Finding authentic Mexican food in Brookville, NY can feel like looking for a hidden gem—even if you know where to dig, real flavor stands out from the crowd. Over the years, I’ve checked countless menus, traded notes with locals, and even found myself side-eyeing friends for claiming the “best taco in town.” Some spots serve a serious salsa, while others revel in the art of the burrito. Whenever someone asks for recommendations, I get a little excited. There’s nothing better than helping someone dodge bland beans and one-note nachos.
Brookville’s Mexican restaurants cover all the cravings—from relaxed grills with family-style plates to those energetic spots perfect for a night out. You’ll find smoky salsas, grilled corn that doesn’t taste like it came from a can, and tortillas that actually taste like they’re made that day. Whether you’re after a splashy plate of guacamole or you prefer your meal simple and spiced just right, there’s a place on this list that’ll hit the spot. Ready to discover your new favorite table? Let’s dig in.
Where to find the best mexican restaurants in Brookville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best mexican restaurants in Brookville, NY:
- Cozymel’s Mexican Grill
- Moe’s Southwest Grill
- Besito
- Puerto Vallarta
- La Verne
- Dirty Taco And Tequila Woodbury
- Desi Fire Grill
- Owen’s Tacos Syosset
- QDOBA Mexican Eats
- Quesos La Ricura
1. Cozymel’s Mexican Grill
Cozymel’s Mexican Grill offers a little slice of Mexico just a short drive from Brookville. The bright, lively atmosphere always feels welcoming, and there’s plenty of space for groups big or small. I’ve spent more than one relaxed evening here, unwinding with house-made salsas and admiring the murals that line the walls.
What sets Cozymel’s apart is their commitment to fresh ingredients—you can taste it in everything from the grilled corn to the fragrant rice. Their enchiladas stand out, especially with verde sauce, and the tacos are never shy on flavor. If you want something to share, the tableside guacamole is a must. Cozymel’s menu balances traditional recipes with crowd-pleasers, making it an easy recommendation.
2. Moe’s Southwest Grill
Moe’s Southwest Grill brings a playful, create-your-own vibe to the Brookville area. I’ve stopped here more times than I can count when I’m craving fast, flavorful food but don’t want to sacrifice quality. The staff are quick with a smile, and every meal comes with free chips and house salsa—a detail I’m definitely not mad about.
Burrito bowls and tacos take center stage here, with countless topping options and fresh pico de gallo made daily. For a solid start, try the burrito bowl with rice, beans, roasted vegetables, and guacamole. It’s filling and packs in the flavor without going overboard. Moe’s ability to offer variety without losing taste is why it keeps making my personal list of favorites.
3. Besito
Besito crafts an atmosphere that feels both stylish and inviting, making it a favorite for special occasions in the Brookville area. The décor strikes the perfect balance—charming without feeling overdone—which always puts me in the mood for a leisurely meal. Every visit here reminds me why I’m drawn back.
Freshness is at the heart of Besito’s menu. Everything arrives beautifully plated and expertly seasoned. I recommend starting with their house guacamole, prepared to order and bursting with bright flavor. For mains, the grilled vegetable tacos are a standout—full of texture and just the right hint of spice. Besito excels at turning simple ingredients into memorable dishes, making this spot a must-try for anyone on the hunt for the best in Mexican cuisine.
4. Puerto Vallarta
Puerto Vallarta is the kind of place where you settle in and feel like you’ve stumbled across a local favorite. The casual setting instantly puts you at ease, and the staff never hesitate to recommend something new. I’ve often brought friends here for laid-back dinners that stretch on because no one’s in a hurry to leave.
What makes Puerto Vallarta special is how it serves classic Mexican comfort food without shortcuts. The rice and beans have real depth, and the fajitas arrive at the table sizzling and fragrant. If you’re looking for something packed with flavor, try the vegetable enchiladas. They soak up the house-made sauces and showcase the kitchen’s attention to detail. This spot understands that simple, honest food done right is all you need.
5. La Verne
(516) 333-7781Call
La Verne is a low-key spot that consistently delivers on flavor, even when my cravings strike at odd hours. The friendly service and unpretentious setting make it a go-to for easy lunches and casual dinners. It’s the kind of place where you can relax, enjoy great food, and never feel rushed.
Authenticity is the cornerstone of La Verne’s menu. Dishes arrive with fresh salsas, warm tortillas, and a noticeable attention to the small details. The vegetable fajitas here are some of the most satisfying around, arriving sizzling and loaded with bright, perfectly cooked veggies. For something lighter, their tortilla soup is rich and comforting without being heavy. La Verne proves that simple, honest cooking always wins.
