Craving superb Mexican food in Farmingville, NY is a journey worth savoring. Whether you think salsa belongs in the “mild” or “bring tissues” category, this area has something for everyone—if you know where to look. Farmingville’s Mexican food scene isn’t about endless chains or standard fare; it’s a flavorful patchwork of cozy diners, family-owned gems, and a few surprising spots you might not expect.
I’ve trekked from crunchy tacos to tender enchiladas, and tasted everything in between, looking for the standout flavors and genuine hospitality that define great Mexican cuisine. This list reflects many meals and miles, so you can skip hours spent scrolling and get straight to the good stuff. If you’re hungry for honest recommendations and reliable details (with no side of exaggeration), stay tuned—you’re in exactly the right place.
Where to find the best mexican restaurants in Farmingville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best mexican restaurants in Farmingville, NY:
- Fax Chix Restaurant
- Taco Bell
- Los Amigos Restaurant
- Don Taco Deli
- On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina
- Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille
- Viva Juan Mexican Restaurant
- Sabrosa Mexican Grill
- Moe’s Southwest Grill
- Taco El Primo Restaurant
1. Fax Chix Restaurant
Fax Chix Restaurant isn’t content to stick to the basics. Blending rich Mexican staples with a touch of Portuguese flair, this spot draws locals who know good food when they taste it. The setting is unfussy, more neighborhood gathering place than fancy eatery, but that’s part of its charm.
My first introduction here featured a plate of enchiladas smothered in their house-made salsa. The flavor had a warmth and depth that’s tough to find anywhere else in Farmingville. Tacos and tortas arrive generously filled, and you won’t leave hungry.
For a taste of Fax Chix’s best, try the fajitas—they come sizzling and piled high with peppers and onions, perfect for sharing. Street-style tacos also shine, delivering classic flavors with extra punch. If you’re lucky, stop by on a Sunday for their rotating specials.
2. Taco Bell
There’s a reason Taco Bell keeps showing up on lists like this—it’s fast, consistent, and endlessly customizable. It’s the dependable go-to when the craving hits late or you need something quick between errands around Farmingville.
My last visit involved a Crunchwrap Supreme, which turned out just as expected: warm, layered, and surprisingly satisfying. The convenience of online ordering means my food is almost always waiting for me, hot and ready, which doesn’t hurt either.
If you’re torn on what to get, the classic tacos keep things simple and familiar. The Cheesy Gordita Crunch stands out with its soft and crunchy shell combo, while the vegetarian options offer some nice variety. When you’re looking for value and speed, Taco Bell holds its own.
3. Los Amigos Restaurant
+1 631-846-9373
Los Amigos Restaurant feels like a secret shared among locals. This spot is all about genuine Mexican flavors and a laid-back, family-friendly vibe. It’s easy to settle in and lose track of time, especially when the scent of fresh cilantro drifts from the kitchen.
During my last meal here, the chicken tacos were the highlight—juicy, well-seasoned, and tucked into soft tortillas. The salsa had just enough zing to wake up the taste buds without overwhelming the dish. Portions strike the balance between generous and just right.
For something special, order enchiladas or the grilled shrimp tacos. Both reflect Los Amigos’ knack for combining freshness with bold seasoning. It’s the kind of place where every dish arrives full of heart and unmistakable flavor.
4. Don Taco Deli
Don Taco Deli may look unassuming, but inside you’ll find authentic Mexican flavors served with a side of neighborhood charm. This is the kind of place where regulars linger, drawn by classic recipes and honest service.
Their shrimp burrito is a personal favorite—packed with plump, well-seasoned shrimp, fresh veggies, and just enough spice. Each bite feels like comfort food with a hint of adventure. The tortillas are fresh, and the portions feel outright generous.
If you’re in the mood for something lighter, their chicken tacos come highly recommended. For a meal that feels quick but never rushed, Don Taco Deli is a local gem worth discovering.
5. On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina
On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina brings a Texas-sized flair to classic Mexican dishes near Farmingville. With freshly made chips and salsa starting every meal, it’s the kind of place that sets the right tone for casual gatherings and family dinners alike.
I’ve tried their fajitas more than once—they always arrive piping hot with colorful grilled veggies, and the aroma alone wins you over. The enchiladas and tacos come packed with bold, familiar flavors, perfect when you want something both comforting and satisfying.
