Discovering the best Mexican restaurants in Long Island, NY, can feel like a flavorful treasure hunt. Over the years, I’ve explored numerous spots, each offering a unique twist on traditional favorites. Whether it’s a bustling cantina with vibrant decor or a cozy family-owned flag-ship serving authentic dishes, Long Island has a rich variety of options. This diversity ensures that every craving can be satisfied, from spicy street tacos to hearty burritos and refreshing margaritas crafted with precision.
My journey through Long Island’s Mexican cuisine has been both delicious and eye-opening. I’ve found hidden gems that excel in ingredients and presentation, yet remain affordable. In this guide, I aim to share top choices that consistently impress locals and visitors alike. If you’re seeking a memorable dining experience filled with authentic flavors and warm atmospheres, you’re about to uncover some excellent options. Rest assured, these selections are tried and loved by many, making your quest for the perfect Mexican meal both easy and enjoyable.
Where to find the best mexican restaurants in Long Island, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best mexican restaurants in Long Island, NY:
- On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina
- Green Cactus
- Vallarta Mexican Grill
- Sabrosa Mexican Grill
- Maria’s
- Taco El Primo Restaurant
- Moe’s Southwest Grill
- Right Coast Taqueria
- Cabo Fresh Mexican Grill
- Senor Taco Mexican Grill
1. On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina
Located at 45 Middle Ave in Holtsville, On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina offers a vibrant take on Tex-Mex cuisine. I vividly remember visiting after a long day, greeted by the aroma of freshly made chips and salsa—an inviting start. Their menu showcases a variety of flavorful dishes like crispy tacos, sizzling fajitas, and hearty burritos, all prepared with fresh ingredients and authentic spices.
What sets On The Border apart is their commitment to creating a family-friendly atmosphere while serving high-quality, flavorful fare. For a true taste of their style, try the Fajitas Grande or the House Made Enchiladas, both bursting with rich flavors. Pair with a classic margarita or refreshing beer for an authentic dining experience in Long Island. Whether dining in or opting for takeout, this spot consistently delivers satisfying Tex-Mex classics.
2. Green Cactus
(631) 567-8226Call
Located at 1274 Montauk Hwy in Oakdale, Green Cactus Mexican Grill offers a cozy yet lively atmosphere. I recall stopping by on a quiet evening and being greeted with warm hospitality. Their menu highlights authentic Mexican and Latin American dishes, making it a great spot for casual dining in Long Island.
What makes Green Cactus stand out is its affordable prices combined with flavorful, well-prepared food. I recommend trying their Fajitas or the Traditional Tacos. Both dishes reflect their commitment to authentic flavors and quality ingredients. Whether you dine in or take out, Green Cactus provides satisfying Mexican cuisine that simply hits the spot.
3. Vallarta Mexican Grill
Situated at 601 Veterans Hwy in Hauppauge, Vallarta Mexican Grill offers an inviting atmosphere filled with authentic flavors. I remember visiting during a busy dinner hour, and the staff’s friendly service made the experience even better. Their menu showcases a variety of traditional Mexican and Latin American dishes made with fresh ingredients.
What makes Vallarta stand out is their consistent quality and affordability. For a classic choice, try the Carne Asada Tacos or the Enchiladas Verdes. Both dishes beautifully reflect their commitment to authentic, flavorful cuisine. Whether you dine in or order takeout, Vallarta Mexican Grill provides satisfying meals that celebrate genuine Mexican taste.
4. Sabrosa Mexican Grill
Located at 131 Ronkonkoma Ave within Kohl’s Plaza, Sabrosa Mexican Grill is a go-to spot for flavorful Mexican and Latin American cuisine. I visited on a weekend and was impressed by the warm, welcoming atmosphere. Their menu features a variety of authentic dishes made with fresh ingredients, perfect for a casual yet satisfying meal.
What makes Sabrosa stand out is their commitment to quality and vibrant flavors. I recommend the Grilled Steak Tacos and Chile Relleno. Both dishes showcase their dedication to authentic taste and hearty portions. Whether dining in or ordering takeout, Sabrosa Mexican Grill offers a true taste of Mexico with every bite.
5. Maria’s
Located at 211 Smithtown Blvd in Nesconset, Maria’s offers a diverse culinary experience blending Mexican, Latin American, and European flavors. I once visited on a lively weekend evening and was struck by the inviting ambiance and friendly service. Their menu showcases a variety of dishes that reflect a passion for authentic tastes.
