Best Mexican Restaurants in Rochester, NY

Rochester, NY, has some amazing Mexican food. Trust me, I’ve tried a lot of it. I’ve explored many spots in the city. I’m excited to share my favorites with you.

So, what are the best Mexican restaurants in Rochester, NY? You’ll find a mix of yummy tacos, spicy enchiladas, and fresh guacamole. Each place has its unique vibe and tasty dishes. Whether you love classic flavors or want something new, there’s something for everyone.

Stick around! I’ll take you through each restaurant. You’ll learn what to order. Get ready for a delicious ride through Rochester’s Mexican food scene!

Top 10 Mexican Restaurants in Rochester, NY

1. Old Pueblo Grill
2. Bitter Honey
3. La Casa Restaurant
4. Salena’s Mexican Restaurant
5. Monte Alban
6. Neno’s Gourmet Mexican Street Food Dinner In
7. Peach blossom
8. dorado
9. Tavos Antojitos y Tequila
10. Mi Rancho Alegre

1. Old Pueblo Grill

Old Pueblo Grill is a true treasure in Rochester. It’s on Russell Street, and it’s always buzzing with good vibes. I love that you can choose to sit indoors or outdoors. The place is also wheelchair-accessible, which is great!

When I first walked in, I felt the warmth. The colorful decor caught my eye. The staff greeted me with big smiles. I knew I was in for a treat!

What really makes Old Pueblo Grill special is the food. Everything is fresh, and the flavors are spot on. You have to try the enchiladas suizas. They’re so tasty and topped with a creamy green sauce. Don’t forget to get the guacamole, too. It’s made fresh and is simply amazing!

2. Bitter Honey

Bitter Honey is a fun spot on Railroad Street. It has a lively atmosphere and cool decor. You can sit inside or outside. It’s also wheelchair-accessible, which is a plus.

When I visited, the place was buzzing with energy. The colorful tiles and friendly staff made me feel right at home. It was a great experience from start to finish.

Bitter Honey stands out for its creative tacos and mezcal. The flavors are amazing and unique. You have to try the baja fish taco. It’s crispy and delicious. Pair it with a mezcal cocktail for the perfect combo. The Mexican bar snacks are also worth a try. Everything here is designed to delight your taste buds!

3. La Casa Restaurant

La Casa Restaurant feels super cozy. It’s on Alexander Street, tucked away in a charming old house. The warm dark-wood interiors make it feel like home. It’s wheelchair-accessible too, which is great!

I went there for dinner last week. The vibe was so relaxed and welcoming. The staff smiled and chatted like we were old friends. It’s a place where you just want to linger.

The food? Oh, it’s amazing. Their carne asada blew me away. The flavors were bold and perfect. And their tamales? Soft, rich, and unforgettable. I couldn’t stop eating. The house margarita was the cherry on top—so refreshing!

If you’re looking for tasty Mexican dishes with heart, this is it. Simple, flavorful, and full of soul.

4. Salena’s Mexican Restaurant

Salena’s Mexican Restaurant is such a lively place. It’s right on North Goodman Street, and it’s always buzzing. You can sit inside or outside, which is nice. They have over 90 types of tequila, perfect for happy hour. Plus, it’s wheelchair-accessible!

I went to Salena’s last weekend, and wow, it was fun. The energy in the room was amazing. The staff greeted me with big smiles, which made me feel right at home.

What really stands out here is the food. The tacos are packed with flavor and so fresh. I loved the fajitas—they came to my table sizzling! Every bite was fantastic. And you can’t skip the margarita; it’s the perfect drink to enjoy with your meal. Trust me, you’ll love it!

5. Monte Alban

Monte Alban is one of my favorite spots. It’s on East Ridge Road, so super easy to find. The vibe there is fun and lively. They’ve got curbside pickup and delivery, which is so convenient. They even have both indoor and outdoor seating. And guess what? It’s wheelchair-accessible too.

When I walked in, I felt right at home. The decor was bright and cheerful. The staff greeted me with big smiles. Everyone there seemed happy and relaxed. It’s a place where you can kick back and enjoy.

Now, let’s talk food—oh, wow! The enchiladas with mole sauce were perfect. The mole was rich and smoky. I couldn’t stop eating. The shrimp fajitas? They came out sizzling hot. So tasty and fresh. The guacamole, too, was creamy and full of flavor.

If you go, you have to try the enchiladas. They’re a must. Pair them with a margarita. Trust me, you’ll be in food heaven. Monte Alban is a gem. You won’t regret it.

6. Neno’s Gourmet Mexican Street Food Dinner In

Neno’s Gourmet Mexican Street Food Dinner In is a little gem on Monroe Avenue. It has such a cozy vibe. The colorful decor makes the place feel warm and inviting. Whether you choose to eat inside or outside, it’s a great spot to enjoy a meal.

When I walked in, I felt instantly at home. The family-run vibe is so special. The staff are super friendly and really care about their customers. You can tell they love what they do!

The food? Wow, it’s amazing! I tried their tacos, and I couldn’t believe how fresh and flavorful they were. Each bite was packed with deliciousness. You have to get the carne asada taco. It’s a standout! You’ll love it just as much as I did!

