Black and White Cookies [www.allrecipes.com]

These Black and White Cookies are a delightful treat made by baking sweet, fluffy cookies topped with rich vanilla and chocolate fondant icing. The process involves baking the cookies until golden, then carefully frosting one half with vanilla icing and the other with luscious chocolate for a classic New York-style flavor experience.

Read the Recipe: Black and White Cookies [www.allrecipes.com]

3. New York City Black and White Cookies

New York City Black and White Cookies are delightful cake-style treats that are perfect for sharing at gatherings or with a favorite New Yorker. These palm-sized cookies are topped with smooth white and rich chocolate icing, making them a fun and delicious nod to NYC’s classic baked goods!

Read the Recipe: New York City Black and White Cookies

4. Black and White Cookies Recipe

These Black and White Cookies are soft, fluffy, and have a cake-like texture with a delicious thick layer of vanilla and chocolate frosting on top. They’re giant treats that are halfway between a cookie and a cake, perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth with a sweet vanilla glaze on one side and a rich chocolate glaze on the other — just like in a classic NYC bakery!

Read the Recipe: Black and White Cookies Recipe

5. Perfect Black and White Cookies

Black and White Cookies are soft, moist treats with a tender crumb, flavored with vanilla, lemon, and almond. They are covered with both vanilla and chocolate glazes, making each bite delightfully sweet and richly flavored.

Read the Recipe: Perfect Black and White Cookies

6. Black and White Cookies [sallysbakingaddiction.com]

These Black and White Cookies are large, soft, and cake-like with a delicious vanilla flavor. They are topped with thick vanilla and chocolate icings that crackle slightly when you bite into them, giving a perfect balance of sweetness and texture. These cookies come together quickly without chilling, making them a fun and easy treat to whip up in your kitchen!

Read the Recipe: Black and White Cookies [sallysbakingaddiction.com]

7. Black and White Cookies – Broma Bakery

These Black and White Cookies are loaded with soft, buttery sugar cookies topped with half chocolate frosting and half vanilla frosting, creating an eye-catching and delicious treat. Perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth, these classic cookies are easy to make at home and taste just like those famous NYC bakery favorites!

Read the Recipe: Black and White Cookies – Broma Bakery

8. Black and White Cookies [www.thekitchn.com]

These Black and White Cookies are a delightful treat that taste like soft, cake-like cookies with a hint of lemon or vanilla flavor. Simply bake big, fluffy cookies, then frost half with vanilla icing and the other half with chocolate, creating a charming and delicious contrast that’s perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth!

Read the Recipe: Black and White Cookies [www.thekitchn.com]

9. Black and White Cookies (Half Moon Cookies)

These Black and White Cookies are a delightful treat with a soft, cake-like texture and are sliced in a perfect half-moon shape, frosted with smooth vanilla on one side and rich chocolate on the other. Making them at home is simple—just bake the dough until golden, then carefully spread the vanilla and chocolate icings on each half, creating a striking and tasty duo that’s perfect for any occasion!

Read the Recipe: Black and White Cookies (Half Moon Cookies)

10. Black & White Cookies

Black & White Cookies are a delightful treat that blend cake and cookie textures, topped with half vanilla and half chocolate icing for the best of both worlds. These soft, tender cookies with a crisp edge are surprisingly simple to make at home—just mix, bake until golden, and add the glossy, flavorful frosting!

Read the Recipe: Black & White Cookies

11. Black and White Cookies [cookiesandcups.com]

Black and White Cookies are a delightfully soft, cake-like treat with a buttery vanilla flavor, topped with glossy half vanilla and half chocolate icing. These cookies offer a perfect combination of sweet, chewy, and tender textures, making them a classic NYC bakery favorite you can easily create at home!

Read the Recipe: Black and White Cookies [cookiesandcups.com]

12. Black and White Cookie

These Black and White Cookies are a delightful New York favorite — soft, cakey, and perfect for dunking in coffee or milk! Made with gluten-free and vegan ingredients, they offer a fluffy texture and classic flavor that brings back memories of iconic bakery treats.

Read the Recipe: Black and White Cookie

13. Black-and-White Cookies

These Black-and-White Cookies are a delightful treat that you can easily bake at home, with a soft, chewy center and smooth, glossy frosting on top. Simply mix the ingredients, bake until golden, then decorate with half chocolate and half vanilla frosting for a classic New York City twist—enjoy these cookies fresh or store them in an airtight container for later!

Read the Recipe: Black-and-White Cookies

14. Black and White Cookies [www.budgetbytes.com]

These Black and White Cookies are a delightful treat that combines a soft, cake-like texture with sweet vanilla and chocolate icing, creating a classic NYC flavor. Easy to make at home, they’re perfect for bringing a little piece of New York into your kitchen with their pillowy bite and satisfying crackle of the crisp icing!

Read the Recipe: Black and White Cookies [www.budgetbytes.com]

15. Black & White Cookies [www.thepioneerwoman.com]

These Black & White Cookies are soft, cakey treats with a perfect balance of vanilla and chocolate glazes, infused with a subtle lemon aroma that adds a refreshing twist. Making them is simple: you mix dough, scoop it onto a baking sheet, bake until golden, and then decorate with smooth glaze for a classic, irresistible snack.

Read the Recipe: Black & White Cookies [www.thepioneerwoman.com]

16. Best Recipe for Black and White Cookies

Black and white cookies are soft, lemon-scented cookies layered with half vanilla icing and half chocolate icing, creating a delightful, cookie-and-frosting combo. These classic New York treats are easy to make at home and perfect for anyone who loves moist cookies with rich, creamy frosting on top!

Read the Recipe: Best Recipe for Black and White Cookies

17. Black and White Cookies Recipe Is a Dessert Dream: Soft, Cakey + Coated in Two Flavors

Imagine biting into a soft, cake-like cookie topped with glossy, flavorful vanilla and chocolate icings on each half—these are Black and White Cookies! In just 30 minutes, you can bake these indulgent treats that combine two irresistible flavors in one perfect bite, with tips on icing to make them look as stunning as they taste.

Read the Recipe: Black and White Cookies Recipe Is a Dessert Dream: Soft, Cakey + Coated in Two Flavors

18. Black and White Cookies Recipe | Cook the Book

Baking Black and White Cookies is a delightful adventure that combines a lemon-scented cakey base with smooth, sweet icing on top. Once you gather your ingredients and master the substitution for cake flour, you’ll enjoy creating these visually striking cookies filled with classic New York charm and rich flavorful layers!

Read the Recipe: Black and White Cookies Recipe | Cook the Book