For those torn between options, try a combo platter to sample a bit of everything. The friendly staff makes even a takeout order feel like a treat. On The Border delivers Tex-Mex with just the right balance of fun and flavor.
6. Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille
Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille builds its menu on a simple foundation: fresh ingredients and bold, authentic recipes. This spot in Selden, just a short drive from Farmingville, is a welcome change from the usual takeout rotation.
I tried their street tacos, and each bite delivered tender meat wrapped in warm, soft tortillas, finished with vibrant salsas that brought the flavors together perfectly. The guacamole is made to order—you can taste the difference, especially when paired with their house chips.
If you’re in the mood for something substantial, the grilled chicken burrito is both satisfying and perfectly balanced. Blue Tortilla stands out for those who crave genuine taste, not just a quick fix.
7. Viva Juan Mexican Restaurant
Viva Juan Mexican Restaurant is the kind of place where regulars greet the staff by name and newcomers feel at home right away. The menu is packed with Mexican classics, cooked with obvious care and attention. It’s ideal for a relaxed night out or a cozy lunch break.
During my last meal, the chicken enchiladas caught my attention—tender, flavorful, and generously covered in rich sauce. The rice and beans on the side had that just-right texture, showing the kitchen’s skill beyond the main dishes.
The veggie fajitas are a solid pick for anyone looking to mix things up. Every dish at Viva Juan has a home-cooked warmth that’s rare to find outside your own kitchen.
8. Sabrosa Mexican Grill
Sabrosa Mexican Grill is one of those places where flavors matter more than flash. This local favorite delivers authentic Mexican favorites in a friendly, inviting space inside the Kohl’s Plaza Shopping Center.
During my visits, the steak tacos always impress—they’re juicy, well-seasoned, and wrapped in soft tortillas that hold everything together just right. The rice bowls are hearty and loaded with fresh toppings, making them a smart choice when you want something filling but not heavy.
If you love heat, their homemade salsas are worth exploring. Sabrosa stands out for straightforward, delicious food that brings a little excitement to your lunch or dinner. Don’t be surprised if you find yourself planning a return visit after your first bite.
9. Moe’s Southwest Grill
Moe’s Southwest Grill is where customization rules and flavors stay bold. Free chips and salsa with every meal set the stage for a satisfying bite, whether you’re craving a classic burrito or something a little lighter.
I’m a fan of building my own bowl—choosing the exact blend of rice, beans, and fresh toppings. The burritos here are massive and packed with flavor, offering a perfect option when you want a hearty, quick meal.
The veggie quesadillas are a dependable pick, always melty and fresh from the grill. Moe’s stands out for letting you call the shots, all while making sure each order tastes great and leaves you full.
10. Taco El Primo Restaurant
Taco El Primo Restaurant manages to deliver authentic Mexican flavors in a setting that feels both lively and approachable. With menus available in both Spanish and English, it’s welcoming to everyone looking for genuine taste.
On my first visit, I couldn’t resist the al pastor tacos. The meat was perfectly spiced, and the toppings added a fresh, bright kick. The portions are just right—not too little, never over the top.
Don’t miss their chicken tortas or classic quesadillas. Each dish reflects El Primo’s commitment to quality and tradition. It’s the sort of place where you’ll find regulars and new fans alike, happy to dine in or enjoy a meal on the go.
More Things to Try in Farmingville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best Mexican restaurants in Farmingville, NY?
Some top picks include Fax Chix Restaurant, Los Amigos Restaurant, Sabrosa Mexican Grill, and Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille. Each offers unique dishes and welcoming service.
Do any Mexican restaurants in Farmingville offer vegetarian options?
Yes. Many places like Moe’s Southwest Grill, Sabrosa Mexican Grill, and Viva Juan offer vegetarian tacos, burritos, bowls, and salads with fresh, flavorful toppings.
Where can I find authentic street tacos in Farmingville?
Check out Don Taco Deli, Taco El Primo Restaurant, and Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille for classic street-style tacos, complete with plenty of fresh toppings.
Are there Mexican restaurants in Farmingville with takeout and delivery?
Nearly all the major spots—Fax Chix, Taco Bell, Moe’s, and On The Border—offer takeout and many have delivery options through third-party apps for extra convenience.
Which Mexican restaurants in Farmingville are family-friendly?
Many, including Los Amigos Restaurant, On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina, and Sabrosa Mexican Grill, provide relaxed spaces, kid-friendly menus, and easygoing atmosphere for the whole family.