Craving bold flavors and warm tortillas? Nutley, NJ, might surprise you with its overflowing roster of Mexican restaurants, each spot carrying its own personality and signature dishes. Over the years, I’ve trekked up and down the town’s stretches, chasing everything from fire-roasted salsa to comforting plates of freshly made tacos. Somewhere between salsa flights and cracking open a traditional Jarritos, I realized that Nutley has tucked away some genuine gems—places where the staff remember your order and the guacamole always tastes like it’s made to order.
The hunt for the best Mexican restaurants in Nutley isn’t just about finding a perfect taco, though that never hurts. With options ranging from homey burrito joints to colorful cantinas with full menus, diversity is on full display. Whether you’re after a sit-down meal or a quick grab-and-go, the local scene delivers hits for every taste. Let’s dive into the top contenders—you just might find your new favorite spot for taco night or a midday burrito fix.
Where to find the best mexican restaurants in Nutley, NJ
Here are some of the top spots to find the best mexican restaurants in Nutley, NJ:
- Pancho’s Burritos
- margaritas mexican grill
- Los Jarros Mexican Grill Restaurant
- Marlitos Burritos
- Metropolis Mexican Grill
- Senorita’s Mexican Grill
- Tinga Taqueria
- El Gallo Mexican Restaurant
- La Casa De Rosita
- Tacos Y Cemitas Mari
1. Pancho’s Burritos
Pancho’s Burritos on Franklin Avenue delivers big flavors in an unpretentious setting. The first thing you’ll notice is a menu tailored for serious cravings, whether you want a quick lunch or a lingering dinner. Each bite here feels like a backyard fiesta, with warm tortillas and fresh toppings setting the tone.
What sets Pancho’s apart? It’s the way the staff pile on the fillings without holding back. Their Veggie Burrito is a textural delight, and the chicken tacos come crowned with tangy salsa and crisp lettuce.
For those indecisive moments, grab a platter of cheese enchiladas—oozy, comforting, and built for sharing. Pancho’s keeps it classic, and their balance of flavor and friendliness always pulls me back.
2. margaritas mexican grill
Margaritas Mexican Grill feels like a secret handshake for locals—if you know, you know. Located in the heart of Nutley, its cozy interior and always-friendly staff make every visit a welcome pause in a busy day. I first stopped in on a cold afternoon and found myself drawn in by the aromatic sizzle from the kitchen.
What makes this spot shine? The generously filled vegetable fajitas come with piping hot tortillas and just the right hit of seasoning. Their grilled chicken tacos burst with freshness and color, each bite perfectly balanced.
If you’re after comfort, their homemade chips with spicy salsa are a must. Margaritas Mexican Grill delivers simple, authentic plates that let fresh ingredients take the spotlight.
3. Los Jarros Mexican Grill Restaurant
Los Jarros Mexican Grill Restaurant radiates a sense of comfort the moment you walk through its doors. With walls dressed in vibrant colors and a staff that greets you like family, it’s the kind of spot that turns newcomers into regulars after one meal. I recall a rainy evening here, warmed up by a cup of their flavorful tortilla soup.
The grilled shrimp tacos steal the show—plump, juicy, and topped with crisp slaw. If you’re visiting for dinner, their carne asada plate (without cheese or non-permissible toppings) comes perfectly seasoned and char-grilled.
For those looking to share, the homemade guacamole and chips offer a bright, citrusy punch. Los Jarros serves up Nutley’s version of comfort Mexican food—thoughtful, satisfying, and never overdone.
4. Marlitos Burritos
(973) 320-2250Call
Marlitos Burritos quickly became my go-to for hearty, reliable Mexican fare. This spot keeps things casual while delivering generous portions packed with flavor. The aroma of freshly grilled vegetables greets you before you even reach the counter. There’s something relaxing about the buzz of the place at lunchtime, with regulars filing in for their favorites.
The menu shines with the classic bean and cheese burrito—simple, satisfying, and served piping hot. Fans of heat will appreciate the house-made hot sauces, always offered on the side.
Don’t overlook their street corn, charred to perfection and sprinkled with just enough spice to keep things lively. Marlitos nails the art of making a quick meal taste memorable, perfect for a low-key dinner or midday pick-me-up.
5. Metropolis Mexican Grill
(973) 667-0202Call
Metropolis Mexican Grill manages to blend local energy with a broad menu that stretches far past the basics. Every visit feels a bit like finding a reliable neighborhood hideaway—always bustling, never overwhelming. I dropped in after a long day once, instantly revived by the inviting aroma and upbeat chatter.
What makes Metropolis stand out is its range of dishes and consistently friendly service. The grilled vegetable quesadilla quickly became my reliable favorite: crisp on the outside, melty and packed with flavor inside.
For something lighter, the fresh shrimp salad is both bright and filling. With solid prices and a laid-back feel, Metropolis Mexican Grill is the kind of spot that encourages lingering a little longer at your table.
