Hunting for the best Mexican food in Selden, NY can feel a bit like treasure hunting—except you’re after smoky salsas instead of doubloons. Every craving has a perfect spot, from tiny taco counters to homey grills where the staff greet you like they’ve always known you. In Selden, the game is strong and surprisingly diverse. Over time, I’ve darted in and out of almost every spot on this list: sampling tender chicken tinga at one place, then finding that another has tamales that could compete with abuela-level magic.
If you’re after more than bland chain burritos or one-note nachos, you’ve landed in the right place. With dozens of options, this isn’t about settling—it’s about discovering. Whether you’re looking for a casual eat with friends after work, a go-to spot for family dinners, or a quick bite that tastes like it took all day to make, you’ll find it here. Get ready. Your new favorite Mexican meal in Selden might just be waiting for you around the corner.
Where to find the best mexican restaurants in Selden, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best mexican restaurants in Selden, NY:
- Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille
- Viva Juan Mexican Restaurant
- Chicos Tex Mex
- Chipotle Mexican Grill
- Taco Bell
- Taco Express Plus
- Moe’s Southwest Grill
- Adobo Mexican Grill
- On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina
- Taco El Primo Restaurant
1. Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille
Tucked along Middle Country Road, Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille is the kind of place that keeps you thinking about your meal long after you leave. It’s a cozy, friendly spot, perfect for a quick lunch or a no-fuss dinner with friends. If you prefer takeout, the staff make sure your food travels well and tastes fresh at home.
What sets Blue Tortilla apart is their dedication to bold, balanced flavors and fresh ingredients. I learned this the first time I tried their chicken enchiladas—juicy, not drowned in sauce, and paired with bright salsa verde that woke up every bite.
The chicken tinga tacos are another must, generously filled and never dry. Their guacamole is made to order, creamy with a little kick, best enjoyed with a side of warm chips.
For those craving something light, the grilled veggie burrito delivers classic flavor without being heavy. This spot is a mainstay when I want food that reminds me to slow down and savor.
2. Viva Juan Mexican Restaurant
Viva Juan Mexican Restaurant is quietly perched on Middle Country Road, embraced by locals for its genuine atmosphere and warm hospitality. The first time I wandered in, the aroma of fresh tortillas was enough to make me forget any menu indecision.
Viva Juan’s real charm is in small details—friendly table service and food that never feels rushed. The staff treat you like a long-lost friend, whether you’re lingering over a meal or grabbing takeout.
The carne asada platter is a must for its tender, well-seasoned steak paired with classic rice and beans. For a lighter bite, the veggie fajitas stay crisp and colorful, capturing all the right flavors.
This restaurant’s balance of comfort and fresh taste consistently calls me back. It’s where I go when I need a reminder of how simple, balanced food can win the day.
3. Chicos Tex Mex
Chicos Tex Mex has a way of drawing you in with its bright flavor and easygoing vibe. The Selden spot, born from a beloved food truck, is always bustling but never overwhelming. It’s the kind of place where you can drop in for lunch or dinner and be greeted by the comforting sizzle of the kitchen.
What makes Chicos stand out is their knack for crafting Tex Mex favorites with serious care. I first fell for their chicken street tacos. Each bite was layered with fresh cilantro, onions, and a gentle heat that kept it interesting.
If you’re up for heartier fare, their grilled steak burrito balances smoky, tender beef with beans and Spanish rice. The flavor stays bold, not muddled. For a lighter option, their veggie quesadillas let the produce shine.
Every order feels made for you—which, at Chicos, isn’t just a slogan. It’s a promise they actually keep.
4. Chipotle Mexican Grill
Chipotle Mexican Grill in Selden is where you go when you want predictable flavor that doesn’t cut corners. The menu may look familiar, but every burrito, bowl, or taco starts with well-sourced ingredients made fresh behind the counter. If you’re feeling indecisive, the build-your-own setup turns lunch into a low-stakes adventure.
What sets this Chipotle apart is the staff—fast, efficient, and always ready with recommendations for customizing your meal. You’re never rushed, even during a busy lunch rush.
The chicken burrito bowl is a favorite for good reason. It’s filling, flavorful, and lets you pick every topping in sight. I also like their vegetarian sofritas bowl for something lighter and full of spice.
Consistency is Chipotle’s quiet superpower. You get the flavor you expect, every single time.
5. Taco Bell
Taco Bell on Middle Country Road is the answer when you want a fast, affordable bite that satisfies in minutes. It’s open all day, making it a favorite for early risers and those late-night cravings alike.
The menu is engineered for comfort, and Selden’s location keeps things fresh and efficient. From my own visits, I’ve learned that the team handles special orders and substitutions with no fuss, which makes a difference during the lunch rush.
The Crunchwrap Supreme is hard to beat—it combines tender seasoned fillings with a crispy shell and plenty of creamy sauce. For a lighter choice, the black bean chalupa brings the crunch without feeling heavy.
