Youngstown, OH, may not be the first place that comes to mind when you think of vibrant Mexican cuisine, but this city has a surprisingly rich tapestry of flavors to explore. Each restaurant tells a unique story, blending traditional recipes with the local palate. Perhaps you’ve strolled through its streets, a taco in hand from one of the hidden gems, wondering where the next culinary adventure lies. The aroma of fresh tortillas and spices wafts through the air, promising warmth and satisfaction with every bite.
As someone who has savored countless enchiladas and danced through the delightful chaos of salsa bars, I can assure you, Youngstown’s Mexican restaurants deliver more than just food; they create experiences. From family-run establishments that feel like a second home to lively spots that turn dinner into a fiesta, this guide will unveil the best dining destinations that this city offers. Dive in, and discover where your next favorite meal is waiting.
1. Tequila Jalisco
Tequila Jalisco offers a vibrant taste of Mexico nestled in Canfield. With a reputation for its authentic flavors and warm atmosphere, this restaurant stands out as a local favorite. The menu features a thoughtful range of options, including vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free selections, ensuring everyone finds something to enjoy.
During my visit, I was drawn to their chicken enchiladas, bursting with flavor and smothered in rich, homemade mole sauce. Each bite took me straight to the streets of Mexico. Pair that with their fresh guacamole, made to order, and you have a meal that feels both indulgent and comforting.
Tequila Jalisco is not just another restaurant; it’s an experience. Their dedication to quality and authenticity shines through every dish, making it a must-visit for anyone exploring Youngstown’s Mexican offerings.
2. El Vallarta Mexican Restaurant
El Vallarta Mexican Restaurant, located at 1738 Boardman Poland Rd, Boardman, OH, offers a delightful dining experience with its vegetarian-friendly options and versatile menu. Whether you’re in the mood for lunch or dinner, this spot provides both table service and takeout.
My visit to El Vallarta was memorable for its warm ambiance and authentic flavors. The staff’s friendliness and prompt service added to the overall enjoyable experience. What sets El Vallarta apart is its commitment to quality and traditional Mexican cuisine.
For an unforgettable meal, try the Chicken Fajitas or the Vegetarian Burrito. These dishes not only highlight the restaurant’s dedication to fresh ingredients but also reflect the rich culinary heritage of Mexican cuisine.
El Vallarta is a standout choice in Youngstown, OH, for anyone craving authentic and hearty Mexican food.
3. Senor Jalapeno
Located at 4055 Belmont Ave, Youngstown, OH, Senor Jalapeno greets diners with a lively atmosphere and an impressive menu that caters to all appetites. Whether you’re stopping by for lunch or dinner, this restaurant offers both table service and takeout, making it versatile for any occasion.
During my visit, I was pleasantly surprised by the flavorful street tacos, which packed a punch with each bite. The vibrant decor and upbeat music create a festive environment, drawing you in for an enjoyable experience. What makes Senor Jalapeno stand out is its knack for blending traditional Mexican recipes with a modern twist.
Don’t miss the Queso Fundido as an appetizer; its gooey, cheesy goodness is perfect for sharing. Pair it with their zesty guacamole for a truly satisfying meal. Senor Jalapeno captures the essence of Mexican cuisine, making it a must-visit spot in Youngstown.
4. Los Gallos
Situated at 9159 Market St, North Lima, OH, Los Gallos invites you to indulge in a delightful Mexican dining experience. With options for lunch and dinner, the restaurant provides both table service and takeout, making it a convenient choice for any occasion.
On my visit, the atmosphere was both lively and welcoming, and I was drawn to the enchiladas, which were bursting with flavor and drizzled in a delectable sauce. Los Gallos stands out for its commitment to authenticity, showcasing a diverse menu that resonates with Mexican culinary traditions.
For a standout dish, try the Carne Asada. The perfectly grilled steak coupled with fresh toppings exemplifies the quality and style of Los Gallos, making it a top choice in the Youngstown area.
5. El Cowboy Tex Mex Grill and Saloon
Located at 1739 S Raccoon Rd, Austintown, OH, El Cowboy Tex Mex Grill and Saloon blends Tex-Mex flair with a fun saloon vibe, offering diners a unique experience. Ideal for both lunch and dinner, the restaurant features comfortable seating and efficient table service.
During a recent visit, I loved the vibrant atmosphere, which was complemented by friendly staff. The standout dish for me was the Texas-sized Fajitas, served sizzling hot and bursting with flavor, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to hearty portions and bold flavors.
Don’t overlook their house-made salsa, which perfectly balances spice and freshness. El Cowboy is more than just a meal; it’s a lively celebration of Tex-Mex culture in Youngstown.
6. Casa Ramirez Mexican Restaurant
Conveniently located at 1578 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown, OH, Casa Ramirez Mexican Restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere perfect for both lunch and dinner. This restaurant shines with its authenticity and dedication to serving traditional Mexican cuisine that delights the senses.
On my visit, I was particularly impressed by the tacos al pastor, which were bursting with flavor thanks to perfectly marinated pork and fresh toppings. The vibrant colors on my plate mirrored the lively ambiance of the restaurant, making the meal even more enjoyable.