6. Senorita’s Mexican Grill
(732) 669-9024Call
Senorita’s Mexican Grill has the feel of a festive gathering spot, where every meal kicks off with complimentary fresh salsa and warm tortilla chips. The first time I stopped in, the bustling atmosphere and rustic decor created a welcoming, upbeat mood. Servers move quickly but never seem rushed, ensuring the experience feels both personal and efficient.
Senorita’s stands out for its broad menu and bright, flavorful dishes. The vegetable enchiladas here are a favorite—nutty, savory, and topped with just the right amount of house-made sauce. Their rice and beans shine as some of the best sides you’ll find in the area.
If you’re planning a family event, Senorita’s has plenty of space and a menu to match any appetite. It’s a top choice for anyone wanting authentic taste in a lively setting, whether dining in or ordering catering.
7. Tinga Taqueria
Tinga Taqueria does casual dining with an inventive twist—think crisp homemade chips, inventive house salsas, and a menu that surprises without straying too far from tradition. My first visit involved a marathon tasting of their sides, from cucumber salsa to sautéed spinach, all layered with bright, zesty flavors.
The standout at Tinga has to be the grilled portobello tacos, draped with garlic and onions, delivering a deep, smoky finish that feels right at home among their other fresh options. The vegetarian tacos also earn high marks for bold seasoning and creative toppings.
If you’re craving comfort, the Spanish rice alongside their soft corn tortillas never disappoints. Tinga Taqueria balances familiar favorites with a few fun surprises, earning loyal fans looking for something light yet satisfying.
8. El Gallo Mexican Restaurant
El Gallo Mexican Restaurant bridges old and new with a menu that plays with both pre-Hispanic and modern Mexican flavors. My visit was memorable for the sense of history—dishes arrive beautifully plated, every flavor rooted in tradition yet distinctly current.
The grilled vegetable fajitas come out sizzling, generously portioned, and layered with just enough heat to wake up your palate. For something a bit lighter, the fresh house salads are tossed with thoughtful dressings that won’t overpower.
What makes El Gallo shine is the energy—always bustling, yet never rushed, with staff who are happy to tailor dishes to your liking. If you’re curious about Mexican cuisine’s depth, this place serves up tradition with a fresh twist.
9. La Casa De Rosita
(973) 815-0004Call
La Casa De Rosita is the kind of neighborhood spot where the cook probably knows your name. It’s cozy, casual, and refreshingly down-to-earth. I stumbled in after a long workday, lured by the comforting aroma of simmering spices and fresh tortillas grilling in the back.
What really makes Rosita’s special is its focus on homestyle Mexican cooking. Their pollo asado platter arrives with tender, well-seasoned chicken and sides of fluffy rice and savory beans. Each plate feels crafted with care, and the freshness stands out.
If you’re after flavor, sample their guacamole—the kind you scoop up with a pile of warm chips and don’t want to share. For a low-key meal that still feels memorable, Rosita’s quietly gets it right every time.
10. Tacos Y Cemitas Mari
(973) 473-2299Call
Tacos Y Cemitas Mari keeps things simple, authentic, and packed with flavor. The first time I stopped by, the scene was bustling—families laughing, orders flying, and a counter full of sizzling, fragrant fillings. This spot excels at bringing a slice of classic Mexican street food to Passaic, and you can taste it in every bite.
The real star here is the cemita, a Mexican sandwich layered with ripe avocado, fresh cheese, and smoky chipotle. If you want something more classic, the vegetarian tacos come generously filled and never feel like an afterthought.
Grab your food to go or snag a table and dig in—Tacos Y Cemitas Mari delivers a no-frills experience with an emphasis on honest, bold taste every time.
More Things to Try in Nutley, NJ
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best Mexican restaurants in Nutley, NJ?
Some favorites in Nutley include Pancho’s Burritos, Marlitos Burritos, and Los Jarros Mexican Grill Restaurant. If you’re willing to travel a bit, options nearby like Senorita’s Mexican Grill and Tinga Taqueria are also popular.
Do Mexican restaurants in Nutley offer vegetarian or vegan options?
Yes, most local Mexican spots offer vegetarian dishes like veggie burritos, tacos, and quesadillas. Some can adjust menu items for vegan dine-in requests; just ask your server when you order.
Are any Mexican restaurants in Nutley family-friendly?
Absolutely. Most Mexican restaurants in the area have inviting, casual atmospheres and plenty of kid-friendly choices. Pancho’s Burritos and Senorita’s Mexican Grill, for example, are known for great service and relaxed seating.
Is there halal food available at Mexican restaurants in Nutley?
Menus change, but most focus on classic Mexican recipes without guaranteeing halal options. If halal is necessary, call ahead to check or stick to vegetarian selections for peace of mind.
Where can I find Mexican restaurants with takeout or delivery in Nutley, NJ?
Popular spots like Marlitos Burritos, Pancho’s Burritos, and Metropolis Mexican Grill all offer takeout and delivery. Most places accept online orders or quick phone-ins for speedy pickup.