Finding fantastic Mexican food in Centereach, NY is a bit like following the aroma of fresh tortillas down a sunny alley—you know there’s something good waiting at the end. From tangy salsas to slow-cooked beans and perfectly folded burritos, this town serves up a wide spectrum of flavors for anyone craving authentic cuisine. Over the years, I’ve made it a small personal mission to explore each spot and order anything that brightens up the prospect of a lunch break or evening meal.
Curious where to start? That’s the fun part. Tucked between familiar favorites and hidden local gems, Centereach’s Mexican restaurants offer dishes full of character, history, and careful attention to halal preparation. Each visit is a snapshot of regional specialties—sometimes it’s the grilled fajitas at a counter-service joint, sometimes an aromatic cup of sopa at a quiet family restaurant. If you enjoy simplicity mixed with surprising depth, you’re in good hands here. Keep reading: that next memorable meal could be right around the corner.
Where to find the best mexican restaurants in Centereach, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best mexican restaurants in Centereach, NY:
- Plaza Margarita
- El Rio Restaurant
- Moe’s Southwest Grill
- Cabo Fresh Mexican Grill
- Taquerza Y Restaurant
- Plaza Margarita Restaurant
- Pollo Rico Latin Bistro
- On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina
- Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille
- Viva Juan Mexican Restaurant
1. Plaza Margarita
Plaza Margarita on Middle Country Road puts comfort and flavor into everyday meals. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, perfect for relaxed lunches or unhurried dinners. I remember my first visit: the sizzle from the kitchen promised something good, and the service lived up to it.
What sets Plaza Margarita apart is their attention to detail. The handmade tortillas feel like a little celebration. Their chicken and vegetarian enchiladas come smothered in fresh, tangy sauce—just spicy enough to leave you thinking about the flavors afterward.
Try the grilled fajitas served with delicate rice and beans. Everything on the menu feels crafted with pride. It’s a spot where classic Mexican dishes shine, and every meal ends with the urge to come back.
2. El Rio Restaurant
El Rio Restaurant isn’t hard to spot—it’s one of the Centereach fixtures where locals gather for genuine Mexican cooking. The first time I came for dinner, the flavors felt both homey and refreshing, as if each plate had its own story to tell.
What stands out at El Rio is their focus on family recipes and big, honest portions. The staff has a knack for making everyone feel like a regular, and there’s no rush—just a steady stream of colorful plates coming from the kitchen.
If you love classics done right, try their chicken tacos or the cheese-stuffed enchiladas. Every dish arrives with bright toppings and a generous helping of fresh sides. It’s easy to see why this spot stays busy for both lunch and dinner.
3. Moe’s Southwest Grill
Moe’s Southwest Grill in Centereach Mall is a favorite for anyone who enjoys building their own meal. On my first visit, the friendly team made it easy to customize every ingredient and offered menu tips without rushing.
The real draw here is the flexibility and freshness. Bowls, burritos, and tacos are packed with choices, from seasoned chicken to zesty black beans, all piled high with crisp veggies. Every order comes with free chips and lively house salsa, making each meal feel complete.
If you’re indecisive, try the burrito bowl. It’s filling, colorful, and easy to make your own. Whether you want something spicy, mild, or piled with guacamole, Moe’s delivers quick, casual, and satisfying southwest flavors every time.
4. Cabo Fresh Mexican Grill
Cabo Fresh Mexican Grill adds a burst of vibrant flavor to Middle Country Road. The first time I stopped in, the scent of grilled veggies and citrusy salsa made choosing what to eat a real challenge. The staff is friendly and quick, happy to help walk you through the menu if you’re feeling overwhelmed by the variety.
Cabo Fresh stands out for its build-your-own-meal format and quality produce. You can go classic with a burrito or lighter with a salad bowl. Each base is topped with freshly prepared vegetables, beans, and lean grilled chicken for a taste that’s both bright and satisfying.
Don’t skip the cilantro-lime rice or the tangy house salsa. It’s a reliable pick for a fresh lunch or a filling dinner, and each visit is as breezy as the last.
5. Taquerza Y Restaurant
(631) 615-2618Call
Taquerza Y Restaurant feels like a secret spot known by those who appreciate authentic family-style Mexican cooking. On my first visit, the staff greeted me as if I were an old friend, and the cozy dining room made it easy to settle in.
This place stands out for its home-cooked flavors and generous portions. Everything tastes as if it came from a well-kept family recipe—simple, honest, and deeply satisfying. The menu blends Mexican favorites with some Latin American influences, so you get a diverse plate every time.
Order the grilled chicken tacos or their hearty quesadillas. Each dish arrives fresh and stacked with flavor. It’s the kind of spot where you leave full and already thinking about your next visit.
