Tracking down the best Mexican restaurants in Ithaca, NY is easier said than done. The local food scene packs more surprises than a piñata at a birthday party. Over the years, I’ve followed the scent of cumin and roasted peppers through side streets and main avenues, from colorful taquerias next to Cayuga Lake to cozy cantinas tucked away from campus crowds. My appetite has endured mild salsa mishaps and tortilla triumphs alike.
The city’s choices shift from lively spots with bustling patios, to unfussy counters where you can hear Spanish guitar and the sizzle from the grill. Whether you crave classics or clever twists, there’s a spot that fits the mood. Curious where to find the best tacos, burritos, or mole in town? I’ve got every corner covered, so you can decide where your next Mexican meal should begin.
Where to find the best mexican restaurants in Ithaca, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best mexican restaurants in Ithaca, NY:
- Viva Taqueria & Cantina
- Old Mexico
- Zocalo Mexican Bar & Grill
- Bickering Twins
- Chili’s Grill & Bar
- Taco Bell
- Chipotle Mexican Grill
- Moe’s Southwest Grill
- Gorgers Taco Shack
- Village Tuaqueria And Grill
1. Viva Taqueria & Cantina
Viva Taqueria & Cantina sits right on East State Street, buzzing with energy and color. It’s the kind of spot where the salsa is always fresh, and so are the conversations. I’ve lingered over piping-hot enchiladas here while watching the world outside swirl past.
What sets Viva apart is its welcoming vibe and a menu built for everyone. Vegetarians, vegans, and gluten-free diners will all find something flavorful. Their tacos are quirky yet classic, stuffed with fillings that make you reconsider your usual order.
For a perfect plate, try the chile relleno or grilled veggie tacos. The house-made guacamole is rich and tangy, made to be devoured scoop by scoop. You’ll know you’ve picked the right place as soon as you take that first bite.
2. Old Mexico
Old Mexico brings a touch of tradition to the Ithaca restaurant scene. Tucked along Elmira Road, the space feels spacious but still warm—ideal for everything from casual lunches to lingering dinners. On my last visit, the scent of grilled peppers and spices hit as soon as I stepped inside, immediately setting the mood for something memorable.
This spot stands out for its careful attention to authenticity. Vegetarians and gluten-free diners will find options that don’t skimp on flavor or originality. The friendly staff make even a quick meal feel relaxed.
If you go, try the vegetarian enchiladas or sizzling fajitas. Both are vibrant, hearty, and loaded with the kind of fresh ingredients that keep regulars coming back for more.
3. Zocalo Mexican Bar & Grill
Zocalo Mexican Bar & Grill is a favorite for anyone searching for fresh flavors set in a lively atmosphere. Just off Catherwood Road, the dining room is always buzzing, especially during dinner hours. One evening, I snagged a window seat and found myself transported—unhurried, plates arriving with colors as vivid as the murals on the walls.
This spot stands out for their creative takes on Mexican classics. The menu offers vegetarian choices, and their attention to detail shows in every bite. That extra squeeze of lime or a sprinkle of fresh cilantro? It makes all the difference.
Order the quesadillas or go for the grilled vegetable tacos. Both highlight Zocalo’s knack for balancing bold seasoning with bright, honest flavors that make the whole meal memorable.
4. Bickering Twins
Bickering Twins brings Latin American flavor with a twist right to the heart of Ithaca. On Cayuga Street, the restaurant buzzes with laughter and the aroma of fresh masa. It’s the place I go when I want tacos that surprise me each visit.
What makes Bickering Twins truly special is its inventive take on tradition. Each menu item is carefully crafted—expect colorful plates, zesty salsas, and satisfying plant-based options. Even the guacamole gets a playful upgrade here.
Don’t miss the sweet potato tacos and their empanadas. Both are layered with thoughtful spices and fresh toppings, capturing the restaurant’s fun, welcoming style. If you want to try something beyond the basic taco, this is where you’ll find your new favorite.
5. Chili’s Grill & Bar
Chili’s Grill & Bar holds its own as a familiar favorite for Mexican-inspired eats in Ithaca. It’s the kind of place where the menu stretches long and you always know what to expect—a real comfort on busy nights. I’ve stopped in more than once, lured by that unmistakable scent of freshly cooked tortillas.
While the feel is decidedly casual, Chili’s serves plates big enough to share and flavors that fit almost any craving. Service is quick, and the space is laid-back enough for families and friends alike.
The Fajita Trio is a crowd-pleaser, arriving at the table steaming and sizzling. Their Veggie Quesadillas are another winning pick, loaded with melted cheese and crisp vegetables, perfect for a quick fix or a lingering meal.
