Roslyn Heights isn’t flashy about its food scene, but if you comb the neighborhoods with curiosity and an appetite, you’ll stumble on a tidy collection of Mexican spots worth more than just a mention. I’ve wandered the backroads between Northern Boulevard and Old Westbury Road, searching for tortillas with real bite, salsas that don’t apologize, and lime-fresh guacamole tweaked with just the right edge of heat. From easygoing taquerias to sit-down cantinas, each stop brings its own twist—sometimes a burst of cilantro, sometimes the comfort of slow-cooked beans, always the promise of a warm welcome for your appetite.
Whether you crave classic tacos, inventive burritos, or something off-the-cuff from a chef who knows how to layer flavor, you’ll find options in Roslyn Heights and just nearby. The trick isn’t choosing where you’ll eat; it’s deciding where to start. This guide features the kind of places I’d send a friend, packed with vibrant flavors, halal-friendly ingredients, and exactly the kind of charm that keeps you coming back. Read on, and let’s dig in.
Where to find the best mexican restaurants in Roslyn Heights, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best mexican restaurants in Roslyn Heights, NY:
- Green Cactus Mexican Grill
- Cozymel’s Mexican Grill
- Green Cactus Grill
- Moe’s Southwest Grill
- Poco Loco
- Besito
- Tocolo Cantina
- Homemade Taqueria Great Neck
- Margarita’s Cafe
- Mole Mole Fresh Mexican Grill
1. Green Cactus Mexican Grill
If you’re searching for straightforward, vibrant Mexican fare, Green Cactus Mexican Grill feels like a local secret everyone should know. The minute you walk in, the aroma of grilled veggies and warm tortillas hits in a way that’s honest and inviting.
Their grilled chicken burrito is a standout—packed, but not heavy, with beans that taste homemade and salsas that wake up all the right senses. Vegetarian and vegan dishes get real attention here, with the same fresh flavors and thoughtful textures.
What I appreciate most is how fast food can still feel fresh and customized. Try the chicken soft tacos and a side of guac—both easy favorites that showcase their no-shortcuts approach. Dining here is simple, memorable, and sets the bar high for affordable Mexican in Roslyn Heights.
2. Cozymel’s Mexican Grill
Cozymel’s Mexican Grill mixes bright coastal flavors with a relaxed, airy vibe that makes it a bit of an escape from the usual. The space is open, with plenty of seating, and the atmosphere always feels like a soft landing after a busy day.
One afternoon, I dug into their grilled shrimp tacos, full of citrus and fresh herbs. They’re light yet satisfying—perfect if you’re after big taste without the weight. The vegetarian enchiladas are another high point, built on layers of roasted vegetables and a mellow, flavorful sauce.
Cozymel’s is the ideal place to bring friends who know their Mexican food or want to linger over a meal. It’s consistently reliable, and the menu covers everything from classics to lighter options that don’t skimp on flavor.
3. Green Cactus Grill
Green Cactus Grill in Garden City Park offers fast-casual Mexican with a clear focus on freshness and value. Walk in and you’re greeted by friendly staff and a place that moves at a neighborly pace—quick if you need it, never rushed if you’d rather linger.
I’ve always been drawn to their grilled vegetable fajitas, which sizzle with color and taste just as lively as they look. The house-made pico de gallo offers the right mix of tang and heat and the soft, warm tortillas make every bite memorable.
Their menu leans toward lighter, healthy options while still capturing that signature spark of Mexican flavor. Don’t overlook their black bean tacos, a surprisingly hearty choice—and a testament to their knack for letting simple ingredients shine.
4. Moe’s Southwest Grill
Moe’s Southwest Grill in Greenvale puts a playful spin on Mexican favorites, all with the easy customization that keeps fans coming back. Step inside and you can smell the warm flour tortillas, beans simmering, and those house-made salsas lining the counter. There’s a genuine satisfaction in watching your meal built fresh, just the way you like it.
One afternoon craving comfort, I chose the vegetarian burrito bowl, loading it up with black beans, grilled peppers, zesty pico de gallo, and a lively jalapeño-lime sauce. That bowl hit the right notes: hearty and bright, without ever feeling heavy.
Free chips and salsa with every order is the signature move here. The nachos are crisp, and the salsas never shy away from real flavor. Moe’s is where you go for a casual bite that never gets dull—every visit is a fresh adventure.
5. Poco Loco
Poco Loco brings a burst of color and energy to Carle Place, serving Mexican classics with a dash of flair. The space hums with a lively vibe and a menu that puts creative twists on familiar dishes without going overboard.
What drew me in the first time was curiosity, but I stayed for the freshly grilled chicken fajitas. They arrive with all the fixings and a sizzle that steals the table’s attention. It’s the kind of dish where every bite feels like it’s made to order, bursting with well-seasoned vegetables and tender meat.
Vegetarian enchiladas here highlight how Poco Loco balances bold sauces with perfectly cooked vegetables. If you’re in the mood for something with a little extra character, their menu delivers. It’s a memorable stop for anyone chasing authentic, satisfying Mexican in the Roslyn Heights area.
