Finding great Mexican food in Holbrook, NY is a bit like searching for hidden treasure—rewarding if you steer clear of the tourist traps and dig just deep enough. The area surprises with a colorful range of spots, from lively taquerias to sleek grills, each with their own take on tacos, burritos, and all the favorites. Every visit I’ve made has reminded me not to judge a place by its strip mall location; more than once, I discovered top-notch salsa or tortillas somewhere I least expected.
If you’ve ever debated where to go for dinner and wished you had an insider guide, you’re in good company. I’ve tasted my way through Holbrook’s options, trading tepid chips for the good stuff and sidestepping menus that confuse quantity with quality. If you want to skip the guesswork and find memorable plates and friendly faces, you’re in the right spot. The following guide breaks down the best Mexican restaurants in Holbrook so you can focus on enjoying your meal—no culinary missteps required.
Where to find the best mexican restaurants in Holbrook, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best mexican restaurants in Holbrook, NY:
- Habanero’s Tex Mex Inc
- Senor Taco Grill
- Señor Taco Mexican Grill & Bar
- On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina
- Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille
- Sabrosa Mexican Grill
- Maria’s
- Taco El Primo Restaurant
- Moe’s Southwest Grill
- Chimichanga Mexican Grill
1. Habanero’s Tex Mex Inc
If you’re after fresh flavors and no-fuss dining, Habanero’s Tex Mex Inc at 310 Main St checks both boxes. This is a place where you can walk in wearing jeans and leave convinced you’ve stumbled on a neighborhood secret. Every time I’ve dropped by, the laid-back setting and welcoming staff made the meal feel unhurried.
What sets Habanero’s apart is the way they balance bold Tex-Mex favorites with classics. The chicken fajitas arrive at the table still sizzling, layered with bell peppers and onions, while the grilled veggie tacos showcase their knack for simple ingredients done right. Don’t skip the homemade salsa or their rice—each bite is full of flavor.
Portions are generous, so come hungry or bring a friend. It’s local, no pretense, and always satisfying.
2. Senor Taco Grill
Senor Taco Grill is the type of place that wins you over long before you find your seat. Located at 480 Patchogue Holbrook Rd, it’s known for bright flavors and a lively, welcoming crowd. Every time I’ve stopped in, there’s a buzz—people laughing over bursting burritos or lining up for tacos fresh off the grill.
The menu isn’t just lengthy, it’s thoughtful. You’ll notice the difference right away in their grilled chicken tacos and the perfectly spiced bean and cheese burritos. I always order the street-style tacos, where each element is given attention for the perfect bite.
It’s clear that quality ingredients are at the heart of everything here, making Senor Taco Grill a must for anyone craving authentic taste without leaving Holbrook.
3. Señor Taco Mexican Grill & Bar
Señor Taco Mexican Grill & Bar brings a laid-back mood to 480 Patchogue Holbrook Rd, matching flavorful Mexican classics with a neighborhood feel. Every visit, I’m welcomed with quick service and a menu that caters to everyone, even those hunting for gluten-free options.
The kitchen makes every dish to order, and you can taste it in their veggie burrito and fish tacos. Both showcase freshness and balance rather than the usual heavy-handedness.
Chill out with friends over tortilla chips and their house-made guacamole—it’s the kind of place where you can linger without feeling rushed. The prices stay wallet-friendly, making this a great pick for anyone in Holbrook looking for value and true flavors on the same plate.
4. On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina
Just a short drive from Holbrook, On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina in Holtsville has made a habit of starting every day fresh. The atmosphere buzzes, thanks to families, friends, and generous portions that keep everyone at the table just a little longer. My favorite moments here have started with warm, house-made chips and that famous salsa, easily some of the best to dip into.
The menu covers all the Tex-Mex classics, but the veggie fajitas and black bean enchiladas are where On The Border truly shines. Each bite is thoughtfully seasoned and satisfying without feeling heavy. Their customizable plates also make it easy to find something you’ll actually crave later.
If you’re looking for kid-friendly choices or group platters for sharing, this spot makes everyone feel at home—no shortcuts, just reliable flavors and relaxed vibes.
5. Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille
If you like your Mexican food with a little extra heart, Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille in Selden serves up plates with real spirit. Tucked away in the Coram-Selden Professional Building, this spot feels like you’ve found a local favorite. My steamy lunch on a chilly day included house-made tortillas—the kind that give each taco its own character.
The menu offers everything from simple street tacos to hearty burrito bowls, but it’s the veggie quesadillas and chile rellenos that keep me coming back. The food manages to be both fresh and deeply flavorful, a testament to their “fresh” claim.
Blue Tortilla stands out for made-to-order plates and warm, unpretentious service. If you crave authentic taste and care about what goes into your meal, this place belongs on your list.
