There’s something magnetic about Nyack’s Mexican food scene. A simple stroll down Main Street can turn into a proper culinary quest, with inviting aromas wafting from tucked-away taquerias and bright cafes. I found myself on such a walk once, searching for more than just a quick bite. Instead, I ended up with three kinds of salsa, the best chicken burrito I’d ever tasted, and a stubborn desire to visit every spot in town. This guide draws from those full-bellied afternoons and plenty of conversations with locals, because the best picks always come from those in the know.
Finding flavor in Nyack isn’t hard—choosing where to start is the real challenge. From spots that keep things simple and authentic, to newer places where creativity rules the menu, every restaurant here has a story to tell. If you’re after fresh tortillas, smoky grilled chicken, or mole more complex than a crossword puzzle, you’ll find it. So, if you’re as curious as I was, or just hungry for a new favorite, keep reading. The perfect table (and maybe a hidden gem or two) is waiting.
Where to find the best mexican restaurants in Nyack, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best mexican restaurants in Nyack, NY:
- Harry’s Burritos
- Casa Del Sol
- El Cunao Deli
- El Rey Del Pollo
- Burrito Builder
- Casa Del Mare
- Fiesta Mexico
- Tua Cocina
- Coco Taqueria
- Desert Moon Fresh Mexican Grille
1. Harry’s Burritos
Harry’s Burritos, right on Main Street, catches your eye with its playful sense of style and easy-going charm. The moment you step inside, the buzz of conversation and colorful plates say you’re in good company. During my visit, the staff couldn’t have been more welcoming, eager to suggest something beyond the usual selects.
The grilled vegetable burrito is a must—fresh, bold, and hearty, it sets Harry’s apart for both vegetarians and anyone who loves flavor-packed Mexican. The enchiladas verde have a cult following too, known for their tangy tomatillo sauce and satisfying comfort.
If you’re after something lighter, their salads and house-made guacamole do not disappoint. What keeps locals coming back, though, is consistency. Harry’s delivers a reliable take on Mexican classics, every single time.
2. Casa Del Sol
Casa Del Sol brings a sunny splash of Mexican spirit right to the heart of Nyack. The first time I wandered in, vibrant décor and live music made it feel more like a celebration than a meal. Friendly faces behind the counter add to the warmth, making it easy to settle in and linger awhile.
The chile relleno is the house favorite, with its perfectly roasted pepper and creamy cheese filling that leaves you planning your next visit before you finish. Their fresh salsa and tortilla chips are a table staple—crisp, flavorful, and made daily.
Vegetarian options are plentiful, showing genuine care for all tastes. Casa Del Sol nails that inviting neighborhood vibe, serving up comfort with every plate.
3. El Cunao Deli
El Cunao Deli is the kind of spot you find by word of mouth and then start recommending to everyone you know. The vibe is unfussy; think deli counter meets home kitchen, with the scents of real Mexican cooking filling the air. On my last visit, I overheard regulars swapping weekend plans with the owner, which says a lot about its loyal crowd.
The tacos here don’t need fancy plating—they’re just packed with flavor, especially the vegetarian options loaded with sautéed peppers and beans. Their tamales are also legendary—warm, fluffy, and always fresh out of the steamer.
Whether you’re in for breakfast or grabbing takeout, El Cunao keeps things rooted in tradition. The authenticity and generous portions have made it a quiet favorite in the neighborhood.
4. El Rey Del Pollo
El Rey Del Pollo leans into its specialty: grilled chicken so good, you’ll start planning your next meal before this one’s even over. Set on a quieter street, it feels like discovering a neighborhood secret. The aroma of spices and smoke hits you before you even step inside, and it always draws a hungry crowd.
The rotisserie chicken is the headline act here—juicy, well-seasoned, and carved to order. It’s no surprise it made me a repeat customer. Pair that with their flavorful rice and beans, and you’ve got a reliable, comforting plate every time.
The serving sizes offer more than enough for leftovers, and if you’re in the mood for variety, their veggie fajitas are just as masterful. El Rey Del Pollo keeps things simple, satisfying, and deeply authentic.
5. Burrito Builder
Burrito Builder is every bit the casual, grab-and-go answer for hungry folks wanting quick, customizable Mexican fare. It shares space and origins with Harry’s Burritos, but sets itself apart by focusing on fast, no-fuss service. I stopped in after a long afternoon downtown and was met with a bustling crowd eager for a satisfying handheld meal.
The star attraction here is—you guessed it—the burrito. Choose your own fillings, from fresh veggies to seasoned rice and beans, all wrapped up just the way you like it. Their vegetarian options are especially popular, making Burrito Builder a go-to for plant-based eaters as well.
If you enjoy picking your own adventure (and flavor), Burrito Builder delivers every time. Ideal for lunch breaks or a late-day snack run.