What makes Maria’s stand out is its ability to deliver quality across multiple cuisines with an elegant touch. I highly recommend trying the Enchiladas Verdes or the Seafood Paella. Both dishes exemplify their commitment to authentic ingredients and flavorful preparation. Whether dining in or ordering takeout, Maria’s provides an appealing fusion of flavors that satisfy the craving for genuine, well-prepared cuisine.
6. Taco El Primo Restaurant
Located at 704 Portion Rd in Lake Ronkonkoma, Taco El Primo Restaurant offers a casual and welcoming atmosphere with options for sit-down or takeout service. I enjoyed visiting here after a busy day, and the bilingual menus made ordering easy and accessible. Their menu features a mix of authentic Mexican and Latin American dishes with a focus on fresh ingredients.
What makes Taco El Primo stand out is their friendly staff and authentic flavors. I recommend trying the Pollo Asado Tacos and the Chiles Rellenos. Both dishes highlight their commitment to delicious, authentic cuisine. Whether you choose dine-in or takeout, Taco El Primo delivers satisfying Mexican flavors that reflect their dedication to quality and tradition.
7. Moe’s Southwest Grill
Located in Hauppauge Plaza, Moe’s Southwest Grill provides a vibrant setting for casual Mexican-inspired dining. I visited during lunch and appreciated their welcoming atmosphere and fresh, customizable options. Their menu features burritos, bowls, tacos, and nachos, all made with quality ingredients.
What makes Moe’s stand out is their fun, laid-back vibe and generous servings. I recommend trying the Joey Bag of Donuts or the Outlaw Burrito. Both dishes showcase their bold flavors and fresh ingredients. Whether dining in or takeaway, Moe’s consistently delivers satisfying Mexican cuisine with a modern twist.
8. Right Coast Taqueria
Located at 101 Hawkins Ave in Ronkonkoma, Right Coast Taqueria offers a casual spot for authentic Mexican flavors. I stopped by during a weekend outing and was immediately struck by the inviting atmosphere and fresh, vibrant ingredients. Their menu features tacos, burritos, and bowls with a focus on quality and bold tastes.
What makes Right Coast stand out is their dedication to fresh, flavorful ingredients and a laid-back vibe. I recommend trying their Fish Tacos or the Grilled Chicken Burrito. Both dishes reflect their commitment to authentic, delicious Mexican cuisine. Whether you dine in or opt for takeout, this spot provides satisfying flavors in every bite.
9. Cabo Fresh Mexican Grill
(631) 580-2226Call
Located at 100 Portion Rd in Ronkonkoma, Cabo Fresh Mexican Grill offers a casual dining experience with a focus on fresh, made-to-order Mexican dishes. I visited on a sunny afternoon and appreciated their vibrant, clean atmosphere. The menu features classic favorites like tacos, burritos, and bowls, all crafted with quality ingredients.
What makes Cabo Fresh unique is their commitment to freshness and customization. I recommend trying their Grilled Steak Tacos or the Vegetarian Burrito. Both showcase their dedication to authentic flavors and fresh preparation. Whether you’re dining in or getting takeout, Cabo Fresh Mexican Grill provides satisfying, flavorful meals that reflect their high standards for quality and taste.
10. Senor Taco Mexican Grill
(631) 676-4011Call
Located at 295 Smithtown Blvd in Ronkonkoma, Senor Taco Mexican Grill is a popular spot for quick, flavorful Mexican bites. I visited during a busy lunch rush and found the friendly staff and aromatic dishes inviting. Their menu features classic favorites like tacos, burritos, and quesadillas made with fresh ingredients.
What makes Senor Taco stand out is its emphasis on quick service and authentic flavors. I highly recommend the Carne Asada Tacos and the Chicken Quesadilla. Both dishes capture the essence of genuine Mexican cuisine. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or dining in, Senor Taco offers satisfying meals that celebrate true Mexican tastes in Long Island.
More Things to Try in Long Island, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are some of the best Mexican restaurants in Long Island, NY? Long Island offers a variety of top-rated Mexican eateries such as On The Border, Green Cactus, and Vallarta Mexican Grill. These spots are known for authentic flavors, fresh ingredients, and vibrant atmospheres.
Are Mexican restaurants in Long Island family-friendly? Yes, many Mexican restaurants, including On The Border and Maria’s, provide welcoming environments suitable for families. They often have kid-friendly menus and casual settings perfect for group dining.
Do these restaurants offer takeout or delivery options? Most Mexican restaurants in Long Island, including Moe’s Southwest Grill and Taco El Primo, provide takeout and delivery services, making it easy to enjoy delicious Mexican food at home.
Are there vegetarian or vegan options available? Yes, many places such as Cabo Fresh and Right Coast Taqueria offer vegetarian and vegan choices like veggie tacos, bowls, and salads to accommodate different dietary preferences.