6. Sabrosa Mexican Grill
Sabrosa Mexican Grill at the Kohl’s Plaza in Ronkonkoma feels like a welcome pause from the usual lunch rush. The first time I tried their food, I noticed how every ingredient seemed intentionally chosen—fresh and bold in every bite. Even the simple black beans had depth.
Sabrosa stands out for its generous salads and loaded burrito bowls. The grilled veggie bowl is a personal favorite; it strikes a great balance between hearty and healthy. For taco lovers, the soft corn tortillas hold up well under savory fillings like spiced potatoes and sautéed peppers.
Priced right and quick to serve, this is a spot for both the regular and the newcomer who wants unfussy, satisfying Mexican food near Holbrook.
7. Maria’s
Maria’s in Nesconset is a local standout that blends Mexican warmth with classic style. My first visit was on a rainy evening when I found the dining room buzzing and the aromas even more inviting. It’s one of those places where you can sit down for a quiet meal or arrive with a group and feel right at home.
The menu at Maria’s is surprisingly diverse, with a strong showing of both Latin comfort food and Mexican staples. The enchiladas verdes showcase tangy green sauce layered with melty cheese, while the grilled vegetable tacos are fresh without sacrificing flavor. Their house-made salsas are also worth a mention.
Maria’s stands out for attentive service, generous portions, and a sense that every plate is made with pride. It’s a cozy, reliable pick for a flavorful Mexican meal near Holbrook.
8. Taco El Primo Restaurant
Taco El Primo Restaurant is the place you stumble on, then wonder why you hadn’t tried it sooner. Set on Portion Rd, it flies under the radar, but the food makes a lasting impression. My first visit was for a quick takeout, but I ended up staying because the aromas pulled me in.
This spot’s charm lies in its straightforward approach and bilingual menus. You’ll want to try the grilled veggie tacos—warm tortillas, well-seasoned vegetables, and bright cilantro come together perfectly. The bean tostadas are crispy, hearty, and just right for sharing or a solo treat.
Taco El Primo isn’t about flash; it’s honest, flavorful food served with genuine hospitality. If you’re craving authentic Mexican near Holbrook without the crowds, this is your place.
9. Moe’s Southwest Grill
Moe’s Southwest Grill on College Rd in Selden offers Mexican-inspired comfort with a make-it-your-way vibe. I first wandered in on a busy afternoon, face-to-face with a long counter of colorful ingredients, and realized this spot is all about choice. It’s a place where the staff remembers your go-to salsa and helps you pile on the extras.
The atmosphere always feels upbeat, whether you’re grabbing lunch solo or noshing with friends. The customizable rice bowls and overfilled veggie burritos come recommended, letting you control every topping from black beans to fresh pico de gallo. Every meal comes with free chips and salsa, and their seasonal creations are always worth a try.
For fast, casual Mexican near Holbrook, Moe’s mixes fresh options with plenty of personality. It’s quick, affordable, and never boring.
10. Chimichanga Mexican Grill
(631) 737-8080Call
Chimichanga Mexican Grill on Portion Rd draws regulars for a reason: the food is consistently fresh and the setting stays casual. My first takeout experience here ended with me savoring salsa in the car, a sign the flavors were hard to resist even before reaching home.
The menu covers all the classics, but the vegetarian chimichanga hits that perfect balance between crispy shell and savory filling. Their grilled veggie tacos shine, too, managing both zest and comfort in every bite. Portions are more than generous, so sharing is encouraged—or saving leftovers for round two.
Chimichanga Mexican Grill stands out for food that’s satisfying without shortcuts. It’s the kind of neighborhood spot you find yourself returning to again and again.
More Things to Try in Holbrook, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are some of the best Mexican restaurants in Holbrook, NY?
Local favorites include Habanero’s Tex Mex Inc, Senor Taco Grill, Taco El Primo Restaurant, and Chimichanga Mexican Grill. Each spot offers its own style, from classic tacos to creative burrito bowls.
Are there vegetarian or vegan options at Mexican restaurants in Holbrook?
Yes, most Mexican restaurants in the area have generous vegetarian and vegan offerings. Look for dishes like veggie fajitas, bean and cheese burritos, grilled veggie tacos, or salads loaded with fresh toppings.
Can I find kid-friendly Mexican restaurants in Holbrook?
Absolutely. Spots like On The Border and Moe’s Southwest Grill are known for their family-friendly menus, relaxed atmospheres, and options tailored for younger diners.
Do Holbrook area Mexican restaurants offer takeout or delivery?
Nearly all of them provide both. Online ordering and third-party delivery apps make it easy to enjoy your favorite Mexican food at home.
Are there Mexican restaurants in Holbrook where you can host a group or event?
Yes, places like Maria’s and On The Border can handle groups and offer plenty of seating, making them suitable for celebrations or gatherings.