Thinking about Mexican food in Seaford, NY is a bit like remembering your all-time favorite movie—vivid, layered, and full of great moments. This town manages to pack a surprising punch, with spots that turn casual lunches and late-night cravings into memorable stories. Whether it’s the perfect burst of fresh cilantro, the crackle of a just-grilled tortilla, or that elusive salsa ratio, you don’t have to cross a border (or even county lines) to taste honest Mexican flavor.
I’ve tracked down tacos, sampled salsas, and asked plenty of locals about their go-to orders. What follows is a line-up that speaks to flavor, value, and pure satisfaction. There’s a spot here for everyone, whether you obsess over carne asada, get poetic about burritos, or simply want a family-friendly place for dinner. Ready to find your new favorite? Let’s get started.
Where to find the best mexican restaurants in Seaford, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best mexican restaurants in Seaford, NY:
- Frida’s Mexican Grill
- Taco Bell
- El Coyote Loco
- GUAC Shop Mexican Grill
- Burrito Mariachi
- Moe’s Southwest Grill
- Oles Fajitas Supreme Mexican
- QDOBA Mexican Eats
- Cancun Mexican Grill
- Escorzas Mexican Restaurant
1. Frida’s Mexican Grill
Stepping into Frida’s Mexican Grill feels like entering a local secret—a spot where bold flavors actually live up to their promise. The walls burst with color, and the welcoming staff sets the tone for a relaxed meal. There’s a genuine charm here that keeps people coming back.
I remember my first bite of their carne asada tacos; the seasoning was spot-on, and each soft tortilla held just enough kick to make it interesting. The house guacamole is another standout—simple, fresh, and bright enough to remind you why avocado exists.
The enchiladas and sizzling fajitas are favorites for a reason, capturing everything good about classic Mexican comfort food. If you’re stuck on what to order, anything that touches the grill is a smart bet.
2. Taco Bell
Taco Bell in Seaford is open late, never judges, and always understands what a tight budget looks like. It’s the go-to for those moments when you want flavorful food, fast. There’s something amusing about recognizing every item on the menu, each one engineered for pure comfort.
On nights when only a Crunchwrap Supreme will do, I’ve found myself in the drive-thru, watching the world go by as my order comes together. You know what you’ll get: freshness, those familiar spices, and food that’s somehow both classic and inventive.
Try the Bean Burrito or the Black Bean Chalupa for a quick bite. For something filling, the Cheesy Gordita Crunch wraps everything Taco Bell does best into one package.
3. El Coyote Loco
(516) 785-9087Call
El Coyote Loco is the kind of spot you stumble into on Merrick Road, then start telling friends about the next day. The vibe is laid-back, with a menu that reaches beyond standard tacos into deeper Mexican and Latin American territory. There’s always a hum of conversation, and the staff handles everything with relaxed confidence.
My go-to is the vegetarian enchiladas—savory, satisfying, and never shy on flavor. Their rice and beans come with just enough zest to be memorable, and each plate feels like a generous home-cooked spread. For those who love a twist, the grilled vegetable fajitas serve up warmth and color in equal measure.
If you’re curious about what Seaford offers beyond chains, El Coyote Loco is a solid place to try something with a little personality.
4. GUAC Shop Mexican Grill
There’s a cool, modern vibe at GUAC Shop Mexican Grill that sets it apart on Merrick Road. It’s the spot you hit for fast service and fresh-tasting meals that don’t weigh you down. Perfect for post-gym or a breezy lunch that feels healthy, not heavy.
The highlight here is clearly the burrito bowl—piled high with crisp veggies, tender beans, your pick of double protein, and their namesake guacamole that actually tastes homemade. Their tacos are bright, generous, and designed with the kind of care you don’t expect from a quick-service place.
The veggie quesadilla is another must-try, offering real flavor in a portable package. For anyone after easy, bold food that skips the shortcuts, GUAC Shop delivers every time.
5. Burrito Mariachi
Burrito Mariachi is one of those places that proves great food doesn’t have to come with a high price tag. The setting is relaxed, the portions are generous, and it’s perfect for grabbing a quick, flavorful bite on the go.
Their signature burritos are big enough to leave you planning what to do with leftovers, stuffed with rice, beans, and an array of fresh toppings. I once went for the veggie burrito—it’s packed with color and has plenty of flavor to keep things interesting without feeling heavy.
If you want something lighter, their crisp tacos and house-made salsa offer plenty of crunch and kick. Burrito Mariachi nails quick, tasty Mexican comfort food every time.