For a true taste of Casa Ramirez, don’t miss their chiles rellenos, a delightful combination of cheese-stuffed peppers in a flavorful sauce, reflecting their commitment to quality and tradition in every bite.
7. El Tapatio Mexican Restaurant & Cantina
Located at 3632 Belmont Ave, Youngstown, OH, El Tapatio Mexican Restaurant & Cantina offers an inviting atmosphere perfect for enjoying authentic Mexican cuisine. Formerly known as Fiesta Tapatia, it continues to impress with a diverse menu that caters to both lunch and dinner crowds.
During my recent visit, I was struck by the freshness of the ingredients and the vibrant presentation of each dish. The shrimp ceviche was particularly memorable, packed with flavor and a refreshing zing that perfectly complemented the warm ambiance.
For the ultimate dining experience, order the huevos rancheros for brunch or the classic mole poblano for dinner. Each dish reflects El Tapatio’s dedication to quality and authenticity, ensuring a satisfying meal for every palate.
8. Hot Head Burritos
Situated at 362 Boardman Poland Rd, Boardman, OH, Hot Head Burritos is the go-to spot for a quick yet delicious meal. This fast-casual restaurant specializes in customizable burritos that satisfy cravings without compromising on quality.
On my visit, I was pleasantly surprised by the variety of fresh ingredients available. The ability to personalize each burrito adds a fun twist to the dining experience. A standout choice is the grilled steak burrito, perfectly marinated and packed with zesty flavors that complement the fresh toppings.
If you’re in the mood for something lighter, definitely try their fresh guacamole as a side; it perfectly balances the heat of their sauces. Hot Head Burritos offers a delightful mix of speed and flavor, making it a must-try in Youngstown.
9. Los Gallos
Located in Boardman, Youngstown, OH, Los Gallos offers a warm, festive atmosphere perfect for family dinners or casual outings. Their vibrant décor and friendly staff make every visit feel like a mini getaway to Mexico. With a menu full of flavorful, vegetarian-friendly options, it’s easy to find something for everyone.
On my last visit, I ordered the Vegetarian Fajitas, sizzling hot and packed with bell peppers, onions, and tender zucchini—absolutely delicious and filling. The freshly made guacamole was a standout, creamy with just the right hint of lime.
What makes Los Gallos shine is their authentic flavor and consistent quality. For a must-try dish, go for the Cheese Enchiladas with rice and beans—a comforting classic with rich, savory sauce.
Perfect for lunch or dinner, with both table service and takeout options, Los Gallos is a true gem in Youngstown’s Mexican dining scene.
10. El Jalapeno Ii
Located at 4626 Mahoning Ave, Austintown, OH, El Jalapeno II serves up authentic Mexican cuisine with a modern twist. The restaurant’s focus on freshness extends not only to their food but also to their handcrafted margaritas, which are made with love and are a must-try.
During my visit, the warm atmosphere and friendly service made me feel right at home. The standout dish was the Chicken Mole, which was rich and flavorful, showcasing a blend of traditional spices that made each bite a delight.
Another highlight is the Street Corn, grilled to perfection and topped with cotija cheese and lime, complementing the bold flavors of the entrees. El Jalapeno II has truly mastered the balance of authenticity and creativity in every dish.
Whether you’re dining in for lunch or dinner, El Jalapeno II is a fantastic choice for anyone seeking delicious Mexican fare in Youngstown.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What are the best Mexican restaurants in Youngstown, OH?
A: Some of the top spots include Tequila Jalisco, El Vallarta Mexican Restaurant, and Senor Jalapeno. Each offers a unique twist on traditional dishes and a welcoming atmosphere.
Q: Do these restaurants offer vegetarian or vegan options?
A: Yes, many Mexican restaurants in Youngstown provide vegetarian and vegan options. Places like Los Gallos and El Tapatio are known for their diverse menus that cater to various dietary preferences.
Q: Can I get takeout from these Mexican restaurants?
A: Most of the popular Mexican restaurants, such as Casa Ramirez and El Jalapeno II, offer takeout, making it easy to enjoy your favorite dishes at home.
Q: Are there any gluten-free options available?
A: Many restaurants have gluten-free options. It’s a good idea to ask your server for suggestions, especially at places like Hot Head Burritos where customizing your meal is encouraged.
Q: What is the most popular dish to try at a Mexican restaurant?
A: A favorite among many diners is the fajitas, often served sizzling hot with a mix of marinated meat, peppers, and onions. Other popular choices include enchiladas and tacos.
Q: Do any Mexican restaurants in Youngstown have outdoor seating?
A: Yes, some places do offer outdoor seating during warmer months. Check with restaurants like El Cowboy Tex Mex Grill and Saloon for their outdoor dining options.
Q: What time do Mexican restaurants in Youngstown open?
A: Opening times vary by location, but many Mexican restaurants typically open for lunch around 11 AM and stay open until late evening, often around 10 PM. Always check directly with the restaurant for specific hours.