If you want quick Mexican-inspired eats without pretense, Taco Bell always delivers exactly that.
6. Taco Express Plus
+1 631-320-0766
Taco Express Plus might not shout for attention, but that’s exactly why it works. It’s a no-frills spot tucked into Middle Country Road, where the focus lands on honest, flavorful Mexican food. On my first visit, I was greeted with a smile and a menu full of surprises.
The magic at Taco Express Plus is in their generous portions and speedy service. Your meal hits the table fast, but there’s nothing rushed about the flavor. The kitchen makes it easy to grab lunch or dinner that feels real and unpretentious.
The fish tacos stand out for their light, crispy coating and fresh toppings. The chicken burritos are another highlight—hearty, well-seasoned, and simple in the best way possible.
For a reliable, satisfying fix, this spot gets it right every time.
7. Moe’s Southwest Grill
Moe’s Southwest Grill at Suffolk Community College is both a student staple and a solid choice for anyone craving quick, flavorful Tex-Mex. Walk in and you’re hit with the scent of fresh pico de gallo and that signature free chips and salsa—always a bright spot at lunchtime.
Moe’s shines with its “build-your-own” menu. You pick a base, add your choice of proteins and veggies, and finish with one of their tangy salsas. I found their staff patient and enthusiastic, ready to suggest the perfect salsa pairing for any order.
The burrito bowl with grilled chicken is hearty without being heavy—packed with rice, beans, and crisp lettuce. Their veggie and tofu tacos are ideal if you want a lighter option without losing flavor.
Moe’s never skimps on portions or personality, making every visit low-pressure and satisfying.
8. Adobo Mexican Grill
Adobo Mexican Grill in College Plaza is one of those places you stumble upon and wonder why you haven’t been coming all along. It delivers cheerful service and a clean, open space that feels relaxed even on busy nights.
The menu zeroes in on Mexican comfort food, but with a freshness that makes everything pop. My first visit left me hooked on their chicken enchiladas—rolled tight and covered in house-made verde sauce, they delivered both tang and warmth.
If you’re in the mood for handhelds, the grilled veggie tacos burst with flavor, showing real care in the prep. Pair them with Adobo’s homemade chips and salsa for a satisfying snack or side.
This spot is dependable and bright, a real go-to for quality Mexican in Selden.
9. On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina
On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina in Holtsville serves up Tex-Mex classics with an energetic, family-friendly twist. It’s the place I go when I want something lively—there’s always a cheerful buzz, whether dining in or picking up food to go.
From the moment the warm, crisp chips and tangy salsa arrive at your table, things are off to a good start. The chicken fajitas here really shine, delivered sizzling with charred veggies and fresh tortillas—perfect for creating your own bite every time.
The enchiladas, wrapped tight and topped with their signature sauce, pack both comfort and flavor. Portions are generous, so it’s a great spot for sharing or bringing home leftovers.
If you want a festive spot that still nails the details, this cantina covers all the bases.
10. Taco El Primo Restaurant
Taco El Primo Restaurant in Lake Ronkonkoma is the hidden gem you hope to stumble across but rarely do. It feels like a family-run kitchen—unpretentious, inviting, and fueled by care for each meal that leaves the kitchen. Both Spanish and English menus make it easy for anyone to order, and the staff is patient with questions.
During my visit, what impressed me was the freshness in every bite. The beef tacos are simple, yet packed with robust flavor and perfect for a quick lunch or casual dinner.
Try the chicken quesadilla if you want something comforting and generously portioned. The homemade salsas, which range from mild to hot, are bright and punchy.
It’s the kind of spot you’ll want to bring friends—or keep to yourself as your best-kept secret.
More Things to Try in Selden, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular Mexican restaurants in Selden, NY?
Local favorites include Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille, Chicos Tex Mex, and Viva Juan Mexican Restaurant. These places are loved for fresh flavors and consistent quality.
Are there any strictly vegetarian or vegan-friendly Mexican restaurants in Selden?
Many restaurants like Chipotle and Moe’s Southwest Grill have build-your-own options with vegetarian and vegan choices. Their menus feature items such as veggie burritos, salads, and fajitas.
Which Mexican restaurants in Selden offer delivery or takeout?
Most spots in Selden—such as Chipotle, Adobo Mexican Grill, Taco Bell, and Moe’s—offer both delivery and takeout for extra convenience.
Can I find halal-friendly options at Mexican restaurants in Selden?
Some restaurants offer vegetarian or fish-based dishes, which are suitable for halal diets. It’s best to ask about ingredient details when ordering.
What should I try for my first visit to a Mexican restaurant in Selden?
You can’t go wrong with classic chicken or veggie tacos, enchiladas, or a burrito bowl. If you like spice, ask about their house salsas for an extra kick.