Craving bold flavors on a quiet afternoon, I once wandered down Water Street with one mission: to sniff out the best Mexican food Elmira has to offer. Years later, after plates of smoky salsa, juicy chicken tacos, and more than a few baskets of crispy chips, the search has turned into a hobby. Elmira’s Mexican restaurants mix family-owned gems with familiar favorites, each adding their own flair to the Twin Tiers. There’s more here than meets the eye—hidden spots, surprising menus, and a whole lot of homemade charm.
Finding the right place can be tricky. You want fresh ingredients, big flavor, and a menu you can trust. That’s where this guide comes in. Whether you’re after a crunchy tostada, a burrito worth bragging about, or a simple, satisfying rice bowl, you’ll find plenty of real options ahead. Set your appetite loose—Elmira’s Mexican restaurants are ready for you.
Where to find the best mexican restaurants in Elmira, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best mexican restaurants in Elmira, NY:
- Garcia’s Mexican Restaurant
- Los Panchos
- Taco Bell
- Taco Bell / KFC
- Roundin Third
- Salsarita’s Fresh Cantina
- Moe’s Southwest Grill
- Salsa’s
- Little Boomers’ Burrito Bar
- Toto’s Mexican Restaurant
1. Garcia’s Mexican Restaurant
Garcia’s Mexican Restaurant keeps things classic with colorful plates, cozy booths, and a menu that feels like a well-kept family recipe book. Every visit, I notice the welcoming atmosphere—the kind where you actually want to linger after you tuck into your meal. Their enchiladas are a must-try; each bite is rich with slow-simmered sauce and cheese that’s melted just right.
Looking for something lighter? Their vegetarian fajitas never disappoint. Packed with peppers, onions, and plenty of seasoning, they arrive at the table still sizzling, putting on a little show of their own.
This place stands out because it’s not just about the food—it’s the sense of tradition. Service is quick, and the kitchen never skimps on flavor or freshness.
2. Los Panchos
Los Panchos has that friendly, lived-in feel where you know the regulars are on a first-name basis with staff. Walking in, the gentle hum of conversation and the aroma of fresh tortillas pulls you right in. Their chicken tacos are a personal favorite—juicy, simply seasoned, and wrapped in warm corn tortillas that hold together until the very last bite.
If you’re in the mood for something more colorful, try the veggie-stuffed quesadilla. Each slice is filled with crisp peppers and onions, plus just enough cheese for a perfect gooey bite.
Los Panchos sets itself apart with generous servings, reasonable prices, and a menu that highlights comforting, homemade flavors. Every plate feels made with care, and you’ll want to return for more.
3. Taco Bell
Taco Bell in Elmira is the reliable choice for a quick bite when time is tight. The first time I stopped on a road trip, I was surprised by how fast and friendly the service was. The classic bean burrito is a safe bet—warm, filling, and consistent every visit.
If you want something with a bit more crunch, try the Crunchwrap Supreme. It’s a clever twist you won’t find at a typical sit-down spot, packing beans, crisp lettuce, and sauces in a handy, griddled wrap that’s easy to eat on the go.
What makes this Taco Bell stand out in Elmira is its streamlined experience and menu that keeps vegetarians in mind. Whether it’s breakfast or dinner, you’ll always find a wallet-friendly option here.
4. Taco Bell / KFC
Taco Bell / KFC on Broadway is a place you go when opinions are split, and you’d rather keep everyone happy than argue. I’ve stopped here with friends who couldn’t decide between tacos and something different, and somehow, everyone walked away satisfied. The joint menu offers the full Taco Bell lineup, so classics like the bean burrito or crunchy taco are always available and come out quick.
It’s surprisingly convenient if you want a fast, familiar Mexican meal on the south side of Elmira. The breakfast menu here is a solid pick, especially the morning wraps that keep it simple and filling.
Taco Bell / KFC stands out by letting you mix and match your cravings with quick service, reasonable prices, and reliable flavors. Efficiency meets choice in every visit.
5. Roundin Third
Roundin Third is where Elmira’s sports crowd and food lovers come together. The first time I went, I expected the usual bar fare, but the menu surprised me with unexpected energy—Mexican options tucked beside familiar favorites.
Their veggie nachos are piled high, crisp, and rich with zesty toppings, making them a popular pick during game nights. The kitchen has a knack for delivering platters that are generous without losing their crunch or freshness.
Roundin Third stands out because it’s more than a sports spot. The blend of comfortable atmosphere and a menu with real variety means there’s always something new to try. This place proves you can enjoy nachos and never miss the seventh inning stretch.