6. Moe’s Southwest Grill
Moe’s Southwest Grill greets you the moment you walk in—sometimes literally—with a burst of energy and the scent of fresh salsa in the air. The setup is casual, with a menu built for full customization. You can pile on the toppings and tweak every detail.
I’m a fan of the burrito bowl here, especially when loaded with black beans, grilled peppers, and their zippy house-made salsa. There’s something about the combination of warm rice and cool pico de gallo that makes each bite satisfying but not overpowering. Plus, you get free chips and salsa with every meal, which never feels like a throw-in.
If you’re after a casual place to experiment with flavors, Moe’s is well worth the visit. Their vegetarian options are plentiful, with enough variety to keep every meal interesting.
7. Oles Fajitas Supreme Mexican
Oles Fajitas Supreme Mexican is one of those neighborhood finds where the food leaves a lasting impression. The quick-service style means your order arrives fast, but the quality never rushes past flavor. There’s nothing generic about what’s served up here.
On more than one occasion, I’ve stopped in for their veggie fajitas. They arrive sizzling, packed with colorful peppers and onions, and paired with sides that taste homemade. The tangy sauces are another highlight—each one adds just enough heat without overpowering your meal.
If you’re in the mood for Mexican food but want something casual, Oles Fajitas is the answer. Their rice bowls and fresh tacos round out the menu, keeping every visit interesting and full of bold flavor.
8. QDOBA Mexican Eats
QDOBA Mexican Eats finds that balance between efficient service and genuine flavor. It’s easy to get drawn in by the build-your-own style, where you control every topping and every ounce of spice. The atmosphere is warm, modern, and geared for family or friends grabbing a casual meal.
I’m always tempted by the burrito bowls here—layered with flame-grilled peppers, fajita veggies, and their fresh salsas. The hand-crafted guacamole is a must, and the famous 3-Cheese Queso is creamy enough to steal the show every time. The variety of veggies and beans keeps things interesting for those steering clear of meat.
If you’re ordering for a group or just hungry after a long day, QDOBA’s focus on bright flavors and smart choices makes it a for-sure stop just outside Seaford.
9. Cancun Mexican Grill
(516) 590-7755Call
Cancun Mexican Grill is the place for those who want their dinner with a splash of energy. There’s an inviting feel to the dining room, making it popular with families and friends out for a fun meal. You can always count on a prompt greeting and plenty of options for everyone.
When I stopped in, the quesadillas and tacos instantly impressed. Each bite was packed with flavor and fresh toppings that showed real attention to quality. The jalapeno poppers also add that bit of heat if you want to start your meal with a kick.
Try their fresh soup or a classic plate of tacos for a true sense of what they do best. Cancun Mexican Grill gives Seaford locals a reliable spot for solid Mexican food and relaxed gatherings.
10. Escorzas Mexican Restaurant
Escorzas Mexican Restaurant feels like an easygoing local spot where every meal is made with care. It draws a dedicated crowd from Wantagh and beyond thanks to its cozy vibe and consistently good food.
I found the vegetarian tacos packed with fresh vegetables and vibrant salsas to be a highlight—full of color and satisfying crunch. The rice and beans, simple as they sound, were cooked just right, showing attention even in the details.
The enchiladas are another strong option, layered with flavor and perfectly portioned. If you’re craving reliable Mexican food with a personal touch, Escorzas brings both comfort and quality to the table.
More Things to Try in Seaford, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best Mexican restaurants near Seaford, NY?
Several standout options include Frida’s Mexican Grill, GUAC Shop Mexican Grill, Burrito Mariachi, and Oles Fajitas Supreme Mexican. Each delivers a distinct experience, from classic comfort food to healthier, modern twists.
Are there vegetarian-friendly Mexican restaurants in Seaford?
Absolutely. Most local spots offer flavorful vegetarian choices. Look for veggie burritos, enchiladas, and fajitas at places like Burrito Mariachi, GUAC Shop, and Moe’s Southwest Grill.
Do any Mexican restaurants in Seaford offer gluten-free options?
Many places now provide gluten-free options. GUAC Shop Mexican Grill and QDOBA allow you to customize burrito bowls or salads to fit gluten-free diets.
Is takeout or delivery available at Mexican restaurants in Seaford?
Yes. Most locations, including Taco Bell, Moe’s Southwest Grill, and Oles Fajitas, offer takeout and delivery for those busy evenings or movie nights at home.
Which spots are best for family gatherings?
Family-friendly environments can be found at QDOBA, Frida’s Mexican Grill, and Cancun Mexican Grill, thanks to broad menus and a welcoming vibe for groups large and small.