Finding great Mexican food in Hurley, NY isn’t a chore—it’s more like a fun treasure hunt, especially when you know where to look. Over the years, I’ve sampled sizzling tacos under string lights, devoured enchiladas with the ideal cheese pull, and discovered guacamole so good it made me rethink how I view avocados. Each spot brings its own flair, from laid-back family eateries to bold new favorites tucked away in cozy corners.
With all these choices, it can feel overwhelming to sort through the options and land that spot with just the right flavors. That’s why this guide takes the guesswork out of your search. Every restaurant mentioned here offers something unique, authentic, and delicious. If you’re aiming for a dinner with friends, a solo lunch, or just a craving for a perfect burrito, you’ll find the right spot here. Keep reading to unlock platefuls of bold flavors without the hassle.
Where to find the best mexican restaurants in Hurley, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best mexican restaurants in Hurley, NY:
- Casa Villa Mexican Restaurant
- Mole Mole
- Rosita’s Mexican Restaurant
- Armadillo Bar & Grill
- El Jaguar Restaurant
- Sky View Mexican Restaurant
- Rosita’s Mexican Restaurant Inc
- Alebrijes
- Diego’s Taqueria
- Taqueria Poblano
1. Casa Villa Mexican Restaurant
Casa Villa Mexican Restaurant has a warm, easygoing vibe that feels welcoming whether you’re new or a regular. The bright murals set the scene but the true highlight is the menu, which delivers real Mexican comfort food every time.
What sets Casa Villa apart is their attention to freshness. On one visit, the perfectly spiced salsa and house-made tortillas turned an ordinary meal into something memorable. If you’re after flavor with no frills, try their chicken enchiladas with a smoky red sauce—they’re a staple for a reason.
Vegetarian options also shine, from the vibrant grilled veggie fajitas to the classic cheese-stuffed chiles. There’s no rush here, just honest cooking in a cozy spot. Casa Villa makes a simple case for coming back again and again.
2. Mole Mole
(845) 338-4765Call
Mole Mole is where you go when you want vibrant flavors with a lighter touch. This spot proves that Mexican cuisine can be both fresh and satisfying. On a sunny afternoon, I grabbed a seat by the window and enjoyed a plate of tangy lime-infused guacamole that set the tone for the whole meal.
The menu focuses on classic dishes done simply and well. The veggie tacos are a standout—piled high with crisp greens and a squeeze of lime, they deliver full flavor without heaviness. If you’re a fan of bold sauces, try their namesake mole; its gentle warmth ties every bite together.
Mole Mole is easy on the wallet and reliably tasty. It’s the kind of place you’ll want to revisit whenever a craving hits.
3. Rosita’s Mexican Restaurant
Rosita’s Mexican Restaurant feels like a local secret you’re lucky to find. The dining room is always buzzing, but there’s a laid-back charm that makes every meal feel easy. I once popped in on a rainy day and the warmth of the staff made the gray afternoon a lot brighter.
Rosita’s is known for simple, homemade comfort food at wallet-friendly prices. Their tamales are a reliable favorite—warm, lightly spiced, and wrapped just right. If you’re after something a bit zestier, the shrimp tacos carry a bright flavor that speaks for itself.
Portions are generous and flavors never feel rushed. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, Rosita’s makes sure every meal feels like it was made just for you.
4. Armadillo Bar & Grill
Armadillo Bar & Grill is a real Kingston fixture, blending modern twists with traditional flavors for over thirty years. It’s easy to spot regulars on the patio, chatting beneath flower-filled awnings. I still think about the night I tried their fresh salsa—crisp, bright, and made right in-house.
What sets Armadillo apart is its inventive menu. Don’t miss the shrimp-stuffed jalapeños; their signature heat mingles with just the right touch of citrus. The grilled seafood and steak fajitas are also worth a special trip, arriving sizzling and packed with flavor.
Vegans and vegetarians will feel right at home here. Gluten-free diners also get plenty of choices, so everyone leaves happy. This is the kind of spot that brings people together over good food and easygoing company.
5. El Jaguar Restaurant
El Jaguar Restaurant sets itself apart by fusing Guatemalan and Mexican flavors, creating a dining experience that’s anything but ordinary. On my first visit, I was greeted with the aroma of sizzling spices and warm smiles from the staff. The space is spotless, cozy, and clearly run with care.
The house-made pupusas and tamales stand out for their freshness—soft, savory, and paired with zesty sides that wake up every bite. You’ll also find classic tacos crafted with top-notch ingredients, always prepared to order.