6. Dirty Taco And Tequila Woodbury
(516) 864-0068Call
See Menu
Dirty Taco And Tequila Woodbury lives up to its playful name, offering a lively atmosphere that never feels forced. This spot draws a crowd, but it’s worth the wait for adventurous flavor and inventive takes on classic Mexican dishes. The energy is contagious and every visit feels like an event in itself.
The tacos here are where Dirty Taco truly shines. Expect corn tortillas loaded with vibrant fillings—grilled vegetables with salsa verde have become a personal favorite. Their elote, coated in zesty seasoning, is the kind of snack that keeps you coming back. If you like bold flavors with a twist, Dirty Taco & Tequila delivers in spades, making it a must-try for anyone exploring Brookville’s Mexican food scene.
7. Desi Fire Grill
(516) 681-3111Call
Desi Fire Grill breaks the mold by blending Mexican classics with South Asian flair, making each visit feel like a new culinary adventure. The menu is entirely halal, which means more people can dig in without worry. I’ve dropped by after late nights, and the team always has something fresh and satisfying ready to go.
Kaati rolls may catch your eye, but don’t miss the tacos and burritos—they come packed with bold spices and lively flavors not found elsewhere in Brookville. For vegetarians, the veggie tacos are vibrant and filling, a true comfort on tough days. Desi Fire Grill’s twist on Mexican dishes adds unexpected excitement to familiar favorites and keeps regulars, like myself, coming back for more.
8. Owen’s Tacos Syosset
Owen’s Tacos Syosset is a small spot with big flavors, channeling the kind of authenticity that’s hard to fake. Every time I walk in, the aroma of grilled corn and fresh cilantro tells me I’m in the right place. There’s always a mix of regulars and new faces, which keeps the mood lively.
Tacos are the star here and pack no-nonsense flavor, from their roasted vegetable option to their tangy salsas poured generously on top. For something heartier, the burrito bowl offers a satisfying mountain of rice, beans, and vegetables. I always add a side of elote—grilled corn with chile and lime, a true favorite. Owen’s Tacos nails the basics and adds their own kick, making them easy to recommend.
9. QDOBA Mexican Eats
QDOBA Mexican Eats delivers on both variety and customization, giving you the freedom to build just what you want. The fast-casual setup works perfectly when you’re feeding a group with different tastes. Every visit, I’m met with quick service and plenty of fresh options ready to mix and match.
Bowls and burritos dominate the menu, but don’t overlook the veggie tacos with fajita peppers and all the fixings. QDOBA’s hand-crafted guacamole and signature salsas taste as if they were made for you alone. If you’re in the mood for something creamy, scoop up their three-cheese queso with a side of chips. This is a family-friendly spot that keeps the flavors bold and the choices wide open.
10. Quesos La Ricura
Quesos La Ricura is more than just a restaurant—it’s a cornerstone for anyone who appreciates the building blocks of real Mexican food. This spot is known for its hand-crafted cheeses and authentic tortillas, which turn even the simplest dishes into something special. Over the years, I’ve popped in to pick up fresh cheese and ended up staying to sample whatever’s just come out of the kitchen.
Their handmade tortillas are a game-changer. Warm, soft, and aromatic, they elevate tacos, enchiladas, and more. If you’re making your own Mexican feast or just want a snack, try their dairy products like queso fresco or panela—fresh, creamy, and never overpowering. Quesos La Ricura brings you the heart of Mexican cooking in every bite and every product.
More Things to Try in Brookville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are some popular Mexican restaurants near Brookville, NY?
Some favorites include Cozymel’s Mexican Grill, Moe’s Southwest Grill, Besito, and Puerto Vallarta. Each offers a different vibe and menu style, so you have plenty of choices no matter what you’re craving.
Do any Mexican restaurants in Brookville offer vegetarian options?
Yes, nearly every spot on this list has vegetarian choices. Try the veggie tacos at Owen’s Tacos Syosset or the vegetable enchiladas at Puerto Vallarta for a satisfying meal without meat.
Are there halal Mexican options in the Brookville area?
Desi Fire Grill is a standout for halal Mexican dishes, so everyone can enjoy fresh tacos, burritos, and more without worry.
Can I find authentic Mexican street food near Brookville?
Yes, spots like Owen’s Tacos Syosset and Dirty Taco And Tequila Woodbury serve up street-style tacos and elote made to order, capturing real flavors and textures.
Do any of these restaurants offer catering or large group orders?
Many places on this list, such as QDOBA Mexican Eats and Moe’s Southwest Grill, have catering menus for family gatherings, parties, or office events.