Searching for the best Mexican restaurants in Plattsburgh, NY can feel like hunting for hidden gems, but let me make it easier for you: there’s real flavor tucked away in this pocket of upstate New York. Some spots wear their jalapeños on their sleeves, bringing vibrant, savory plates to the table, while others put a quirky spin on the classics. On quiet evenings, wandering past the buzzing corners of downtown, I’ve discovered salsas with a slow burn and tacos packed with memories of Mexico’s southern sun—right here along Lake Champlain.
If you’ve ever found yourself torn between crunchy, cheesy comfort and the promise of fresh guacamole, you’re not alone. Plattsburgh offers everything from fast-casual bites to long, relaxed meals where each dish is worth savoring. Every pick on this list has its own story to tell—about family recipes, local flavor, and the kind of food that brings people together. So, if you’re already hungry, don’t worry: the next few minutes might get your taste buds planning ahead.
Where to find the best mexican restaurants in Plattsburgh, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best mexican restaurants in Plattsburgh, NY:
- The Pepper
- Chipotle Mexican Grill
- Olive Ridley’s
- Lomeli’s Mexican Food
- Taco Bell
- Taco Bell
- Cheechako Taco
- Bella Bueno
- Pasquale’s Pizzeria
- Livingood’s Restaurant & Brewery
1. The Pepper
Sitting just off City Hall Place, The Pepper has a welcoming, easygoing buzz whenever you stop by. The space feels bright and lively, drawing locals for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner with friends. One night, I wandered in craving something bold and left thinking about their signature salsa for days.
What sets The Pepper apart is consistency. The kitchen puts heart into every plate, and you can tell. Their vegetarian enchiladas pair bright flavors with just the right kick, and the chile relleno hits that perfect note between comforting and classic. If you’re feeling adventurous, try their take on veggie fajitas—they’re colorful, generous, and best enjoyed with a full table.
Portions are generous without being heavy, and you can always count on friendly table service or an easy takeout experience.
2. Chipotle Mexican Grill
Chipotle Mexican Grill in Plattsburgh is the fast-casual spot for anyone craving fresh, customizable Mexican fare with no fuss. The dining room always has an easy hum, with people choosing between burrito bowls and tacos at their own pace. It’s the kind of place where you can build your meal exactly how you like it―and I’ve never once felt rushed, even on a busy lunch break.
What lifts Chipotle above the average chain is its focus on ingredients. Bowls are packed with flavor, especially when you go for the sofritas or veggie bowl. The fresh salsas and guacamole add brightness and just the right bite, while the options for both vegetarians and vegans make it accessible for everyone.
If you want a hearty, quick fix that still tastes fresh, go for a black bean and rice burrito. It fills you up without weighing you down and delivers all the classic flavors in each bite.
3. Olive Ridley’s
Olive Ridley’s brings a mix of vibrant atmosphere and inventive food, right on Court Street. This spot is as much about the company and music as it is about the menu. Once, I caught a local band here and ended up staying for dinner—the food matched the energy of the crowd.
What stands out most is their fresh, handcrafted approach. The kitchen doesn’t shy away from bold flavor, and you’ll notice it in their takes on classic Mexican dishes. Their vegetarian quesadillas are loaded and satisfying; the nachos arrive piled high, layered with rich, melty cheese and fresh toppings.
If you’re in for lunch or dinner, pair your meal with their house-made salsa for an extra pop. Olive Ridley’s makes finding something crave-worthy easy, no matter your mood.
4. Lomeli’s Mexican Food
+1 518-310-3800
Lomeli’s Mexican Food sits on Oak Street and feels like a true neighborhood staple. The first time I tried their menu, I noticed how much care goes into their cooking—you can taste recipes handed down through generations. The restaurant is cozy, making it easy for a quick meal or a lingering dinner with friends.
What makes Lomeli’s special is its homemade touch. Every plate feels intentional, from the salsas to the tortillas. Don’t miss their veggie tacos, bursting with flavor and fresh enough to impress even the pickiest eaters. The cheese enchiladas strike the right note of comfort and spice, showing off what the kitchen does best.
It’s easy to see why locals love Lomeli’s: you get hearty, authentic food served with a bit of warmth that sticks with you long after your last bite.
5. Taco Bell
Taco Bell on Cornelia Street is a well-known go-to for quick, familiar Tex-Mex cravings. Sometimes, nothing hits the spot quite like the reliable comfort of a hot, ready taco after a long day. I’ve dashed in more times than I care to admit, and it’s always exactly what I expect—fast and satisfying.
Speed and customization are where Taco Bell shines. You can grab everything from a bean burrito to the famous Cheese Quesadilla, all made to order. The Crunchwrap Supreme is another favorite: portable, satisfying, and full of flavor without the wait.
For variety, try building a meal with their Fiesta Veggie Burrito or pile up a few classic tacos. Whether dining in or taking out, Taco Bell keeps it simple and tasty every time.
