17 Irresistible Sugar Cream Pie Recipes for Any Occasion

Are you looking for a delicious and easy dessert recipe? I am offering you 17 simple Sugar Cream Pie recipes that are perfect for any occasion.

Discover the timeless charm of Sugar Cream Pie, a classic dessert that never goes out of style. Its rich, creamy filling and buttery crust create a comforting treat that feels like a warm hug. Over the years, I’ve found that this pie is perfect for any occasion, from family dinners to cozy weekends at home.

With just a few simple ingredients, you can easily whip up this delightful pie. I’ve learned that the secret is in the balanced sweetness and smooth texture, which make every bite irresistible. Whether you’re an experienced baker or trying your hand at pie-making, this recipe will boost your confidence.

Imagine the aroma of cinnamon and vanilla filling your kitchen as it bakes. Once chilled, this nostalgic dessert will have everyone asking for more—no fancy techniques needed. Dive into the world of authentic Indiana tradition with every slice you serve.

1. Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie

Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie is a deliciously creamy dessert that combines sweet sugar and rich cream in a simple, fuss-free way. Just stir a few ingredients together, bake everything in the crust at once, and you’ll have a smooth, luscious pie with no worries about lumps or cracks!

Read the Recipe: Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie

2. Sugar Cream Pie

This Sugar Cream Pie is a dreamy dessert where the filling is cooked until thick and creamy using butter, half-and-half, sugar, and cornstarch. Once poured into a baked pie crust, it gets a quick broil with a butter and cinnamon topping, then chills for at least an hour to set into a luscious, sweet treat everyone will ask for!

Read the Recipe: Sugar Cream Pie

3. Old Fashioned Sugar Cream Pie

Savor the classic charm of Old Fashioned Sugar Cream Pie, a delightful treat with a buttery crust and rich vanilla custard that’s topped with a sprinkle of cinnamon sugar. This easy-to-make dessert uses simple pantry staples and is perfect for holidays, potlucks, or any special occasion — just bake, cool, and enjoy the creamy, sweet magic that everyone will love!

Read the Recipe: Old Fashioned Sugar Cream Pie

4. Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie [stateofdinner.com]

Imagine a creamy, sweet pie that tastes just like a crisp Snickerdoodle cookie—that’s what makes Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie so delightful! It’s quick and simple to make, with a smooth custard filled with vanilla and topped with a caramelized cinnamon-sugar layer, all finished in just minutes.

Read the Recipe: Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie [stateofdinner.com]

5. Sugar Cream Pie (The Hoosier Pie)

This Sugar Cream Pie, a beloved Hoosier classic, is a rich, creamy, and totally decadent dessert that’s simple to make with just a few pantry staples like sugar, cream, butter, and nutmeg. Bake it in a preheated oven until warm and heavenly—perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth with a taste of Indiana tradition!

Read the Recipe: Sugar Cream Pie (The Hoosier Pie)

6. Sugar Cream Pie [www.tasteofhome.com]

This sweet, custardy Sugar Cream Pie is a delightful Indiana classic that features a rich filling of sugar, vanilla, and a hint of cinnamon, all nestled in a flaky, buttery pie crust. With simple ingredients and easy steps, you’ll have this comfortable and cozy dessert ready in just over an hour—perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth!

Read the Recipe: Sugar Cream Pie [www.tasteofhome.com]

7. Sugar Cream Pie [peartreekitchen.com]

Sugar Cream Pie is a delicious, no-fail vintage treat from Indiana, made with a creamy, egg-free custard topped with cinnamon inside a flaky pie crust. Simply combine milk, sugar, cornstarch, butter, and vanilla, cook until thickened, pour into a baked crust, sprinkle with cinnamon, and chill until set for a comforting dessert that’s easy to enjoy!

Read the Recipe: Sugar Cream Pie [peartreekitchen.com]

8. Old-Fashioned Sugar Cream Pie

This Old-Fashioned Sugar Cream Pie is a deliciously creamy custard dessert with a buttery homemade crust and a crackling cinnamon sugar topping that adds a perfect sweet crunch. Simply cook the custard filling gently on the stove, pour it into a pre-baked pie crust, and finish with a quick bake under the broiler to caramelize the topping—creating a rich, smooth pie that’s simply irresistible!