El Jaguar’s menu invites you to try something new while staying true to authentic roots. If you want variety and a taste of tradition, this spot delivers every time.
6. Sky View Mexican Restaurant
Sky View Mexican Restaurant matches its inviting name with a laid-back atmosphere and friendly service. I remember sitting near the window as sunlight spilled in, snacking on crunchy tortilla chips while scanning their wide-ranging menu. It’s an easy place to linger with friends or family and share a leisurely meal.
Sky View is known for its hearty portions and bright flavors. The steak fajitas arrive sizzling, never short on color or spice, while the veggie quesadillas hit that perfect balance of crisp and cheesy. Even their sides—think fresh pico de gallo and rice—up the ante.
With both English and Spanish spoken, everyone feels welcome. For generous plates and a relaxed setting, Sky View never misses the mark.
7. Rosita’s Mexican Restaurant Inc
Rosita’s Mexican Restaurant Inc in Port Ewen delivers a family-friendly take on classic Mexican cooking. There’s a neighborly feel in the dining room, where laughter drifts between tables and the staff treat you like a regular from day one. My last visit was on a quiet weekday, and watching the kitchen send out colorful plates felt oddly comforting.
Rosita’s gives you reliable, hearty meals without fuss or pretense. The chicken burritos here come packed and perfectly rolled—never skimpy, always satisfying. Their fresh guacamole also deserves a moment of attention, smooth and seasoned with a deft hand.
Come for the old-school charm, stay for the homemade taste. Rosita’s makes every meal feel like a family get-together.
8. Alebrijes
(845) 853-8388Call
Alebrijes is the kind of spot that takes pride in every detail, blending Mexican tradition with a bit of playful creativity. The décor is bright and artsy, giving you that first hint you’re in for something special. I stopped in with friends and found the energy infectious—every table seemed to be enjoying a new discovery.
The menu at Alebrijes is where it truly shines. Don’t miss the enchiladas verdes, layered with tangy tomatillo sauce and packed with fresh ingredients. The tacos dorados also deliver, served crispy and generous, with all the toppings just right.
The vibe is cheerful and the food never feels rushed. If you’re after both style and substance, Alebrijes hits the mark every time.
9. Diego’s Taqueria
Diego’s Taqueria is a downtown favorite that packs a punch with simple, gutsy flavors. There’s an easygoing buzz to the place—a steady hum of conversation and clinking plates. My most memorable visit involved sharing a small mountain of street tacos, each one better than the last, beneath the glow of vintage string lights.
At Diego’s, the focus is on freshness and a menu that changes up just enough to keep things interesting. Their carne asada tacos are always a crowd-pleaser, but the potato and poblano version wins for sheer comfort. Pair your pick with house salsas for an extra kick.
Expect quick service and full flavors. It’s the go-to spot when all you want is really good tacos and no distractions.
10. Taqueria Poblano
Taqueria Poblano keeps things unfussy with a focus on big flavors and friendly service. Hidden away on Van Buren Street, it’s easy to miss, but once inside you’re greeted with deep, savory aromas and genuine smiles. My first visit ended with a new go-to for quick, fresh Mexican food in the area.
The house favorite here is the classic poblano pepper tacos, filled with just the right heat and paired with bright salsas. Their vegetarian offerings are far from an afterthought—in fact, the bean and cheese tacos are as memorable as any meat option on the menu.
Taqueria Poblano is made for casual drop-ins and spur-of-the-moment cravings. If you want time-honored recipes done right, you’ll find them here.
More Things to Try in Hurley, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best Mexican restaurants near Hurley, NY?
Some top picks include Casa Villa Mexican Restaurant, Mole Mole, and Diego’s Taqueria. Each offers a unique twist, from homestyle classics to modern street food style fare.
Are there any vegetarian or vegan options?
Absolutely. Many Mexican restaurants in the area, such as Armadillo Bar & Grill and Taqueria Poblano, provide plenty of vegetarian and vegan dishes including veggie fajitas, bean tacos, and salads.
Can I find gluten-free options at Mexican restaurants in Hurley?
Yes, places like Armadillo Bar & Grill and Sky View Mexican Restaurant offer gluten-free choices like corn tortillas, rice bowls, and fresh salsas. Always let your server know about dietary needs.
Do these restaurants offer takeout or delivery?
Most local favorites provide takeout, and many offer delivery through popular apps or direct phone orders. Check individual websites or call ahead for details.
Which restaurant is best for families?
Rosita’s Mexican Restaurant Inc and Casa Villa are loved by families for their relaxed atmosphere, generous portions, and kid-friendly menus.