Looking for good Mexican food in Nanuet, NY is like joining a secret club—once you’ve found the real spots, you never go back to bland, chain-restaurant burritos. I still remember wandering into a tiny taqueria off Route 59 and being served a plate of tacos that tasted so fresh, I spent the next week defending their superiority to anyone within earshot. Whether you’re chasing after the smoky spice of authentic salsa or you simply need a mountain of guacamole to brighten your day, Nanuet makes it surprisingly easy to find your fix.
Navigating the area’s options can get overwhelming. From casual counters to family-run gems and nationwide names that actually deliver on flavor, each place on this list serves something worth trying. If you’ve ever stood in a parking lot, phone glowing with reviews, second-guessing your next meal—this guide is for you. Read on and uncover where you’ll be ordering your new favorite plate (and why some of the smaller joints may just outshine the biggest names).
Where to find the best mexican restaurants in Nanuet, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best mexican restaurants in Nanuet, NY:
- Chili’s Grill & Bar
- Estrella’s Cafe
- The Sombrero Tacoria Nanuet
- Taqueria America #2
- Taco Bell / Kfc
- Chipotle Mexican Grill
- La Cascada
- Moe’s Southwest Grill
- Qdoba Mexican Grill
- Dos Agaves
1. Chili’s Grill & Bar
Chili’s Grill & Bar at 255 E Route 59 brings a relaxed, inviting atmosphere with a Southwestern flair. The vibe is comfortable, perfect for lingering over lunch or making a casual family dinner feel special. The sizzling fajitas here are a must-try—delivered on a hot skillet, they turn heads every time. It’s tough to resist the aroma of freshly grilled veggies and spiced chicken or steak, all served with soft tortillas.
I once dropped in after a long day and couldn’t help but order their classic fajitas and a big plate of chips with house-made salsa. The flavors are bold, and portions satisfy even on hearty appetites. For approachable Tex-Mex that never overwhelms, Chili’s is a reliable pick in Nanuet.
2. Estrella’s Cafe
Tucked along Main Street, Estrella’s Cafe radiates warmth and small-town charm. The staff greets regulars by name, and newcomers fit in fast. I dropped in for a quiet brunch and was treated to huevos rancheros so good I almost ordered seconds. It’s the sort of place where every plate feels homemade.
What truly sets Estrella’s apart is their variety of vegan and vegetarian options—a rarity among local Mexican spots. Their veggie tacos, bursting with grilled peppers and fresh avocado, are both colorful and full of flavor. If you’re looking for something classic, the enchiladas offer that balance of zest and comfort that’s hard to beat. Whether you’re in for breakfast or dinner, Estrella’s keeps it delicious and approachable.
3. The Sombrero Tacoria Nanuet
The Sombrero Tacoria Nanuet feels like a hidden gem tucked inside the modern buzz of Fashion Drive. Walk in and you’ll see families and friends laughing over trays packed with colorful tacos and overflowing burrito bowls. My first visit had me hooked—thanks to a plate of birria tacos that left me debating an immediate second order.
Birria is the absolute standout here. The slow-cooked beef, rich consommé, and soft tortillas make for a dipping experience that’s hard to match in Nanuet. Their fresh guacamole and homemade salsas add serious punch, no matter what you order. Consider the quesadillas or burrito bowls if you’re extra hungry. For an authentic and family-friendly spot, Sombrero Tacoria brings both flavor and heart.
4. Taqueria America #2
+1 201-466-2393
Taqueria America #2 is the kind of no-frills spot where the focus is on pure, unfiltered Mexican flavor. The understated setting lets the food speak for itself. I swung by with a friend who swore by their tacos—and after just one bite of the carne asada taco, I understood the hype. There’s something special about their balance of spice, char, and freshness.
The tacos here are hard to beat, especially with a splash of their tangy salsa verde. If you’re craving more, their burritos wrap up rice, beans, and your protein of choice into a hearty, satisfying package. Taqueria America #2 manages to capture the essence of authentic Mexican street food, making it a go-to for anyone searching for big flavors in a modest space.
5. Taco Bell / Kfc
If you need a quick bite on Route 59, Taco Bell / KFC offers a familiar and convenient solution in Nanuet. The dual-branded setup means your group can satisfy both Mexican cravings and fried chicken urges—no tough decisions required. I’ve breezed through here after late nights, and the speed never disappoints.
For the best Mexican-inspired picks, try the bean burrito or the veggie Power Menu Bowl. Both deliver reliable flavor without straying into complicated territory. Those who want a crunchy fix tend to lean toward nachos or the satisfying Crunchwrap Supreme. While the flavors aren’t as nuanced as a local taqueria, the appeal here is all about convenience and consistency.