6. Plaza Margarita Restaurant
Plaza Margarita Restaurant delivers a reliable mix of Mexican and Latin American comfort food. Walking in, the scent of grilled peppers and soft tortillas makes you want to stay awhile. On my last visit, the team treated every question with patience, and the mood was always cheerful.
The standout here is the consistency of fresh ingredients and balanced seasoning. Each plate, whether it’s a classic enchilada or something from their Latin selection, is served with generous sides and a pop of color. Their salsa is especially bright and addictive.
If you crave something filling, try their veggie fajitas or one of the custom taco platters. It’s a local pick when you want something hearty, simple, and always satisfying.
7. Pollo Rico Latin Bistro
Pollo Rico Latin Bistro sits at the crossroads of flavor in Centereach, blending Colombian and Mexican favorites in a welcoming spot. I dropped by with a group of friends, and everyone found something unique to try—always a good sign. The staff is helpful, and the patio dining brings out the best in a casual evening.
Pollo Rico shines because of its fresh, home-style meals and friendly atmosphere. The grilled chicken is always juicy and perfectly seasoned, while the sides—especially the rice and beans—taste as if they’ve been made just for your table.
Order the grilled chicken bowl or try a veggie fajita platter. Each dish showcases thoughtful seasoning and bright, fresh sides. It’s a solid pick for anyone craving variety and comfort in one meal.
8. On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina
On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina is just a short drive from Centereach, but its flavor could convince you you’ve traveled much farther. I stopped in for lunch one rainy afternoon and found the place buzzing, with plates streaming out of the kitchen and the scent of grilled veggies in the air.
Freshness is the hallmark here—every meal starts with house-made chips and salsa. Their Tex-Mex staples arrive piping hot, with a special nod to the well-charred fajitas and the stuffed burritos that leave you feeling satisfied but never weighed down.
Try the chicken fajitas or the vegetarian enchiladas. The generous helpings and bright flavors are perfect for sharing with friends or family. It’s an ideal pick if you want big, bold flavor and a lively setting that feels fun from start to finish.
9. Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille
Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille sits in Selden, but it’s well worth the hop from Centereach if you’re after flavors that don’t hold back. My first taste was their signature salsa—tart, bright, and clearly made in-house—which set a cheerful note for everything that followed.
This spot stands out for homemade touches and thoughtful portions. Each plate features fluffy rice, scratch-made beans, and grilled fillings that capture a real depth of flavor. The atmosphere is laid-back, with a menu that covers both the traditional and the unexpected.
Consider the chicken burrito or their roasted veggie tacos. Meals arrive balanced and fresh, never heavy. Blue Tortilla is a dependable stop for anyone who appreciates honest, vibrant cooking and a quiet escape from the busy main road.
10. Viva Juan Mexican Restaurant
Viva Juan Mexican Restaurant is the type of place you stumble upon and end up recommending to everyone you know. The first time I popped in, I was drawn to the colorful décor and the friendly greetings from behind the counter.
What really sets Viva Juan apart is their attention to tradition and generous portions. Every dish arrives looking lively—think vibrant rice, crisp veggies, and plenty of house-made sauces. The menu balances classics with a few surprising twists that keep things interesting.
Don’t miss their chicken enchiladas or the hearty veggie burrito. Fresh ingredients and big flavors anchor every meal. It’s a solid stop for comfort food that’s both satisfying and never fussy.
More Things to Try in Centereach, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best Mexican restaurants in Centereach, NY?
Some top picks include Plaza Margarita, El Rio Restaurant, Cabo Fresh Mexican Grill, and Taquerza Y Restaurant. Each offers a distinct style and a welcoming atmosphere.
Do any Mexican restaurants in Centereach serve vegetarian options?
Yes, most local spots feature vegetarian dishes like veggie burritos, enchiladas, fajitas, and salads. Cabo Fresh and Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille are known for flexible menus with plenty of vegetarian choices.
Are there any Mexican restaurants in Centereach that offer takeout or delivery?
Almost all the major Mexican restaurants in Centereach, such as Moe’s Southwest Grill and El Rio Restaurant, provide takeout and delivery options. Ordering online or by phone is easy and convenient.
Which Mexican restaurants in Centereach are family-friendly?
Most local Mexican eateries are casual and family-friendly. Plaza Margarita Restaurant, Pollo Rico Latin Bistro, and On The Border are good options for groups and kids.
Where can I find fresh salsa and homemade guacamole?
Authentic house-made salsa and guacamole are highlights at places like Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille and Plaza Margarita, where freshness is part of the experience.