7. Peach blossom

Peach Blossom is such a charming spot on East Main Street. It has a cozy vibe with both indoor and outdoor seating. The entrance is wheelchair-friendly, which is a big plus!

When I walked in, I felt instantly welcomed. The bright decor really lifted my spirits. The staff were super nice and made me feel at home.

What makes Peach Blossom stand out is its fun menu. They serve both traditional and modern Mexican dishes that are really tasty. You have to try their shrimp tacos! They are so fresh and packed with flavor. Add some of their homemade salsa on top, and you’re in for a treat. Trust me, you’ll love it!

8. dorado

Dorado is such a cute little cantina on Park Ave. The first thing I noticed was the sky-painted ceiling. It really gives the place a fun vibe! They have both indoor and outdoor seating, which I love. Plus, the entrance is wheelchair-accessible, making it welcoming for everyone.

When I visited, I was greeted with big smiles. The staff were super friendly and helpful. I couldn’t wait to dive into the menu!

What makes Dorado special is their tasty cocktails and Latin food. I absolutely recommend the carne asada tacos. The steak was so tender and flavorful. And don’t skip the guacamole! It’s fresh and creamy, perfect with the tacos. Trust me, you’ll enjoy every bite!

9. Tavos Antojitos y Tequila

Tavos Antojitos y Tequila is such a fun place on Merchants Road. The vibe is lively, and they have great seating options indoors and outdoors. Plus, it’s wheelchair-accessible, which is awesome!

When I walked in, I felt the energy right away. The staff were super friendly, making me feel welcomed. The colorful decor added to the cheerful atmosphere, and I loved it.

What really stands out at Tavos is their amazing food and tequila. I have to recommend the street tacos. They’re bursting with flavor and topped with fresh ingredients. And don’t skip the queso dip! It’s creamy and perfect for sharing. Trust me, every bite is delicious and makes you want to come back for more!

10. Mi Rancho Alegre

Mi Rancho Alegre is such a cozy spot on Center Place Drive. I love how warm and welcoming it feels. You can choose to sit inside or outside, which is nice. And it’s wheelchair-accessible, making it friendly for everyone!

When I went there, the staff were super friendly. They greeted me with big smiles. The colorful decor made everything feel festive and fun. I felt right at home!

What really stands out at Mi Rancho Alegre is the food. I can’t recommend the chiles rellenos enough. They’re stuffed with creamy cheese and so tasty! And you have to try their homemade salsa. It’s fresh and just the right amount of zesty. You’ll want to keep coming back for more!

Map of Mexican Restaurants in Rochester, NY

Choosing the Right Restaurant for You

With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:

Restaurant	Price	Seating	Takeout	Delivery	Wheelchair	Reservation
Old Pueblo Grill	Moderate	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	No
Bitter Honey	Moderate	Yes	Yes	No	Accessible	Yes
La Casa Restaurant	Moderate	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	Yes
Salena’s Mexican Restaurant	Moderate	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	Yes
Monte Alban	Moderate	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	Yes
Neno’s Gourmet Mexican Street Food Dinner In	Moderate	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	Yes
Peach blossom	–	Yes	Yes	No	Accessible	No
dorado	Moderate	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	No
Tavos Antojitos y Tequila	Moderate	Yes	Yes	No	Accessible	Yes
Mi Rancho Alegre	Moderate	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	Yes

Frequently Asked Questions

• What are the best Mexican restaurants in Rochester, NY?
  Oh, there are so many! Old Pueblo Grill is a must-visit for unique tacos. Bitter Honey? The vibe there is unbeatable. La Casa feels super cozy, and Neno’s has such fun street food vibes.

• Do Mexican restaurants in Rochester offer vegetarian options?
  Yes, they sure do! La Casa has yummy veggie tacos. And don’t miss the guac—it’s always fresh and so good.

• Are there any authentic Mexican restaurants in Rochester?
  Absolutely. Monte Alban nails those traditional flavors. Old Pueblo Grill also feels like a bite straight out of Mexico.

• Which Mexican restaurant in Rochester is best for families?
  Families will love Mi Rancho Alegre. It’s cozy and welcoming. La Casa also works great—plus, their kid’s menu rocks.

• Do any Mexican restaurants in Rochester have outdoor seating?
  Yep, lots of them! Bitter Honey and La Casa are my picks. Enjoy some sunshine while munching on tacos.

• Can I find gluten-free options at Mexican restaurants in Rochester?
  Totally. Corn tortillas are everywhere, so no stress. Old Pueblo Grill is especially good with gluten-free choices.

• What’s the price range for Mexican food in Rochester?
  It’s super affordable. Most dishes are around $10-$20. Definitely worth every penny.

• Do Mexican restaurants in Rochester offer takeout or delivery?
  Yes, for sure. Neno’s and Bitter Honey do both. Perfect for when you’re staying in.

• Are there any Mexican restaurants with live music in Rochester?
  Yep! La Casa sometimes has live music nights. It’s such a cool and festive vibe.

• What’s the most popular dish at Mexican restaurants in Rochester?
  Oh, tacos, hands down! But don’t skip Mi Rancho Alegre’s chiles rellenos. Trust me, they’re unforgettable.