6. Salsarita’s Fresh Cantina
(607) 739-9040Call
Salsarita’s Fresh Cantina brings a little bit of fun to every meal, thanks to its build-your-own approach and lively vibe. I first stopped in out of curiosity and ended up building the best rice bowl I’ve ever had. The counter setup makes it easy to pick your own fresh toppings, so every visit can be a completely different experience.
If you’re in a hurry but craving big flavor, try their burrito bowl with grilled vegetables and house-made salsas. Each bite tastes fresh and bright, which is what sets this place apart from the rest.
Salsarita’s keeps things interesting with choices for vegetarians and anyone looking for a fast, tasty meal. It’s one of those spots where healthy and satisfying don’t feel at odds.
7. Moe’s Southwest Grill
Moe’s Southwest Grill is all about keeping things lively, from the energetic greeting at the door to the aroma of roasted peppers in the air. On my last visit, the line moved quickly, and every ingredient looked fresh—exactly what you want from a customizable spot. Every meal comes with free chips and salsa, a simple perk that never gets old.
If you’re unsure where to start, grab a burrito bowl with cilantro-lime rice, black beans, and extra pico de gallo; the flavors are distinct and bright, making for a filling and satisfying bite. For lighter fare, their salads let you pile on all the veggies and salsas you like.
Moe’s stands out by letting you call the shots with each order, so personal taste always comes first. Simple, tasty, and speedy every time.
8. Salsa’s
Salsa’s feels like a local favorite—the kind of place where you see big tables celebrating and regulars chatting with the staff. I dropped in one weekend and noticed right away how lively the atmosphere was, with plates arriving at every table in quick succession. Their vegetarian enchiladas are hard to beat: generous, packed with vegetables, and topped with a savory red sauce that tastes like it’s been cooked low and slow.
If you like fresh, bright flavors, their guacamole is a standout starter; creamy, chunky, and paired with perfectly crisp chips. Every dish looks and tastes homemade, offering real value.
Salsa’s stands out for its combination of friendly service and a menu that’s as reliable as it is colorful. This spot turns even a quiet lunch into a small celebration.
9. Little Boomers’ Burrito Bar
Little Boomers’ Burrito Bar is a spot where you pick your own adventure, right on Market Street. My first time inside, I was greeted by the energy of a busy lunch rush—and not a single person waiting looked impatient. That’s a good sign for any burrito joint. The made-to-order burritos are generous and fully customizable, each one arriving hot and neatly wrapped.
The veggie bowl is a favorite of mine: it’s packed with rice, black beans, salsa, and a mix of toppings you choose yourself. Every ingredient is fresh, and you never feel rushed making your selections.
This spot stands out for its lightning-fast service and family-run warmth, making it easy to grab a flavorful meal before exploring downtown Corning or heading back to Elmira.
10. Toto’s Mexican Restaurant
(607) 684-6009Call
Toto’s Mexican Restaurant feels like a cheerful spot to recharge in downtown Corning. On my first visit, I found the space cozy and filled with the aroma of seasoned vegetables and toasted spices. Their veggie tacos are a safe bet—warm tortillas filled with perfectly sautéed vegetables and just the right amount of house salsa.
The rice and beans on the side are always fluffy and flavorful, a great bonus when you’re hungry for something simple yet well-made. Service at Toto’s is laid-back but attentive, giving the space a homey feeling.
It’s easy to see why people return: friendly faces, quick meals, and generous portions on every plate make Toto’s stand out from the crowd.
More Things to Try in Elmira, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best Mexican restaurants in Elmira, NY?
Local favorites include Garcia’s Mexican Restaurant, Los Panchos, and Salsa’s. For quick service, tried-and-true options like Taco Bell and Moe’s Southwest Grill are also available nearby.
Are there vegetarian options at Mexican restaurants in Elmira?
Yes—most spots offer vegetarian-friendly choices. Dishes like veggie fajitas, burrito bowls, and cheese enchiladas are widely available.
Which Mexican restaurants are good for takeout?
Garcia’s, Little Boomers’ Burrito Bar, Salsa’s, and Salsarita’s Fresh Cantina all provide fast and reliable takeout service.
Do Mexican restaurants in Elmira offer group dining or catering?
Many do. Moe’s Southwest Grill and Salsarita’s Fresh Cantina have catering menus, while several local restaurants can accommodate large groups with a quick call ahead.
Is authentic Mexican food available in Elmira?
Yes—places like Los Panchos and Garcia’s pride themselves on serving classic, homemade dishes you won’t find in chains.