6. Besito
Besito offers a polished, intimate take on Mexican dining in the heart of Roslyn. Step inside and you’ll find warm lighting, charming decor, and service that’s attentive without being overbearing. The whole atmosphere feels made for memorable meals, whether it’s a casual lunch or a special occasion.
My favorite moment came at brunch, with chile relleno perfectly roasted and stuffed with vegetables and cheese—each bite rich, mild, and full of flavor. The kitchen has a gift for elevating the classics while keeping the soul of the dish intact.
Don’t overlook the hand-pressed guacamole prepared tableside. It’s a signature touch that sets the stage for everything else Besito does well: fresh, vibrant, and layered with care. If you’re after refined Mexican dining in Roslyn Heights, Besito’s your answer.
7. Tocolo Cantina
Tocolo Cantina reimagines Mexican cuisine with a modern edge and a dose of West Coast style. Walking in, you’ll notice the copper accents and communal tables, setting a tone that’s equal parts sophisticated and sociable.
Every visit, I’m reminded how much care goes into the simplest things here. The street corn, charred and spiced just right, hits a nostalgic note. For a main, go for the grilled chicken tacos—tender and bright with fresh salsa, wrapped in hand-pressed tortillas that make all the difference.
The kitchen isn’t afraid of bold, layered flavors or beautiful plating. Whether you sit indoors or under the canopy, Tocolo Cantina pulls off authentic flavor in a space that feels fresh and inviting—great for both groups and solo meals. Their approach puts them at the top for memorable, modern Mexican near Roslyn Heights.
8. Homemade Taqueria Great Neck
Homemade Taqueria Great Neck feels like stepping into a friend’s kitchen where everything starts from scratch. The scent of griddled corn and fresh herbs hits as soon as you walk in, a promise that the name is no idle boast.
On my last stop, the grilled fish tacos stood out—each served on a pillowy, warm corn tortilla, topped with crisp slaw and a squeeze of lime. Portions are generous, but the flavors stay balanced and light. Vegetarian enchiladas here are smothered in a savory sauce that keeps you coming back for just one more bite.
Homemade Taqueria thrives on simplicity, freshness, and family atmosphere. If you’re searching for authentic, no-corners-cut Mexican near Roslyn Heights, this spot truly delivers.
9. Margarita’s Cafe
Margarita’s Cafe in Williston Park offers a cheerful, festive environment perfect for small gatherings or family dinners. There’s something inviting about the colorful decor and the way the staff treats you like an old friend, even on your first visit.
My personal favorite is their enchiladas verdes, which pack plenty of tangy tomatillo flavor and arrive bubbling hot. If you’re with a group, the tableside guacamole is essential—fresh, zesty, and tailored to your liking every time.
The menu leans classic but never dull, striking the right balance between comfort and excitement. For anyone in Roslyn Heights seeking a spot where flavors shine and meals are meant to be shared, Margarita’s Cafe is a reliable go-to.
10. Mole Mole Fresh Mexican Grill
Mole Mole Fresh Mexican Grill in Manhasset feels easygoing and authentic, with a menu rooted in classic flavors done right. You’ll find a relaxed pace and friendly faces behind the counter, proof that this spot values comfort as much as taste.
Every time I visit, I go for their grilled veggie burrito. It’s warm, hearty, and neatly wrapped, with just enough spice to keep things interesting. The chips and salsa trio is a table favorite, crisp and fresh with a nice kick from the house salsas.
Mole Mole stands out for its focus on simple, quality ingredients that let each dish speak for itself. If you’re craving honest Mexican fare near Roslyn Heights, this spot will make you feel right at home.
More Things to Try in Roslyn Heights, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are some popular Mexican restaurants in Roslyn Heights, NY?
Top picks include Green Cactus Mexican Grill, Besito, Margarita’s Cafe, and Moe’s Southwest Grill. Each offers its own style, from quick bites to refined dining.
Are there halal or vegetarian options at Mexican restaurants in Roslyn Heights?
Yes, several spots like Green Cactus and Homemade Taqueria offer vegetarian, vegan, and halal-friendly choices. Always check the menu or call ahead to confirm options and preparation methods.
Which restaurants are best for families or groups?
Margarita’s Cafe, Tocolo Cantina, and Moe’s have casual atmospheres, roomy seating, and menus to please all ages. They’re solid picks for a relaxed meal out with the whole crew.
Can I find gluten-free dishes at Mexican restaurants in the area?
Many Mexican restaurants offer gluten-free items like corn tortillas, rice bowls, and salads. Ask the staff for suggestions and to accommodate specific needs.
Do any places serve authentic Mexican street food?
Yes, Homemade Taqueria and Mole Mole Fresh Mexican Grill are known for classic street eats like tacos, burritos, and corn on the cob, all crafted with a homemade touch.
Is advance reservation necessary at these restaurants?
Reservations are smart for weekend nights at Besito or Tocolo Cantina. For casual spots like Green Cactus, walk-ins are typically welcome and seats are easy to find.