Read the Recipe: Old-Fashioned Sugar Cream Pie

9. Sugar Cream Pie Recipe

This Sugar Cream Pie is a creamy, sweet treat with a delightful hint of spice from cinnamon and nutmeg on top, all sitting in a flaky pie crust. It’s super easy to make with common ingredients like heavy cream, sugar, and vanilla, and can be prepared ahead for any special occasion!

Read the Recipe: Sugar Cream Pie Recipe

10. Sugar Cream Pie [www.crazyforcrust.com]

This Sugar Cream Pie is a delightful, easy dessert with a rich, creamy custard filling topped with a sprinkle of cinnamon and nutmeg. Simply fill a partially baked crust with a mixture of sugar, cornstarch, half and half, and butter, then bake until set and bubbly for a comforting, nostalgic treat!

Read the Recipe: Sugar Cream Pie [www.crazyforcrust.com]

11. Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie [www.askchefdennis.com]

Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie is a rich, creamy dessert with a smooth custard-like filling made from heavy cream, butter, sugar, and cornstarch that’s cooked until thick and silky. Just pour this luscious mixture into a flaky pie crust, bake until golden, and enjoy a sweet, comforting treat straight from Indiana’s classic recipes!

Read the Recipe: Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie [www.askchefdennis.com]

12. Sugar Cream Pie [www.averiecooks.com]

This easy Sugar Cream Pie combines a creamy, custard-like filling with a flaky pie crust, topped with a sprinkle of cinnamon for that perfect finishing touch. Simply bake the crust, whisk together the warm filling, pour it in, bake again, and chill overnight for a deliciously comforting dessert that’s ready to enjoy!

Read the Recipe: Sugar Cream Pie [www.averiecooks.com]

13. Indiana Sugar Cream Pie

Indiana Sugar Cream Pie features a buttery crust filled with a rich vanilla custard made from milk, cream, sugar, and a touch of vanilla. Simply roll out the dough, fill it with the creamy mixture, and bake until golden for a classic, irresistible dessert!

Read the Recipe: Indiana Sugar Cream Pie

14. Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie [www.farmwifecooks.com]

Get ready to enjoy a classic Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie, a sweet family favorite with a rich, pudding-like filling that’s made on the stove. Bake a pre-made pie shell, then whisk together butter, scalded milk, sugar, cornstarch, salt, and vanilla on the stove until thickened, pour it into the shell, and sprinkle with nutmeg and cinnamon before letting it cool.

Read the Recipe: Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie [www.farmwifecooks.com]

15. Sugar Cream Pie [bakedinaz.com]

Imagine savoring a creamy, buttery pie with a simple yet irresistible flavor, topped with a sprinkle of cinnamon and nutmeg for a perfect finish. Made with just a few basic ingredients like sugar, butter, and cream, this Sugar Cream Pie delivers a custard-like texture that’s both nostalgic and delightful!

Read the Recipe: Sugar Cream Pie [bakedinaz.com]

16. Sugar Cream Pie [thedomesticrebel.com]

This delicious Sugar Cream Pie features a creamy, vanilla-flavored custard sitting atop a flaky, buttery crust dusted with cinnamon sugar, making it rich and irresistible. It’s an easy, comforting dessert that will satisfy your sweet tooth and leave you craving more—perfect to bake when you want something sinfully sweet and utterly satisfying.

Read the Recipe: Sugar Cream Pie [thedomesticrebel.com]

17. Sugar Cream Pie Recipe [lilluna.com]

Get ready to enjoy a rich, creamy sugar cream pie made with simple pantry ingredients and no eggs! Just blind bake the crust, whisk together sugar, cornstarch, and milk until thickened, then stir in butter and vanilla before pouring it into the baked shell, sprinkle with cinnamon sugar, and chill for a few hours to reveal a dreamy, nostalgic dessert.

Read the Recipe: Sugar Cream Pie Recipe [lilluna.com]