6. Chipotle Mexican Grill
Chipotle Mexican Grill in Rockland Plaza draws a steady stream of regulars for good reason. The build-your-own format means you get a meal made just how you like it, no surprises. I’ve made countless lunchtime pit stops here for a burrito bowl piled with rice, black beans, sofritas, and fresh tomato salsa—every time, the freshness stands out.
Burrito bowls are the top pick, especially if you want a hearty, customizable option that skips the tortilla. Their vegetarian ingredients shine, matched by crisp lettuce, tangy salsa, and smoky grilled veggies. When you want fast service and food built around your tastes, Chipotle makes it easy to get exactly what you’re craving.
7. La Cascada
+1 845-290-1677
La Cascada is one of those low-key neighborhood spots you might drive past without realizing what you’re missing. Step inside and there’s a sense of quiet hospitality—no frills, just welcoming staff and comforting aromas from the kitchen. I once wandered in on a rainy evening and found the place filled with locals gathered over heaping plates of food.
Their chicken enchiladas are a real highlight, offering rich sauce and just the right amount of cheese, paired with beans and rice. For a lighter bite, their fresh guacamole and chips provide the perfect start. La Cascada’s menu might seem simple, but the flavors come through with an authenticity that keeps regulars coming back.
8. Moe’s Southwest Grill
Moe’s Southwest Grill welcomes you with the irresistible aroma of freshly made tortillas and sizzling fillings. Every order begins with a cheerful greeting and a complimentary basket of warm chips and salsa, a touch that always feels generous. On busy afternoons, I’ve ducked in for a speedy lunch and left with a custom-stuffed burrito that’s both filling and fast.
The Homewrecker burrito is always a crowd-pleaser, loaded with cilantro-lime rice, beans, crisp lettuce, pico de gallo, and your choice of protein. The variety of salsas, made in-house, keeps flavors vibrant and fun. Try a burrito bowl if you’re looking to keep it lighter. Moe’s balances fast service with made-to-order freshness, making it a reliable stop along Route 59 when you want bold, customizable Mexican flavors.
9. Qdoba Mexican Grill
Qdoba Mexican Grill at The Shops at Nanuet puts flavor front and center with every order. The setup is casual, yet everything—from smoky salsas to the tender grilled veggies—feels thoughtfully put together. I’ve stopped in after errands and appreciated how you can go bold with toppings without feeling rushed.
Their burrito bowls are a standout option, thanks to layers of seasoned rice, beans, crunchy lettuce, and zesty pico de gallo. Make sure to add the hand-smashed guacamole—it’s included and elevates every spoonful. If you feel adventurous, try the queso over nachos for a treat. Qdoba strikes a balance between speedy service and hearty, Mexican-inspired food that leaves you satisfied every time.
10. Dos Agaves
(845) 501-7023Call
Dos Agaves sits right off Route 59 and delivers classic Mexican fare in a bright, cozy space. The atmosphere leans welcoming and unpretentious, making it easy to settle in with friends or family for a relaxed meal. I remember a weekday dinner where the table kept quiet—everyone too focused on their enchiladas to make conversation.
The vegetarian enchiladas are a highlight, generously filled with sautéed veggies and blanketed in a rich tomato sauce. Their rice and beans have a homemade taste that’s tough to beat. If you’re after starters, don’t overlook the fresh guacamole. Dos Agaves caters to both quick lunches and leisurely dinners, standing out for honest flavors and genuine hospitality.
More Things to Try in Nanuet, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best Mexican restaurants in Nanuet for authentic cuisine?
Top picks include The Sombrero Tacoria Nanuet, Estrella’s Cafe, and Taqueria America #2. These spots deliver traditional flavors, fresh ingredients, and a local touch that stands out.
Are there vegetarian or vegan options at Mexican restaurants in Nanuet?
Yes, several places offer vegetarian and vegan choices. Estrella’s Cafe is known for its veggie tacos and plant-based options. Chipotle, Moe’s Southwest Grill, and Qdoba also have customizable menus for different dietary needs.
Which restaurants in Nanuet are best for families or groups?
Chili’s Grill & Bar, Moe’s Southwest Grill, and Dos Agaves offer plenty of space, kid-friendly options, and laid-back atmospheres perfect for families or gatherings.
Can I find halal or vegetarian-friendly Mexican food in Nanuet?
You’ll find vegetarian-friendly options at most major chains and several local spots. For specific halal offerings, it’s best to call the restaurant in advance and ask about their menu options.
Is takeout or delivery available for Mexican restaurants in Nanuet?
Yes, most restaurants, including Chipotle, Qdoba, Taco Bell, and local favorites, offer takeout and delivery through various apps or direct ordering from their websites.
What’s the best Mexican dish to try in Nanuet?
It depends on your mood. For something hearty, try birria tacos at The Sombrero Tacoria. If you’re looking for a lighter meal, the veggie bowls at Chipotle or Qdoba are solid choices.