6. Taco Bell
Set inside Champlain Centre, this Taco Bell offers a break from shopping with quick Mexican-inspired meals. Whenever I find myself hungry between errands, it’s my reliable spot for something fast and satisfying. Friendly staff make the visit easy, and the menu covers all the classics plus some fun twists.
Convenience is the key here, but there’s more to it. The Potato Soft Taco is a trusted pick for a light, flavorful bite, while the Black Bean Chalupa offers a crispy shell filled with texture and spice. Both reflect Taco Bell’s knack for customizable, vegetarian-friendly options that work for any time of day.
If you’re after breakfast, the hash brown toasted breakfast burrito is a popular choice, setting you up with a hot meal in minutes. This location keeps things effortless, whether you’re dining in or taking something to go.
7. Cheechako Taco
(518) 561-0559Call
Cheechako Taco on Margaret Street offers something a little different—a fusion of classic Mexican comfort and creative, local twists. I still remember my first bite of their grilled veggie taco: smoky, vibrant, and wrapped in a house-made tortilla that tasted unmistakably fresh. The space feels laid-back, colorful, and never tries too hard.
What makes Cheechako Taco unique is its attention to detail and playful approach. Their black bean burrito is generous, packed with just the right mix of rice, beans, and toppings. The vegan tacos show just how satisfying plant-based options can be when handled with care.
This is the spot for anyone who wants bold flavor and a break from the usual. If you’re hungry and curious, Cheechako Taco will likely surprise you.
8. Bella Bueno
Bella Bueno may sit across the water in Burlington, but it’s worth the trip when you’re seeking bold Mexican flavors near Plattsburgh. The first time I stopped in, it was the aroma of fresh peppers and homemade corn tortillas that caught my attention immediately. The atmosphere is welcoming, with staff who know their menu and care about every plate.
This spot shines with its commitment to real ingredients and generous portions. The vegetarian enchiladas come piping hot, stuffed, and smothered in a savory, house-made sauce. For a lighter choice, their veggie tacos burst with crunch and color, letting fresh produce take the lead.
Bella Bueno delivers Mexican classics you’ll crave, even if it means planning another visit across the lake.
9. Pasquale’s Pizzeria
Pasquale’s Pizzeria in Peru is best known for its pizza, but their menu has a few surprises for anyone craving something with a Mexican twist. On a recent visit for trivia night, I was drawn in by laughter and the variety on the table—from cheesy pies to zesty Mexican-inspired plates.
While it’s not a traditional Mexican restaurant, Pasquale’s shines when it comes to their veggie quesadillas and loaded nachos. Both arrive stacked high and ready for sharing, making them a hit for groups. The flavors are bold, the ingredients fresh, and the portions don’t disappoint.
If you’re in the mood for familiar flavors with a local twist, Pasquale’s offers a little something for everyone—especially if you pair your meal with good company and a game on the screen.
10. Livingood’s Restaurant & Brewery
Livingood’s Restaurant & Brewery blends a love for local fare with pub classics and inventive plates. Set on Bear Swamp Road, it’s the kind of place where the menu always holds a surprise. I stopped in after a long drive, looking for something hearty and left thinking about how many creative comfort food options they offer.
Though known for house-made pizza and craft brews, Livingood’s pays attention to its Mexican-inspired choices, too. The standout is their vegetarian nachos—layered, crispy, just spicy enough, and perfect for sharing. If you want something with a fresh twist, try their black bean tacos, which balance flavor and texture with each bite.
For anyone craving a relaxed spot with consistent quality and a mix of global flavors, Livingood’s makes it easy to enjoy a touch of Mexican flair without leaving Peru.
More Things to Try in Plattsburgh, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best Mexican restaurants in Plattsburgh, NY?
Some local favorites include The Pepper, Cheechako Taco, Lomeli’s Mexican Food, and Chipotle Mexican Grill. Each offers its own unique take on classic Mexican dishes, from fresh salsas to loaded tacos.
Do any Mexican restaurants in Plattsburgh offer vegetarian or vegan options?
Yes, you’ll find vegetarian and vegan choices at The Pepper, Chipotle Mexican Grill, and Cheechako Taco. Many spots also customize orders to fit plant-based diets, so just ask your server.
Are there any places for quick Mexican food in Plattsburgh?
Taco Bell, Chipotle Mexican Grill, and Cheechako Taco are known for fast service. They’re great for a quick bite or convenient takeout.
Where can I find authentic Mexican food in Plattsburgh?
Lomeli’s Mexican Food is celebrated for its homemade style and authentic recipes. The Pepper and Cheechako Taco also deliver plenty of classic flavors with local flair.
Which spots are good for families or groups?
The Pepper, Olive Ridley’s, and Pasquale’s Pizzeria have spacious seating and menus with something for everyone, making them easy choices for larger parties.