6. Casa Del Mare
(845) 353-5353Call
Casa Del Mare carries a pleasing mix of two worlds—Italian and Mexican, making it a haven for diners with mixed cravings. Tucked along North Highland, it offers a change of scenery from downtown’s bustle. The interior is cozy, and I’ve found it’s a favorite for family dinners, thanks to its approachable menu.
The standout from their Mexican selections is the cheese quesadilla, pressed until golden and oozing with rich, melty cheese. The house-made salsa gives everything a fresh, bright kick, making for a lively start to any meal.
Portions run generous, and the staff never misses a chance to recommend something you might not have tried. Casa Del Mare’s dual identity means you can come back for pizza or tacos without ever getting bored.
7. Fiesta Mexico
Fiesta Mexico invites you to a relaxed setting just outside of Nyack, with easy parking and a spacious dining room that’s perfect for groups or laid-back family nights. On my last stop, a steady stream of regulars filed in, all greeted by name, which always bodes well for any restaurant.
The vegetable fajitas are a showstopper—served sizzling, loaded with fresh peppers, onions, and perfectly spiced beans. The portions are more than generous, so come hungry.
Every plate arrives with thoughtful presentation and a side of homemade salsa that brightens up each bite. If you’re looking for solid value and a friendly atmosphere, Fiesta Mexico keeps it consistent. Their affordable menu and warm service make you feel like a familiar face, even on your first visit.
8. Tua Cocina
(845) 848-2234Call
Tua Cocina may not sit in the center of Nyack, but it’s worth the short drive for anyone craving comfort food with a twist. The dual Mexican-Italian menu means there’s always something new to surprise your palate. My own meal here started with the aroma of simmering spices and a helpful nudge from the staff, who never hesitate to share their favorites.
The veggie enchiladas are the real winner—tender tortillas packed with vegetables and baked in a tangy, memorable sauce. Their rice and beans side delivers classic comfort and balances every plate beautifully.
Ideal for both casual dinners and a gathering of friends, Tua Cocina blends reliability with a little adventurous spirit, always served with a friendly smile.
9. Coco Taqueria
Coco Taqueria’s bright storefront promises lively flavors and doesn’t disappoint. I wandered in on a sleepy afternoon and found the mood cheerful and the service quick, whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout. It’s the kind of place where even a quick lunch feels special.
The street corn off the cob and their signature veggie tacos are menu highlights—fresh, vibrant, and layered with spices that make each bite pop. Portions are perfect for mixing and matching, so you can sample a bit of everything without overdoing it.
Coco Taqueria stays true to the casual taco joint vibe, but delivers a level of care you can taste in every corn tortilla. It stands out for bright flavors and unfussy charm.
10. Desert Moon Fresh Mexican Grille
Desert Moon Fresh Mexican Grille offers a welcome break from shopping chaos in Palisades Center, serving up quick, flavorful meals with none of the fuss. The open kitchen lets you see the care that goes into each build-your-own bowl or wrap, which makes every bite feel fresh and satisfying. I’ve stopped in after errands, grateful for speedy service and staff that know the menu inside out.
The veggie burrito bowl stands out here—generous with seasoned beans, veggies, and rice, all topped with their tangy house salsa. The freshness shows even in the little things, like crisp lettuce and just-made guacamole.
A perfect pick for a lunch break or post-movie hunger pang, Desert Moon balances fast-casual convenience with real, bright flavors that hit the mark every time.
More Things to Try in Nyack, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best Mexican restaurants in Nyack for vegetarians?
Several places cater well to vegetarians. Harry’s Burritos, Casa Del Sol, and El Cunao Deli offer tasty meatless options, with standouts like veggie burritos, chile relleno, and fresh tamales. Most restaurants in Nyack have dedicated vegetarian menus or customizable plates.
Which spots offer takeout or delivery?
Most of Nyack’s Mexican restaurants provide takeout, and many partner with delivery apps. Harry’s Burritos, Burrito Builder, and Desert Moon Fresh Mexican Grille are popular choices for quick and easy pickup or delivery, making it simple to enjoy your favorites at home.
Are there family-friendly Mexican restaurants in Nyack?
Absolutely. Casa Del Mare, Fiesta Mexico, and El Rey Del Pollo are well-known for their relaxed atmosphere, roomy dining areas, and menus suited for all ages. Plenty of spots even have kids’ menu options or smaller plates to share.
Can I find authentic Mexican flavors in Nyack?
Yes. Places like El Cunao Deli and El Rey Del Pollo keep their menus close to tradition. Their tacos, tamales, and grilled chicken show off authentic flavors and technique, drawing locals back for the real deal.
Are there any options for large groups or parties?
Fiesta Mexico and Casa Del Sol both have spacious dining rooms and flexible seating for bigger tables, making them great choices for gatherings, celebrations, or office dinners. Calling ahead is always a good idea for large groups.