6. Taco Bell
Taco Bell on Elmira Road is a mainstay for quick, customizable Mexican-inspired bites any time of day. The drive-thru line moves swiftly, making it the obvious stop when you crave something speedy without sacrificing flavor. I’ve grabbed a late-night snack here more times than I can count, grateful for the reliable menu and fast service.
What makes Taco Bell stand out is how flexible and affordable it is. The build-your-own options mean you always get exactly what you want. The staff is used to special requests and don’t bat an eyelash at modifications.
Try the Bean Burrito or the ever-popular Crunchwrap Supreme. Both hit that sweet spot between hearty and flavorful, perfect for anyone after a fast, satisfying meal in Ithaca.
7. Chipotle Mexican Grill
Chipotle Mexican Grill on S Meadow Street draws steady crowds for its made-to-order bowls and burritos. The moment you step in, the aroma of warm rice and grilled veggies makes the wait worthwhile. I’ve spent enough lunch breaks here to have my order down to a science—there’s comfort in knowing each meal starts fresh, every single time.
Chipotle thrives on quality and consistency. The menu is delightfully straightforward, so customization is fast and easy. You can load up on beans, veggies, and salsas until your burrito barely rolls shut—perfect for big appetites or lighter eaters alike.
The go-to here is the classic Vegetarian Burrito Bowl, packed with fajita veggies, beans, and a bright cilantro-lime rice. The fresh guacamole, perfectly tangy, always earns a spot on my order for that extra burst of flavor.
8. Moe’s Southwest Grill
Moe’s Southwest Grill on Elmira Road is where I turn for big flavors, fast service, and friendly faces behind the counter. There’s an energy here—a casual buzz that sets it apart from other quick stops. Whether grabbing takeout for a hike or a sit-down lunch, Moe’s feels like a treat.
The customization at Moe’s is a huge win. Each visit, you’re handed a vast array of toppings, so piling on your favorites is part of the fun. The staff always nails my complicated orders, whether I’m in a hurry or settling in for a meal.
I recommend the Homewrecker Burrito (vegetarian) or a crunchy Vegetarian Taco Stack. Both bring bold southwest flavors with plenty of fresh salsa and guac, reflecting Moe’s knack for tasty, crowd-pleasing bites.
9. Gorgers Taco Shack
Gorgers Taco Shack gives the downtown taco scene a fresh punch of attitude and taste. Tucked into E State Street, the place is easy to miss unless you’re following your nose. I ended up here on a whim and left plotting my return—the flavors didn’t disappoint.
This spot’s edge is all about boldness and variety. Each taco packs a different twist, and the toppings reach beyond the usual. It feels like a spot designed for the adventurous and the hungry alike.
The smartest move? Dive into the black bean tacos or try a build-your-own option. The house salsas bring real zing, and each bite captures the laid-back but inventive spirit that keeps Gorgers on my shortlist.
10. Village Tuaqueria And Grill
Village Tuaqueria And Grill is worth the short drive to Dryden if you’re hunting for homestyle Mexican in a laid-back, welcoming spot. I first stumbled in on a rainy evening, and found the warmth inside matched only by the flavors coming out of the kitchen. The friendly staff makes new diners feel like regulars on the first visit.
This taqueria’s stand-out feature is its devotion to authentic taste and well-balanced plates. Each dish reflects the time and care put into the recipes, giving the menu a homemade charm you don’t often find.
If you go, get the veggie burrito or the street-style tacos. Both show off simple, fresh ingredients and reflect why Village Tuaqueria And Grill continues to win loyal fans near Ithaca.
More Things to Try in Ithaca, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the best Mexican restaurant in Ithaca for vegetarian options?
Viva Taqueria & Cantina leads the pack with plenty of vegetarian and vegan choices. Bickering Twins and Old Mexico also offer delicious plant-based dishes with creative touches.
Are there any Mexican restaurants near Cornell University?
Yes, Viva Taqueria & Cantina is a hotspot a short walk from campus. Zocalo Mexican Bar & Grill and Gorgers Taco Shack are convenient options if you’re looking for variety nearby.
Which places offer takeout or delivery?
Most spots, including Chipotle, Moe’s Southwest Grill, Taco Bell, and Chili’s Grill & Bar, provide easy takeout. Delivery is available through popular apps for many of these restaurants.
Where can I find authentic Mexican street tacos?
Village Tuaqueria And Grill and Gorgers Taco Shack are known for their street-style tacos packed with fresh ingredients and bold flavor.
Are gluten-free options available at Mexican restaurants in Ithaca?
Yes, several restaurants like Viva Taqueria & Cantina and Old Mexico have strong gluten-free menus, making dining out safe and easy for everyone.